45 answers

Out the Mouth It Came....

Ok ladies. I know we all have our MIL issues. I'm going to be brief and just say that one of my biggest problems with mine is she is always calling my 5 month old son "her baby," or "her little guy" and it absolutely drives me nuts. Well, we work together too which usually is not a problem. Some background info on us. We have always, always gotten along and are pretty good friends. When my son was born, something snapped in me, and I guess I become a little possessive with him when it came to my MIL. Anyway, we were getting ready to go to lunch today and I have been just extremely tired lately (and my son does sleep through the night...but my sleepiness is another story), and I just mentioned being ready to go because I was tired and honestly had a hard time even getting to work today. So, she replies (somewhat in a joking tone, "you're not endangering my baby, now, are you?" Well, I guess that was the last straw for me because out it came.... I said, of course, "MY Baby. He is not your baby, he is your grandbaby. I don't know how many times I have to tell you this before you realize it bothers me." So, least to say, she wasn't really wanting to go have lunch after that. I SO did not mean for all that to come out, but it did and I can't take it back now. I feel terrible. I could tell she was starting to tear up, so I tried to tell her I was sorry, and that I didn't mean to hurt her feelings, but obviously she is upset now. What do I do??? I'm going to try and go talk to her in a little while, but her family tends to hold grudges, and I am afraid that our relationship may not be the same now. Any suggestions is greatly appreciated!

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thank you all SO, SO much for your advice, kind words, and words of wisdom. As of today, nothing has really changed much. I tried to go over to her office to see if she would talk at lunch yesterday, but she had already left. So I sent her a very nice email apologizing AGAIN for my outburst, and I told her that I loved her and that I didn't want to see our relationship damaged by my stupid and out of line comment. Apparently also when my Husband had called and tried to talk to her, some other issues were brought up about her thinking I didn't trust her with my Son,etc. All of which are completely false. I guess since I am a little selfish with my time with my son on the weekends (after all I do work full time, and I don't feel like I see him much), she doesn't see him as often as she wants. Somehow or another she has interpreted that into I don't trust her with him. Anyway, I ver briefly mentioned that in the email, and told her I would like to talk with her to try and clear up her misconceptions. She hasn't replied or mentioned anything about it, so I am still waiting. I feel at this point that I have done everything I can on my end, so it is now up to her. I think it will be fine, but time will tell. Thank you again for ALL your help. This is such an amazing group of Moms. I so glad I found this site!! Ya'll are wonderful!!

Featured Answers

You did nothing wrong...MIL needs to suck it up and leave it alone already! Don't let the guilt getcha!!! Good luck!

The best you can do is just as you did... just explain that you were tired and cranky and apologize. She is a grown up and needs to get over it! However, if something is really bothering you just have a talk about it. If you hold things in that will happen again. My MIL and I get along very well but there are things that get on my nerves and if I don't have a talk the same thing happens, I blow up. Sometimes even if we do talk about it she gets offended and mad, but she gets over it in a couple of days and we move on! I wish you luck.

I just want to remind all of you that one day you will be that MIL. Especially if you have sons it will not be easy. When a daughter marries you gain a daughter. When a Son married you lose a son. This is true I see it over and over again. The Grandchildren are always closer to the wife family.

One day I will be that MIL trying to see my Grandchilren...trying to be close to them. This is what I tell myself to cope with my in laws.

More Answers

Hi, S.,
I disagree with the responses that you have received which say your MIL has the right to say, "My Baby", etc. Your baby is not her baby. She had her baby already and this is your turn and YOUR baby. I think you could let it sit for a few days. When you are both calm just tell her that you have been upset for a while about this. It's probably a good thing that you both are talking about it now. Sometimes in families there is a conflict or disagreement which gives us the opportunity to mend something. She is being too territorial and I would let her know.
Good Luck!
D.

