Photo by: Heather

Does Motherhood Equal Identity Loss?

Photo by: Heather

Who are you? Who am I? What collection of facts and figures makes up the upc code emblazoned on your soul that when scanned, reads: ‘likes to be read to, enjoys the color orange, keep away from harsh chemicals, may contain peanuts’? What are the things, the memories, the loves and hates that make up my “identity”? Is it my tendency to wonder and wander? Is it the stoner and artsy kids I hung out with in high school? Is it the fact that I prefer vinyl or that I’m a sucker for the holidays every year? Is it the way I love, or the memories of the way I’ve been loved? Is it the pain I’ve caused others or the pain I myself have endured?

I could make a list of “100 things about me” and it would say arbitrary things like “startles easily” or “believes that cream cheese icing makes everything better”. But I don’t know that those things have anything to do with me or me with them. They are liner notes. Indexed tips on how to manage me for long periods of time.

I am recently a mother for the second time. As I create the foundation for this little person to establish who and what she is in this life, I am faced daily with the question of my own personhood. For weeks I’ve been milk maker, soother, diaper changer and occasionally ‘lady who showers and smells nice’… I stress “occasionally” here.

I was already a mother when this one came along. So prior to a few weeks ago, part of my consumer friendly label read: lunch maker, wound kisser, soother, protector, clothes washer, and occasionally ‘lady who brings cupcakes to my class’. But as my new role emerges, all other things become cloudy and less integrated and I begin to wonder which of them still constitute ‘shades of Me’.

The thing about this that sucks so much is that it is a very lonely place. This happens to you and only you, while the people around you go about their usual lives without question as to how and if anything has changed for them. While I’m concreted to the couch or the rocking chair for 45 minutes at a time to feed a new baby, everyone else in my world cruises by. Off to play or live or reconnect with old friends or simply enjoy the Independence that comes with not being affected by a life altering event.

So I try to remember who and what the ingredients are for a well made ‘Me’. I scan the pages of things I’ve done, stuff I’ve written and people I’ve loved. Somewhere, is the combination of things that light the center of me. Somewhere is a complete list of nutritional value, warnings and tips for best consumption.

Misty is the Mama of two little girls, wishes she was better at gardening, fancies herself a writer and can be fairly innovative at times.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

104 Comments

Great post! I'm right there with ya sister. I have a son who'll be 3 in April, and I'm due with my 2nd son the end of May...

See entire comment

To get an answer to how to incorporate your new motherhood into the real essence of who you were and are go to our website www.cmomwork.com. I wrote a little fun book to help uplift moms just like you, and to guide you to use the qualities that motherhood gives you to be a better YOU.

Great post, I think the changes to our identity when we become mothers are real and profound. I ended up devoting two chapters to the topic in my book This is Not How I Thought It Would Be: Remodeling Motherhood to Get the Lives We Want Today. Mothers need to know it is okay to both mourn losses of pieces of our selves and remodel our identity into something we feel good about...

See entire comment

This reads like an excerpt from the diary I would have written when my little ones were new had I not been glued to the sofa and rocker. It is the way of the world: you must deconstruct -- examine the past, tear things up a bit -- in order to build a strong foundation for something new. I disagree with those who read self-pity in your blog. I hear a woman who is smart and strong enough to grapple with the overwhelming transformations that motherhood brings...

See entire comment

OK, this resonates with me too but maybe for a different reason than some others. I have 6 children, 5 by birth and 1 by adoption. I have spent MANY hours nourishing a human life through my body before birth and after birth. I have been diaper changer and all those other "action" labels...

See entire comment

Congratulations to all of you that can be mothers. Have you ever stop and think what a privilege that is?? While you are at the chair feeding you baby and thinking how nice it will be to be in the "real world" Others out there are wishing exacly the very thing you are doing. To feel the warm head of a sweet baby. To sooth a crying one, to feel such a soft skin, to see those beautiful ice awaikening to this world, and yes, even to hear them cry...

See entire comment

I love the article Misty. The fact that you write about this shows part of your passion and identity as a writer. For me not becoming too attached to anyone identity is challenging as everything shifts, changes, and evolves. I suppose just sitting back and enjoying the moments that come with motherhood, artist, teacher, writer, but not grasping too hard onto one identity is the ideal...

See entire comment

Thank you so much for this entry!! I have been feeling conflicted and sort of lost the last several months and then this post showed up in my e-mail inbox. I too am a stay at home Mom of two and for the most part really love my job but I feel like I have lost some of who I am. Most times it doesn't bother me.....well to be quite honest I'm usually so busy I have had little time to think about it until recently...

See entire comment

I am so glad that I am not the only one feeling like this!! I have a 3.5 year old daughter, and she is needing me less and less. So now I gotta figure out who I am again! I don't know who I am any more and am worried what to do when she goes back to school!

I can completely relate to the "where did I go" feeling. I have a four year old son and a two year old daughter and I have been a stay at home mom for the past four years. I finally let go a little and started them in a preschool/mothers day out program and it has made a world of difference for me. I realized how much I needed just a little time for myself on that first day when I got home and was able to carry on a regular phone conversation with a friend uninterrupted...

See entire comment

Hi Magnificent Mamas,

I've often said that when we get married we lose our last name and when we have children we lose our first name, and then we wonder why we find ourselves in an identity crisis.


I am a mother of two and had major depression issues when my youngest was a baby. I could write a book about how I got out of my funk but essentially it all came down to taking care of me.

Being a mother you are still you, but an expanded you...

See entire comment

My son is 9. Just in the last few days I realized, I have spent most of the last 9 years trying to "find me", as opposed to being the best mom I could be. I was focused on ME- and it was a huge disservice to my son. I also realized- that it is GOD who has given me this gift of a child, and he knows who I am- and I am ANDREW's mom. I am realizing that I love running him to ball practice, and cub scouts, and helping in his classroom, and only wish I had more time to dedicate to being a mom...

See entire comment

I have thought about this so much for the last week. I was listening to my three kids talk, when my seven yr. old asked my 10 what he wanted to be when he grows up. He answered, "I think it would be fun to be an engineeer like Dad, What do you want to be?" My daughter replied, "I want to be a teacher." Then she asked 4yr. old. "Charlotte, what do you want to be?" Without hesitation, my 4yr...

See entire comment

I agree, I only have one, and trying for another. There are days that I question who I am all the time. Did I waste my degree that I worked hard for? The 8 years of work? Am I just an entertainment board, boo-boo kisser, cook, maid? Luckly my DH understands and I take classes at craft stores, or go see movies. Even a couple hours by myself makes me feel so much better, more aware of who I am...

See entire comment

Misty, don't ever let what you do identify who you are! Whether your job is as a secretary, a judge, or a Mommy, all of those things are merely a part of the total package. Although you may respond, "Misty," when someone on the phone asks "Who is this?" neither does your name make you who you are, it's just another label. Obviously, the part of your "job description" that is most important right now is the "Mommy" part...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all