Photo by: Olaf Gradin

To Sibling or Not to Sibling?

Photo by: Olaf Gradin

From the day we announced we were going to have the G-man, people have been asking if we are going to have another. My standard response was that we were going to try to keep the one we already had alive first. Like I could really think about more when G-man was just a few hours old?

But now that we’ve managed to keep him mostly safe and sound for two years, the question is still looming. But unlike others that always knew they wanted lots of babies or can’t wait to see their family grow and be Parents 2.0, our decision is based mostly on the G-man: does he need/want a sibling? We are perfectly happy and complete with one (or as the blogs call him, a singleton), but is he?

Scott and I both have siblings so we can’t imagine an accurate picture of growing up as an only child. Is there too much pressure placed on them with having both parents full attention? Are they lonely? Or, are they happy to receive the full force of love, maybe better finances, a room of their own, the back seat all to themselves? This seems like a question for my mom as she was the only apple of my grandparents’ eye (which to be honest, we sometimes teased her about. Hmmm…).

I think if I ask people with and without siblings I’ll get a wide range of answers, even in the same family. For instance, I tend to think that my appearance in my older brother’s life caused such a cataclysmic shift that he never fully recovered and I, in some ways, ruined his life. I feel bad about that. On the other hand, my younger brother’s arrival into my life was one of the best things that could have happened to me and the joy I had when he came home from the hospital is one of my fondest childhood memories.

And let’s face it, a lot of my best stories growing up are because I had siblings. Good or bad, the experiences made me who I am today and shaped our relationships.

Maybe the answer differs from where you are in the birth order – first, middle, last. Maybe it’s a result of whether the new sibling is the same gender. Or how far apart you are in age. Or how close your birthdays are (I’m the day before my older brother, something I don’t think worked out so well). Thus, the questions I would have for the G-man are posed to both only children and the oldest child (as those are his two options right now) and just a curiosity into how gender plays into it.

I know lots of you will think about what it’s like to be a parent of one vs. more and how your children interact, but that’s not on our radar right now. We know his life would change with a sibling, but would it be for good or evil?

Thoughts?

Debi is a stay at home/work at home mom to a toddler born December 2007, one feisty cat and the world’s neediest dog. Her husband Scott does his best to keep her sane amidst the daily chaos of their lives.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

212 Comments

We have decided on an only child for several reasons. I am the youngest of 4 and my husband is the oldest of 3. The majority of my friends I went to high school with are only children and extremely successful adults. I asked all of them if they ever wished they had a sibling and all said no they did not.

My husband wants an only child so we can concentrate on our son becoming the best man he can with our help, since his siblings lack in that category...

See entire comment

I have a 13 year old step son (14 next month) and we have a scheduled C-section on Thursday (yeah!!) for his brother. My situation is a bit different. Technically I have 2 kids but one is only here part time (every other day) and his mom is great (another different situation). I have been thinking of the family of 4 and how that will be different=but my 13 yo is already fighting for his freedom as a teen-kind of a blessing rather than pure jealousy...

See entire comment

I think the greatest gift you can give your child is a sibling. I think children growing up with siblings learn more naturally about self sacrifice. Onlies can learn this also but the parents must be aware of creating opportunties for them. One thing that I have seen with my parents and husband is how important siblings are when you parents are ill and/or pass away. You have a bond with your sibling that you don't share with anyone else.

At my oldest son's 2nd birthday party, an only child friend made me promise that my son would not grow up an only child. Her parents, also both only children, were divorced and both in failing health and she was bearing the brunt of all of it without any family support. I now have 3 boys, ages 16, 13 and 10, and although they fuss occasionally, I know they would be there for each other...

See entire comment

I, like you, was perfectly happy with only 1 child. In fact, I was overwhelmed at the thought of having another. But while I didn't "feel" it - I did "believe" that "The greatest gift you can give your child is a sibling." I couldn't imagine not having my siblings, and it saddened me to no end to think of my daughter left alone later in life with no immediate family (or no one to whom she could say "Mom's crazy, isn't she?")...

See entire comment

Try reading "Maybe One" bu Bill McKibben. That book sealed the deal on one for us. One is GREAT! For eveyone.

We have only one boy and because of quite few reasons this is how it will be. We are happy and works for us. We do travel a lot and my son loves it. That won't happen if there were N 2. Recently my son desided that he might like to have a little brother or sister and he did share that with his best friend who is the youngest of 4. His friend told him that it is only good if you are the youngest one...

See entire comment

My son is 4 1/2 years old and is our only child. For medical reason I was unable to have anymore children, so this decision was made for me. My son is very well balanced and honestly he is better at sharing than most of his friends who have siblings, including several of his friends who have twin siblings!! I can't help but feel somewhat annoyed when I read from other mothers who do not have an only child, how they tend to be spoiled and lonely. These are both such big myths.....

See entire comment

I have a 13 year old son and only child. We get compliments all the time that people can't believe he is an only. Before he was born I had that "mommy tingle" for years. I can truly say that after he was born, I never felt that again. Even holding new babies, I felt complete with our family. I am one of four and my husband has two sisters. People asked us and pressured us about having more. We just told them that our family was complete...

See entire comment

I am an only child now 45 years old. I always had friends over and had lots of fun. Over the past month I have reconnected with childhood friends via the modern social networks... Comments made about how being at our home was the fondest memories they have of their childhood, how much fun we had together, it was always exciting to know they were going with us etc... So, being an only child for me was fun!YES Was I spoiled? YES...

See entire comment

I am the oldest child, and I was so happy when my brother was born. I always wanted more siblings, and am just so thankful for my brother at least. We were close growing up, and though I don't see him much anymore, it is a comfort knowing there is more family than just me. Even though he doesn't live close, I know he is there if I would need him, and I know I will not be alone in dealing with my parents as they age...

See entire comment

I am an only child and I wouldn't have wanted it any other way. I always thought I'd only want 1 child as well. I attribute my feeling that way to my personality. For me, I believe it has to do with your child's personality. I have a 6 year old daughter who is a wonderful intelligent and independent child, but I can fully imagine her as a big sister. Unfortunately, until recently I've been a single mother with no prospect of a new daddy...

See entire comment

I am pro sibling. When my husband (then boyfriend) and I discovered we were pregnant, it was a surprise. But even then I knew that if I had the one, I'd have to have the other (if nature allowed). Now, our daughter is 3 1/2, our son is 10 months, we've moved to the suburbs and are married. All of it, from some internal vibe that said, "that's what she'll need." It's different for every parent. But that's what worked for us.

my answer is yes yes yes.after i had my first son i never wanted another one and accidently i got pregnent and my second son was born after 3 and half year. i think that was the best for aour family my sons are best friend and they are always together and i am kind of free becouse they help eachother too

My best friend is an only child. When we were kids she "had it all" because she was an only child. Now we are 55. Her parents have had some health issues and through it all, she has said she really wished she had at least one sibling to share the aging parents' issues with. My Dad has had some health problems as well. I have 2 sisters and 1 brother. I could not have dealt with all Dad's health issues alone. It's a hard decision in these economic times...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all