P.J. asks from Toppenish, WA on November 19, 2008
Angry Almost Pre Teen
how do u talk to a child who can make an arguement out of anything from whose toy is whose to not going to rm and evry time u talk 2 child its i dont have to listen f you u b ur not my boss &picking fights with others just because and then says they dident do anything wrong evryone else is a lier and uses her sibling as a justification to start the arguments . it doesent stop until evryone is in tears
Featured Answers
V.J. answers from Portland on November 20, 2008
P.:
There is a program called "Total Transformation" that will correct bad attitudes almost over night. Give them a call at 1-800-259-1840. I've recommended them to other parents and they said it worked like a miracle.
Good luck,
V. J.
1 mom found this helpful
J.M. answers from Seattle on November 20, 2008
Seems like he or she may be mildly depressed and this is its way of expressing itself. Besides counseling, which I think could be a good outlet, is the child getting a good balanced diet and exercise? The dark winter days really affect some people.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
M.C. answers from Portland on November 20, 2008
Greetings Patsy, The problem you describe can be fixed by your (and Dad's?) approach to your daughter. Choose a time when she is not throwing a fit or upset at something. Sit down with her and tell her that you love her and you know she loves you, and that she's probably just as tired of fighting as you are. Tell her you won't be fighting any more. Let her know that you expect her to do what she's told, when she's told. You tell her all of this in a calm, respectful, loving manner...not with an asking tone and not with an aggressive tone. Then let her know that when she doesn't respect your expectations there will be a consequence. You (and Dad if there's one in the picture) need to decide on the consequences ahead of time. Example: If I tell you to pick up your things in the living room and you don't do it in a 'reasonable' (for a teenager) amount of time, then those things will go in a box, locked in a closet and you won't get them back til you prove you can pick your things up. If you yell or swear at me, you will go to your room for a half hour (no tv or phone...and time doesn't start til she calms down).
Remind her how precious she is to you, and that she is a cherished part of this family...and as such she has her own responsibilities too...such as picking up after herself and acting like a human being (no swearing and yelling).
Your job--no matter how mad you get, don't yell at her, don't ever call her names. Just get her to her room, or go to another room yourself. Don't engage in her adolescent level of arguing. You are the boss. Don't argue with her. Set the expectation and enforce it with consequences. And shower her with love, and notice what she does well and right.
Good luck.
4 moms found this helpful
L.B. answers from Portland on November 20, 2008
P.,
I've been reading a book called, "How to Hug a Porcupine: Negotiating the Prickly Points of the Tween Years" by Julia A. Ross, and it is helping me understand my budding teen's often difficult behaviors. My son is my only child whichhas made this change from the sweet-natured kid he was in elementary school to the (sometimes) venomous, parent-baiting jerk all the harder because we have always been so close. The book talks about the physical, emotional and developmental changes middle school age kids face, and how families can get through the transition with some sanity and dignity intact. I highly recommend it.
4 moms found this helpful
P.G. answers from Seattle on November 20, 2008
I recommend the book " Parenting with Love and Logic for Teens" (or the title is really close to that). It has so many helpful ideas and insights. Also, I just attended a parenting seminar, and the presenter offers a free one hour consultation for parent/family coaching, I thought she was really good. Here is her info:
Stacey Witte
Family Matters
____@____.com
###-###-####
3 moms found this helpful
M.P. answers from Portland on November 21, 2008
I fell into arguing with my daughter and then my granddaughter. someone reminded me to "never argue with a child." When an adult argues with a child they are giving the child their own power. As a parent you are in charge. When you argue you've made yourself equal to the child. Reembering this helped me to stay quiet when I felt like giving back an answer.
I've found that not paying any attention to the child who wants to argue helps a lot. Tell them what you want done and in what time frame. Then turn off your hearing. Go to another room if you have to. IF what you've asked them to do is not done calmly enforce a consequence.
It is important to tell your child what you're going to do. As another mother said, choose a time when you're both calm. Stop the discussion if she wants to argue. If she continues to argue, leave the room. IF she doesn't come to you to ask about your plan then administer the consequence. This may get her attention causing her to wonder what is going on and you can then have that conversation.
