Twins: One Eats Everything, the Other NOTHING!

Updated on March 28, 2008
M.M. asks from Groveland, FL
18 answers

I am beginning to become frustrated with one of my boys. I have one who eats just about anything in front of him or that's not nailed down! The other has always been the lighter eater. He never has eaten as much as his brother including the amount of formula in their bottles. Now, even if I mashed all his food together (which is what I've done for both over the past 6 months or so) he gives me a realy hard time eating it. So, lately, I've been using the little individual things of applesauce and diguising his food with that. I figured it worked with them when I was giving them cereal and stuff, why not now. He sucks off the applesauce or sometimes I've used yogurt, and spits out the meat, vegetables and usually potatoes.

I don't know what to do anymore because I am constantly trying to make something else that I think he'll eat. I want him to be eat the same food as his brother. I am not running a restaurant!LOL However, I'm getting so tired of fighting with him and I know since he isn't eating a well-balanced dinner like he used to, he's not getting full and I think that is why he wakes up during the night sometimes 2 or 3 times.

Any suggestions or advice of those of you who have gone through this....I would greatly appreciate them!! I want my boys to be healthy and I'm concerned if he doesn't start eating a little better, his health will be affected.

Thanks,
M.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.L.

answers from Jacksonville on

I have twin boys who are the same way, one is just a better eater. I cut back his formula and he started eating a little better but still not as good as his brother. Here's the thing....everything I have read and everyone I have talked too says not to worry. They will eat when they are hungry. I give my boys the same food for all of their meals, sometimes he likes it and sometimes he doesn't, if he doesn't like it I don't try to force it or trick him, I just try a few times and then that's it I'm done and sometimes he is too. Then he eats more the next time I go to feed him. I think having consistant meal times is important as well as no juice or snacking in between meals. I wouldn't get to worked up over it. If he's happy and seems healthy than he must be getting the nutrition he needs. I think he will grow out of it soon enough.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.N.

answers from Gainesville on

I've had issues with food with all three of mine, on and off -- both eating a lot and not eating at all, depending on the kid and the time. I like Brazelton's advice and think it's important to not make too big a deal out of it (so long as they eat within certain bounds).

I make regular meals at regular times. If they don't like what we're having, they can have plain bread and water. Usually they eat enough in reasonable healthy parameters and it balances out. I offer vegies and fruit snacks everyday and treat are only offered after a meal is properly consumed, but it's not big deal. If they didn't want to eat, they must not want a treat!

Good luck!

L. D.
mom of three

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.S.

answers from Jacksonville on

I don't think that kids will ever purposely starve. I am the mother of "the world's pickiest eater"...If he's gaining weight and your pediatrician doesn't think there is anything wrong & you give him a multivitamin supplement....I think you just don't worry. You cannot force feed a child. (my son, the picky eater, is 19, by the way. He looks pretty healthy to me). I "induced" his pickyness (I think) by fixing what he would eat (mac & cheese, fish sticks, chicken nuggets) while I was on a high protein/lo carb diet (and my husband worked most evenings). At times, I wish I'd put the broiled chicken/salad/broccoli in front of my son every night. Maybe because of my "indulgence", he has been a picky eater all his life. So was I. But I learned to eat vegetables in college & love them now. Even my son just called us & said he ate some Cuban food on spring break in S.Florida...and HE LIKED IT! This is the same child who lived on buttered bread & milk for lunch his entire 3 year old year in preschool (his teacher told me she felt like a failure because that's all he would eat). Just put healthy food in front of your son & repeat "children will not purposely starve themselves"....I really regret "running a restaurant" when my son was forming his eating habits...you will not "win" this fight, but you can prevail if you are patient. He will eat when he is hungry....you may just have to "wait that out". Best of luck to you....you're in my prayers.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.U.

answers from Orlando on

M.,
Congratulations on being the mother of twins. That obviously has many aspects that us mother's of singles never think about. However, the eating problem seems to be universally frustrating. It is hard. I have two events to share from my young mothering years.
First, I had a daughter who would hardly eat. Finally, I asked my chiropractor about it. He adjusted her and she began eating. She did not become a huge eater as a child, but immediately she began to eat more and enjoy it more. It seems that little adjustment relieved pressure on some part of her digestive tract.

My neighbor had a daughter who would balk at eating, so the mother let her down from the table and put her food in the fridge. If her daughter wanted to eat later, she got out the food that she had refused to eat. When she was hungry enough, she would eat. She learned to eat whatever her mother served. It worked for her.

Also, I have an extreme example of not finding a solution while the child is young. A few years ago, I worked with a teacher who had a little boy who would not eat. By the time he was in kindergarten, he had no interest in food at all and was feed with a feeding tube, even though he was capable of eating. In other words, this mom made an invalid out of her son because she did not keep at it till she found a solution. Don't give up.

