J.C. asks from Gilbert, AZ on May 21, 2010
Teaching My Son About Cultural Diversity
My 4 yr old said recently that "he doesn't like black people"....I have no idea where he is getting this idea from but want to put an end to it ASAP. Not cool. We had a long talk about loving and accepting everyone for who they are, no matter what their skin color is and asked him why he would say that. Basically what I got out of it, is that he said he thinks anything black is mean...like dark rooms, dark "bad guys" from movies, etc. I think this all started when he saw "how to train a dragon" because the dragon is black in that movie and considered the worst of all dragons...but its weird because as the movie goes on, that dragon becomes the kids friend and is not bad. So I ordered 2 books yesterday online, "Priscilla McDoodlenutDoodleMcMae asks why?" and "Adventures at Walnut Grove" which both are about this subject, but was wondering if anyone had any other good teaching aids or suggestions how to teach cultural diversity and acceptance?
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Thank you to everyone for the suggestions. In response to a few of the posts, I never said that skin color doesn't matter. If you read the post, it says we talked about loving and accepting people for who they are, no matter what their skin color is- and I do believe in teaching my kids about how we are different, that's the whole reason I'm asking for help. He does go to school, it is very small and there are no African Americans in his class. He has Asian friends and Mexican friends, and hopefully will be exposed to other cultures in some recreation classes I have him signed up for this summer. It was on more than one occasion that he has said this to me, and yes...I could be overreacting so I'm not going to dwell on it too much so as not to draw too much attention to it. But like I said, I did get a few books and he has seen the Princess and the Frog (loves that movie actually) and I'll keep an eye out for another show or movie with a broad cultural range of characters. Thanks again for all of the insight.
Featured Answers
C.C. answers from Phoenix on May 22, 2010
The best teaher is experince. try introducing him to black playmates so he will know that they are not different . Abstract thought is not the same as liviing the experince.
More Answers
C.W. answers from Phoenix on May 22, 2010
There are several ways you can make sure to incorporate the positive image of African Americans and others into your child's life. He may or may not be getting it from outside sources but you need to make sure the right message is instilled at home. Books are a good place to start as you stated. Make sure you have books, toys and watch programming that show African Americans and others in a positive light. At the early age of four, you just do it in little ways to see if it is just a 'black is scary' thing.
Books: Please Baby Please, Please Puppy Please, Girls Hold up this world
http://www.amazon.com/Girls-Hold-Up-This-World/dp/0439087...
Toys - have toys of different colors and when you play , make sure the 'black' toy is the good guy sometimes and make an animal or something toy like a dinosaur (not a human figure) the bad guy. A friend of mine when playing chess in her house, black goes first sometimes. So there are little ways to instill the idea and positive image.
Lots of great shows: Backyardigans, Little Bill, Handy Mandy, Dora the Explorer, Go, Diego, Go, all instill positive images of people of ALL colors. The Movie - The Princess and the Frog, also has a very positive image while still having an interesting storyline for girls and boys. (Not your typical Princess movie of the Prince coming in to save the day which is great for girls).
If the problem continues and maybe get more books that tackle the problem directly.Here are a few others including a link at Amazon.
Grandpa, is everything black bad? Also, We all have a Heritage. http://www.amazon.com/Grandpa-Everything-Black-Sandy-Holm...
It may be nothing but better to start addressing it just in case it is something that develops into something more serious later. If it is nothing, it is still wonderful to instill equality and teaching diversity to your children no matter what color they are. Good luck and kudos to you for being smart enough to even realize that this should be address and searching out resources to help.
2 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from Honolulu on May 21, 2010
**Adding This: perhaps, as a family or with him, join culture clubs. Then he will meet other kids from around the world, learning about different people and cultures and interests and having friends, that are interesting and fun, too. There are usually many culture clubs for any culture, in any city. Just look it up online for your city.
Just the other day on CNN, there was a segment on how color of skin affects children's impressions of people.
It was interesting... but basically, yes, the darker skinned items (they did not use actual people in the visual test/answer sessions with the kids, just a cartoon figure, non-gender based either). But anyway, the mass majority of the kids, chose the darker skinned items as being "bad" or "stupider" etc.
Even the African American kids, had a bias... choosing the darker skinned items as being "bad" or "stupider" or more dangerous.
Both white and African American kids... had a perceptual "bias" toward dark skinned items (ie: people).
It is the media. It is the socialization of society. It is the world-view of society in the mainstreamed culture. It is celebrities, it is everything... that skews and creates a "majority" and a "minority" outlook toward certain skin colors. It is also cultural....