1 mom found this helpful

You have so many responses and I have not been able to read them all. But I believe that all of us are capable of being a bit snappy when we are tired. Do not fault yourself for long; just know that you are human. Hopefully your MIL will understand this but be sure to apologize again. Do explain how the question made you feel without casting accusations in her direction. It can be something like, 'when I am tired, I feel like I am being accused of being a bad mom when I am asked if I am endangering our baby'.
You are so lucky to have a MIL who cares about your baby so much. Think about that in a positive way and maybe that will help you overcome being so possessive about your baby. For sure, the baby is yours, but your MIL is including the baby as hers, even though just grandbaby, because she loves him so much.
And remember, if your MIL cares so much abour her grandbaby, and you need extra rest, consider asking her to give you some time off and keep the baby for a while. I have a sister who gets to watch her grandbaby every Saturday which gives her son and DIL precious time together, time to run errands or time for themselves alone. And it has fostered a wonderful relationship between grandmom and grandbaby.

1 mom found this helpful

To be honest, I think you were taking it to literally. Would anyone really believe that you son is her baby. Grandparents tend to do that and just refer to new baby's as theirs, meaning it is the newest baby in the family-not that the baby is personally theirs. It's no different that saying this is "my little angel". I think you over-reacted and you need to keep apologizing

Wow, well I highly doubt that she will hold it against you for too long being that her affection for her grandson runs deep. She'll most likely give you a hard time or perhaps have a heart to heart with you also being that your previous relationship was near and dear. It sounds like you are on the right track with wanting to apologize and talk with her. Just explain to her the same thing you explained to all of us strangers. Given your background relationship and related ties you should be able to open up to her in a deeper way than with us, right??
Best wishes.

The best you can do is just as you did... just explain that you were tired and cranky and apologize. She is a grown up and needs to get over it! However, if something is really bothering you just have a talk about it. If you hold things in that will happen again. My MIL and I get along very well but there are things that get on my nerves and if I don't have a talk the same thing happens, I blow up. Sometimes even if we do talk about it she gets offended and mad, but she gets over it in a couple of days and we move on! I wish you luck.

I would have been more upsent about the insinuation that I was a careless mother who would "endanger" her little baby! That to me was the insult! I am a grandmother to 6 and always call them "mine". I always thought it was a way to show how much I love those little kids (as if they were MY own..everyone knows there is nothing like a mothers love for her "OWN" children). Maybe I should be more careful, but not one of my kids have said a thing-or my daughter-in-law either.
I see it this way: Life is too short. We all have TWO choices with EVERYTHING that comes our way-- take it the POSITIVE way or take it the NEGATIVE way. We can never go wrong always taking things the positive way. Today you let things out because you were tired. Dont dwell on things, forgive quickly, dont take everything so SERIOUS! Make and take time to love and laugh with everyone.
I would die with a problem with one of my children or inlaws. I try extra hard to avoid conflict. Again, life is too short.
I hope you can solve this. It breaks my heart when families have conflicts that are unnecessary. Afterall, enough conflict enters our lives on it's own.

Honestly, I think that I would have more of a problem w/ her implying I was "endangering" my son, even though she meant it as a joke, than I would the "my baby" part. It was like she didn't trust you to take care of your own child, no matter how jokingly she meant it, I would have a problem with. I think I would apologize and then just let time deal with it. I might even eventually try to make a joke out of it, such as refer to him as her baby sometimes to show you don't hold a grudge, and hopefully she won't do the same.

I am not a grandmother yet, but I don't think I would ever try to take that mother's role away, and if I did I would understand if the mom did not appreciate it, instead of acting all upset about it. I think she was just as much in the wrong as you, personally.

Take it from me, there may always be that little rough spot in your relationship, but it will go on, regardless.

Take care.

I think that of course you should apologize for the way you said it, but I do not think you need to apologize for what you said!

If it bothers you, then you have every right to ask her not to call him "her baby". and no matter what anyone else would feel, or think if it bothers you then you havw a right to ask her to stop.

Personally that would tick me off too. Term of endearment or not, I would ask her to find another way to refer to him.

I would approach it calmly and explain that you are sorry you blew up, BUT that it really bothers you when she uses the term "my baby" and you would appreciate if she could find antoher term of endearment or knickname in the future.

We all have our breaking point and you hit yours. Don't beat yourself up about it, if she had taken previous hints that it bothered you then it wouldn't have happened.

Hang in there, things will get better!!

Reba :o)

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.