I hope you can find something that works soon because part of this could become a behavior issue whereby he learns how to use it to control you. Remember that you are not only the kind and caring and loving mom, but you are the in charge mom.
Perhaps this does not describe you at all, but in today's society, children have often been put in such positions of privilege that they are not learning the safe and happy and wise ways of simple obedience which ultimately leads to a happier child and a more well functioning adult.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.H.

answers from Fort Walton Beach on

One of my buys wouldn't each much of what I offered either when he was a baby. Now he is a strong, healthy 15 year old and he's never been unhealthy as a result of his picky eating. He's still a picky eater, but boy can he EAT!! He did wake up often if he didn't eat well through the day, just like your son, so I found something he WOULD eat, (oatmeal, yogurt, baby cereal mixed with smashed bananas...) and fed him right before bed. I even fed him the baby cereal well after he turned one because I knew he would eat it and I knew it was a great source of nutrition. I continued to only offer him the foods we all ate at meals and snacks and when he didn't eat `it, I just went on with life. I didn't offer anything special at those times and he DID (eventually) start to try some other things, but he still didn't eat much. That's ewhy I fed him right before bed. I wanted him to sleep well (which is just as important to development as eating), so I did what I could to accomplish that.
I can understand you not wanting to make something special for him at meals, but to save your worry, try feeding him something filling (and nutritious) at bedtime. I hope this helps you...
~C.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.S.

answers from Orlando on

I have one that is now 12yrs and he never ate anything.Other than tenders,waffles or creamcheese.To this day he still only eats the same type of foods.NO MEAT at all NO VEGGIES, NO FRUIT.And he has never been sick.On the other hand I have a 11yr old that eats everything and will try anything, who is always sick.Who knew All I can tell you is that our Doctor said if he gets hungry he will eat...Just a note my 12yr old is 5'5 125lbs with a size 12 foot.and healthy as a horse....

about myself working, married with 3 kids 18,12,11.
H.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.C.

answers from Daytona Beach on

Sometimes their bodies just don't need the amount of fuel we think it does. My 5th child ate like a horse until she was 2 or 3 and then it stopped. She didn't get picky just was never particularly hungry. Too busy to stop. In the last month that child eats like a horse and has gained 8lbs. You just have to follow their cues. They will not starve themselves.. their natural instinct is to eat when hungry.

My 3rd child was very picky. There were only 5 foods she would eat. So I put out a variety of foods and let her pick and choose (nothing unhealthy in the choice). I'm not saying make seperate meals but rather always have available a good variety. When she was 3, I told her the new rule of the house was that everyone was must take a "hello" bite of food. No matter what's on the plate we must take one bite of each food. Don't have to eat it..just one bite. She quickly discovered that she liked many more foods than just those 5 she'd been eating. LOL

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.E.

answers from Panama City on

TOTAL GUESS: wHICHWAS BORN LARGER. MAYBE THE HABIT STARTED PREBIRTH, ONE GOT MORE TWINS ARE INDIVIDUALS EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE BORN TO GETHER/

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.R.

answers from Orlando on

Hi M.,My name is S. I am a mother of twin boys, there age is 22 years. I also am a grandmother of a 27 month old grandson. When my boys were that age I went through the same thing, it is the same way to this day. Give them a good daily vitamin. For the one that won't eat, adding the sweet stuff is a no no. My grandson is a poor eater like his Dad. The Dr. put him on a high fat diet, chicken nuggets, french fries, ect... ect.... for the vegtables part good luck, try the fruit and vegtables V8 drinks it seems to work for my grandson. My boy's hardley ever went to the Dr. and I can't even remember the last time they went, they are both very healthy adults. There tast buds will change as the years past by. My twin who ate nothing, eats raw oysters, go figure.. If you are not a member of the Mother Of Twins Club. (M.O.T.C.) Join it, it is a wonderful club and so very helpful look in the yellow pages in your local phone book Good luck and keep in touch.
TWINSERLEY S.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.K.

answers from Jacksonville on

I would say that as long as he is gaining weight then I would not worry how much he eats. He might not eat as much as his brother and the other one might go through the same thing down the road. Since he is almost two, sometimes kids go through a period where they don't eat much. You will notice pretty soon that he will be eating like a champ again. As long as he is eating something then he is not going to starve. Just check to make sure he is not sick, otherwise I would not worry.

I hope this helps.

Jennifer

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.A.

answers from Daytona Beach on

well, put exactly the same thing on each plate.
when they clean their plate, they get a surprise.
the surprise can be dessert or it can be a trip to the park. the one who finishes his plate or at least eats
some of each thing, gets to go to the park, the other cannot go. Let them choose or take turns picking what they want to do if they finish their meal. take away the applesauce and let that be the dessert maybe. and if he's hungry later, don't feed him if he didnt' finish his meal. You can reheat up his leftovers maybe. Don't force feed them though. and just because they're twins doesn't mean they like the same things. Though at 20 mos, I don't think they have a choice yet in their thinking. who knows. good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.H.

answers from Tallahassee on

I also have twins and have similar issues. My twins are now 3 and one still eats pretty much anything, and the other is still very picky. I do not make separate meals for my family of 6. I make sure there is something everyone will eat a little of and I am okay if they don't finish their plates. When dinner is over, if my picky ones are hungry, they can eat what is left on their plates. I don't offer snacks if they don't eat their dinner.

