12 answers

Organic Milk or Not

My son recently turned one and I am debating whether to give him organic milk. It is so much more expensive and I don't buy organic anything else, so I am wondering if it is worth it. Any opinions would be appreciated especially from those moms whose children are now on whole milk. Thanks

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

We just had that discussion a few days ago. A friend who works in the health field asked some experts and they did highly recommend organic milk especially for girls. I have not been doing it but will start now and I have a 2 yr old.

More Answers

I have given my daughter either raw or organic milk since she was about 1 year old with no problems.
Good Luck

Hi J.,
I think it is worth it, milk is a big protion of his diet.
Try Borden's brand kid builders itis 5.69 a gallon, a little cheaper than the organic brands but it is the same. My kids love it. I would also try to incorporate a little more organic as he eats more table food and snacks.
Good Luck,
K.

when i had my first son i gave him mostly organic baby food and milk. i now have 3 toddlers and they drink about 4 gallons (or more) of milk a week. i recently stopped buying organic because it was cutting into my budget although i do feel very guilty about it. i tell myself that many kids are raised on regular (non organic) milk and i too was raised on non-organic milk and i turned out okay. go with what you can afford or what really matters to you.

personally, i think the more organic, the better. i dont go crazy, but i try, especially for the things my kids eat the most of, like milk, yogurt, and bananas. if there is a fairway near you, their prices arent bad. also, bj's wholesale club has some organics now, including milk and some fruit and veggies and frozen veggies.

If you choose to give him milk, go with only organic whole milk. It is worth every penny.

But I find dairy to be very closely related to infections and mucus. Keeping away from it prevented my kids from all kinds of colds and ear infections.

C.

Hello J.,

Although it does cost more, organic milk is worth it. I have been drinking organic milk myself for years and as soon as my son turned 1 (now 2 1/2) I started him on it. Toddlers drink so much milk (30 oz or so) daily that I thought it better for him. Actually I usually try to go all organic with my dairy products (yogart, cheese, eggs, etc). it really is better for them and you.

My family has quit drinking cow milk because of food allergies. However, we do eat organic as much as possible and I know from research I've read that animal fats carry a lot more environmental pollutants in them than vegetables. People who don't eat any animal products have much less of these pollutants in their systems, people who don't eat meat but eat dairy have more and people who eat meat have the most. Eating organic meat may be more important than drinking organic milk, but organic milk does have fewer pollutants than factory farmed milk. If you have access to grass-fed milk that has a lot more Omega 3s than the usual grain fed. Do some research on Google and see what you find.

I do think rBGH effects people. When I was nursing my youngest daughter I noticed that although I drank a lot of organic milk, when I had ice cream made from commercial milk my breasts would become engorged and I would make more milk than usual. Kinda creepy.

We just had that discussion a few days ago. A friend who works in the health field asked some experts and they did highly recommend organic milk especially for girls. I have not been doing it but will start now and I have a 2 yr old.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.