For some children including them in a discussion on howto stop the arguing helps them to follow the plan. However, it sounds to me that your daughter is too angry to be able to have a calm discussion.
I would get her involved in counseling to find where the anger is coming from and how both of you can deal with it. A counselor may be able to help her process her anger so that she has less.
I suspect the core reason for her arguing is anger and without addressing the anger changing her behavior will be difficult. So....don't work on changing her behavior. Work on changing your reaction. Put yourself back in control. She's in control now. DO NOT ARGUE WITH A CHILD.
When my granddaughter is calm I do listen
to her side of the situation and sometimes I find that she has a good reason to suggest something else. But if she's emotional (tears or argumentative) I try very hard to not respond. It's not easy.
2 moms found this helpful
L.K. answers from Portland on November 21, 2008
I love Margie C's response!!
How can you find balance AND let her know you cherish her?? That's so important!
A few years ago I participated in a descussion group at our church on the '5 love languages' books by Gary Chapman: "5 Love Languages of children" & "5 L L of teenagers!"
By ~ 5 pr 6 years old, you can ID a child's love language - how do they show you love? Do they give you drawings & other little gifts? Do they LOVE to cuddle? Which love language tells them YOU love THEM? We all need all 5, but usually one is 'most meaningful.'
Of course you can give consequences, & stick to them! & the time to set guidelines for behavior - & consequences in later teen years is NOW!!
The Languages he's IDed are: Quality time, words of appreciation, touch, gifts, & service.
One of the gals in the group - a social worker (!) realized that her teen son's language was 'words of appreciation,' & every time he did something around the house, she criticized him!
-- He'd prepare the recycling, but would forget to do the cans --
"Oh! You didn't do the cans!!"
-- he'd mow the lawn (they're in the country - so BIG lawn)
"Oh! You forgot to mow under the trees!! The rest looks good, . . . "
So she talked with him about it, & asked "would it work better for you if I thanked you for doing the job, & when it's time to do it again, reminded you "Please be sure & get the cans!"?" & he thought that was awesome, & agreed it was tough to work hard on something, & feel she just picked on him for not doing it 'right!' Over the last couple of years, she has commented on how he has done more arround the house, & much more willingly.
During the teen years it can get harder to show affection - examples in the book inc. a kid feeling unloved because his folks came to all his games (quality time) when he was in grade school, but now they rarely make it! I have a dance teacher in her 60s, who still remembers that her mother (a concert pianist) NEVER came to see her dance - even when she was dancing professionally.
Appropriate, loving touch is especially important during the teen years, & from both parents. That may change; a biff on the shoulder rather than a hug, a gentle hand on the arm . . . & Chapman comments on girls needing their dads (appropriatly, again!) to touch them & not avoid them.
I rhighly recommend these books to any parents - they have a copy of the children's version at the birth center where I do postnatal massage for the moms, & I smile every time I see it!
& if you want to improve your relationship with hubby - check out the original '5 Languages of Love' book - he gives lots of personal stories, & a number of marriages have turned arround after couples attend a workshop & realize they aren't showing their love in a way their partner can 'read!'
blessings
2 moms found this helpful
H.D. answers from Portland on November 20, 2008
"How to Talk So Kids Will Listen..." book by Faber and Mazlish. And family counselling. She sounds very hurt.
2 moms found this helpful
W.G. answers from Portland on November 20, 2008
Im a little confused, this is about a teenager, but you say your a mother of one girl who is in headstart? Is this a stepchild?
1 mom found this helpful
C.J. answers from Eugene on November 20, 2008
You can't talk to a child who is arguing with you, so my suggestion is to ignore her. When she uses profanity, either take away privileges or charge her a quarter each time she uses a bad word. If she takes things away from others, take the toy away from both until they can get along. As far as not going to her room, go to yours and lock the door. Don't talk to her until she acts civilly. Remember, kids want attention, and even negative attention is attention. Therefore, if you ignore her outbursts, she will eventually get the message that you won't give her attention when she acts immaturely.
1 mom found this helpful
Email