My suggestion is not to worry about how much one eats over the other. As long as they are on the growth charts and developing normally you don't need to worry. You don't want to create food issues when there really aren't any. He just doesn't eat as much as the other one. No big deal. As long as you are providing healthy food choices when he does eat, I don't think you should worry.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.H.

answers from Orlando on

Hello M.!

Well we all know that while twins share a lot of things they dont always share preferences! If it were me i would try and suppliment with ensure or something, to make sure he is getting what he needs, and still try to impliment reg food as much as possible! Hope that helps! Have a wonderful day!

L.
www.TheMomTeam.com/lajeanhuntley

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.H.

answers from Fort Walton Beach on

Hi M.,

You'll get plenty of advise on things to try for them, so excuse me if I jump to the next step.

You didn't say if they were identical or fraternal twins. I know I'm getting "medical" but if they are fraternal twins with blood types they will want different things. Different blood types are nourished by different type foods. That's why you might have one kid that is a meat eater and one that loves salads. If they do have a different type, google blood type diet and see what foods they have in common.

Hope this helps, whether with these young men or your next batch :)

God bless!

M.

P.S. I agree with Janie above. Chiropractic will help. Also I have a friend whose 5 year old is 4 feet tall, and 33 pounds. The doctors told her he was just a fussy eater. She was at her wits in and I suggested detoxing. She put him on a product called Fiberwise and he has gained 4 pounds in two weeks...

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.W.

answers from Orlando on

First at 20 months--they are normally VERY PICKY. So your son that eats everything is actually the one that is not in the norm of toddler eating.
Don't worry about tricks and disguises. Give you toddlers a healthy meal with a protein, veggie, fruit and starch and let them decide what they will eat.
Also, cut back on snacks during the day--don't let him graze. My son is much more prone to try new things when he hasn't been eating all afternoon.
I try to make one thing for the whole family for dinner, but that doesn't always work out--so I at least get one thing on my toddlers plate that he has had a history of eating--for example, if we are having pasta, we all get pasta, my husband and i get a salad, but my toddler will also get peas or carrots--since those are two veggies i know he will eat.I also put a very small amount of salad on his plate (or whatever it is we are having) and he may or may not try it.
He also LOVES most fruit, so he doesn't get his fruit until he eats his veggie or tries it if it's something new or something he hasn't liked it the past.
To get him to try something we take the gradual approach:
look at it
touch it
kiss it
put it in your mouth (baby bite)
Sometimes he makes it this far and likes it and sometimes he spits it out. LOL
Anyways, don't beat yourself up over it, this really is the pickiest of age. I alway tried to make the basics for breakfast and lunch which I know he'll eat so if he doesn't eat too much at dinner, I'm not worried.
My friend also gave me this awesome book that really gives great advice and perspective on feeding your children...
check it out of you get the chance:
Child of Mine: Feeding with Love and Good Sense by Ellyn Satter.http://www.amazon.com/Child-Mine-Feeding-Love-Sense/dp/09...

Anyways--you are right, you are not a restaurant--as a parent it is your job to give your child healthy choices to eat--it is their job to decide if they are going to eat it and how much of it they are going to eat!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.B.

answers from Tallahassee on

Thank goodness we have supplements and don't have to even worry about this any more! Get him those children's drinks with all of the nutrition and use that. Also, give them a variety of finger foods and vegetables to try (like easy to prepare toddler foods), and let him eat what he wants and don't worry about it. Also, I always gave my children vitamins. Life is stressful enough, don't stress over this. If you come across something nutritious he really likes, let him eat a lot of it and serve it more often. Everyone's right, children really won't let themselves starve, but you need the vitamins in them somehow.
Also, maybe don't mix stuff in with the applesauce - he may just start to hate applesauce! :)

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.W.

answers from Orlando on

To me, it sounds as if somebody's working you, Mom. It's a control issue. He's 20 months old!!.. His health will not suffer if he doesn't get his meat and potatoes everyday for a week or so. Lighten up immediately and I bet you withi a week or so he will come around. He is fighting you for control. If you push it you will constantly have food battles. With all the food issues these days (obesity, overeating, bulimia, anorexia) is food the thing you want to start fighting over? FYI None of my boys (and there are 4 of them) will eat potatoes; while Dad and I love potatoes. I let it go. Pick your battles. Don't make food one of them.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.B.

answers from Orlando on

HI M.,
it might be a "texture" thing or just picky as you said! I have five, a set of twins....same thing.....three eat GREAT, anything and everything....the other, Im a "short order cook" most nights....because he takes issue with texture, before ever even tasting! but as they grow up and out of these things...its ok...its a pain...and creativity has to kick in and good vitamins are key (for him especially)! i just made sure that he wasnt snacking so that he developed a true/good hunger! so eventually, he ate out of hunger/necessity...where the others got snacks, etc..because they had good appetites...I am and was very strict with him....especially as he got older and we could 'talk'..so he understood...you do this, I will do this and let you eat this, etc...so you are in charge...stick with things that he does like and develop the habit! it is a habit...we think the "same ole" is boring, some kids like the "same ole" and don't want change... I have one!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions