S.L. asks from Surprise, NE on March 06, 2008
6 Year Old Attitude
Is it just me, or do girls get mouthy at 6? Just out of the blue my daughter has started talking back, doesn't want to help around the house and uses the "I HATE YOU" to her brothers and sometimes me. She has never said it to Dad, but he can be a softy at time.
Do you have any suggestions?
THANK YOU
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
R.B. answers from Duluth on March 07, 2008
My husband and I also have a Sassy Six year old girl. We do what they do on the Nanny. We only had to do it for a month and she was a changed girl. We would have two money jars, one for us and one for her. When she made a snotty comment or had a crying fit she would have to give us money. When she got enough money she got to buy a toy that she picked out and if she wanted something and didn't have enough money we would tell her how she needed to save more money. We rewarded her with money in her jar when she was helpful and said please and thank you. IT REALLY WORKED FOR US!!! Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
L.G. answers from Iowa City on March 07, 2008
Thank you for posting this. My 6 year old is the same way. For days now, she has said she hates me and wishes I was dead anytime she doesn't get her way. She puts her nose up in the air and stomps around. I was in shock at first but it is only getting worse despite losing privledges and toys every time. It doesn't seem to bother her. :(
More Answers
A.H. answers from Sioux Falls on March 06, 2008
I have a seven year old son and he has been saying "I hate you" and been really defiant for the last year. So it is not only girls. My sister is also seven and she has been this way for a year now too.
In our family we combat it by setting boundaries and sticking to them. When we say something we mean it and if our rules are not followed our son loses something... tv or video games or his favorite toy. We start with him losing one item for a day and each time he is mean or doesn't listen one more thing goes. And when he says he hates us we respond with "I understand you don't like what is happening, we are giving you choices it is up to you what happens but no matter what we love you." It is our sons choice how much trouble he gets in, he can lose one thing or he can lose everything it is up to him. We take things one at a time but with love and ultimately the decision's his. And once in a while he can earn things back, for instance vacuuming the house will earn one toy back (not tv or video games though, he loves them too much and that would make it not a punishment). And that only happens if he has calmed down and apologized, after we have a nice long talk on his behavior.
Consistency and lots of love, is what is working for us.
That's my thoughts
A.
ps. One of the rules in our house is to treat others with respect so that means not saying mean things, so things can be taken away for doing that as well
1 mom found this helpful
R.B. answers from Duluth on March 07, 2008
My husband and I also have a Sassy Six year old girl. We do what they do on the Nanny. We only had to do it for a month and she was a changed girl. We would have two money jars, one for us and one for her. When she made a snotty comment or had a crying fit she would have to give us money. When she got enough money she got to buy a toy that she picked out and if she wanted something and didn't have enough money we would tell her how she needed to save more money. We rewarded her with money in her jar when she was helpful and said please and thank you. IT REALLY WORKED FOR US!!! Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
L.W. answers from Minneapolis on March 07, 2008
Yes, this is normal. What I did (and am still working through) with my now 7-y-o is to remind her of the good side of things, of why she must do x, y, or z, and the benefits of doing so. I then encourage mine to think of the good parts of doing whatever, then reward her with a break where she can do something SHE wants to do.
When she says "I hate you," I always say "Well, I still love you." Of course back when that word showed up in her vocabulary, she and I had a talk about the fact that hate means you wish that person would "go away forever" and that people have died because of hate. That last bit might not be good for all children, but it helped mine, along with "I know you're angry right now, but I think you'll feel better about me later."
A.M. answers from Minneapolis on March 06, 2008
sadly I don't have any good advice for what to do. I just wanted to stand in your corner with you. My 5 yr old girl is very sassy and bossy lately. If I tell her that I want her to turn off the game she is playing and get ready for bed she starts in with the "but I'm just doing *whatever*" or "what if I want to do *fill in blank*"
What if I want you to get ready for bed, honey? I guess that means nothing.
she hasn't used the 'hate you' card, yet. but I'm waiting as I'm sure that day will come soon enough.
It must be a girl thing, I remember my sisters saying that.
K.L. answers from Bismarck on March 07, 2008
Hey S.--it's not you, or her siblings, or your job, so don't beat yourself up with a guilt trip. I stay home and my daughter receives most, if not all of my attention, and we still deal with the same type of behaviors. Our daughter is 3--so when I read your post, I thought, "at 6? you've got a late bloomer!" :) A few months back, our 3yr old would respond to reprimands with a screaming, "DON'T KILL ME!" And of course, hubby and I were completely beside ourselves. It was so bazaar, neither one of us knew how to respond to that--except perhaps figure which movie it was she heard it from and disown it--honestly, I think it was the Lion King. It passed.
You could try, when your 6yr old has calmed, or at a time that is completely outside of the tantrums, just having a conversation about love/hate and using hurtful words. And then, when she becomes angry, try and reinforce the conversation. Have everyone involved make sure their response includes something like, "but I still love you." And just keep reinforcing positive words/behavior at every chance--and until then just don't take her out in public (Just Kidding!)
L.G. answers from Iowa City on March 07, 2008
Thank you for posting this. My 6 year old is the same way. For days now, she has said she hates me and wishes I was dead anytime she doesn't get her way. She puts her nose up in the air and stomps around. I was in shock at first but it is only getting worse despite losing privledges and toys every time. It doesn't seem to bother her. :(
A.R. answers from Minneapolis on March 07, 2008
Is it attitude or anger S.? A six year old girl with two brothers and a mom who works three jobs is probably mad about the limited mommy time she gets. I am guessing her three year old brother requires more attention than anyone else and that her 8 year old brother takes his anger out on her for convenience.
You may want to slow down a little and realize that your full time job is actually being a mom. Are you devoting 40 hours a week to it? At a minimum, cut back on your firefighting and EMT work and spend more time with your daughter - she wants to hold hands, cuddle and talk. This is all girls really want. When they don't get it, they get mad.
B.H. answers from Minneapolis on March 06, 2008
My 6year old daughter told my best friend she's a "F-ing Btch"
She got soap in the mouth for that one.
My daughter has a horrible mouth on her, but to be honest I know exactly where it comes from-ME! I have the worst cuss mouth and attitude sometimes myself and have realized I'm the prime problem and example. I've been trying to set a better example in my house. I've decided to go back to church and have my daughter in Sunday school again too. That and the kids at school and on the school bus she picks up all sorts of junk. Then they're at the age of testing what they can say and not say so you have to nip it right away.
My daughter said things like :
"Mom, your stupid"
"Your the meanest mom in the world"
"You don't love me"
I look at her and tell her I have the worst daughter in the whole world how could she say that about me after I've done this and that for her. Then she'll get teary eyed and say I'm sorry mommy your not really.
Email