In my State, there are many many many different cultures and people and skin colors. The kids, grow up, not really knowing a certain skin color... because many of them are mixed ethnicities as well, and from a mix of cultures. My kids have friends of all colors/cultures/ethnicities from all parts of the world, and we do too. BUT on TV/movies/games, which kids watch, even the news... there are certain delineations of "skin color" and who "criminals" are or who "bad people" are, or what is cool and what is not. And this becomes subliminally ingrained in kids minds. Then their beliefs. Then their Habits. And either taught by their parent(s) or not.
4 years old is young but even younger, I taught/teach my kids about people all being different... but the SAME inside. Even my daughter's Teachers teach that to the kids. It takes repetition... for kids to understand 'abstract' concepts... kids this age are 'literal' and only go by their senses or what is tangible... abstract concepts are harder to perhaps understand.... or to make a connection based on empathy or feeling based connections with it. Kids this age often don't even know how they feel....
But yes, teach him. Like a rock collecting moss... that is how it becomes a part of them.
The other poster had a good point as well... maybe it is how he is/has been treated by "darker skinned" kids in school? Still, you must teach him... about the world, about attitude, about heart.... about acceptance... about right/wrong.
all the best,
Susan
2 moms found this helpful
A.C. answers from Cincinnati on May 22, 2010
GOOD FOR YOU!!! I feel that it is vital to teach cultural diversity to kids. I would suggest going to the library and finding kids books about how other kids live is other countries (not just the USA)
http://www.multiculturalchildrenslit.com/
http://www.adl.org/bibliography/
http://www.education.wisc.edu/ccbc/
http://www.dawcl.com/introduction.html
maybe get a map and have your child pick a country in the world and then find information/children books on the country (your library can also help with this).
Good luck and THANK YOU for teaching your child about diversity
1 mom found this helpful
S.B. answers from Gainesville on May 21, 2010
Are you sure he is not getting picked on at school? My brother grew up hating black people because of the way they treated him at school. My dads kind of racist, but we lived with my mother who definitely is not. Anyways, my bro was overweight and there were particular kids who were black that picked on him constantly about his weight, and would " gang up" on him and make his life miserable. Having been bullied by mainly this ethnicity made him feel a certain way about all of them. OR maybe its just the dragon movie. I dont know, maybe take him on vacation to Jamaica.
1 mom found this helpful
T.N. answers from Phoenix on May 22, 2010
When my children are a little older, like elementary school age, I plan on taking them on "service" family vacations occasionally. It's okay and good to have fun family vacations, too, so I'm not saying it will completely replace those -- just every once in a while instead of making it all about us we will spend our time helping those in need. I found a nonprofit my sister volunteered through that helps orphans and orphanages in South America. She thoroughly enjoyed her experience with the organization and has gone back to serve a few more times. They offer short family service vacations that they arrange, so a lot of the planning and organizing is already done. On the "vacation" I believe you primarily spend your time as a family playing with and caring for orphaned babies and children. They also allow free time to go explore the local area and give you ideas of places to go see. If you have smaller children, you can just help out half days while you're there so your own kids can rest. I think this will really help kids be grateful for what they have and less entitled, more compassionate, and more aware of how other people live in other countries and cultures. Here's the website: http://www.orphanagesupport.org/index.html
On the left side click on "Volunteers" and the scroll to the bottom and click where it says "short-term family service adventures" to learn more. The website has very detailed information.
1 mom found this helpful
M.F. answers from Sioux Falls on May 21, 2010
I have always gone out of my way to expose my children to people of different ethnicities. I make a point to talk to them in the parks, at church, wherever we might meet people. I have always talked with them and asked them what they like about the people we meet and see. We like to admire their hair, the way they dress, their eyes, whatever. Always help to point out the good, and see the good in everyone. and try to introduce him to kids of different races and make friends with them.
Once he meets more people and interacts with them he will be just fine!
1 mom found this helpful
M.A. answers from Houston on May 21, 2010
As far as the "skin color doesnt matter" approach...skin color DOES matter. It makes people who they are. I would never show such disrespect to another human being and not "see" who they are.
TEACH your child. TEACH him that there ARE black people. TEACH him that there are Asian people.....Teach him that skin color SHOULD be respected and UNDERSTOOD.
There IS a matter to skin color. To say "it doesnt matter", is to say it shouldnt be recognized...it should.
1 mom found this helpful
S.B. answers from Kansas City on May 21, 2010
maybe you could have him watch Return of the Jedi? They specifically had Luke wear black in that movie to show that sometimes the good guys wear black too. :-)
Unfortunately, I dont know how else to help. My daughter isnt really exposed to anyone of other races, unfortunately, except her cousin who is half black, and he's an infant, so that doesnt really help.
Email