K.M.
I have been using Loreal Paris Voluminous Waterproof.
I have been using the same mascara for years, and refuse to go with anything else, it doesnt flake or smudge. And because it is waterproof and a little harder to get off I use the Neutrogena towlette make up removers, they take off the mascara no problem and are not in the slightest oily.