K.P. asks from Woodland Hills, CA on August 01, 2008
2 Month Old Will Not Sleep in Her Own Bed - Only Wants to Sleep While Being Held
We don't co-sleep - it's not a safe choice for my family. My 2 month old will only sleep at night in my arms. Every time I put her down in her own bed ( a cradle right next to my own bed), she wakes up and screams. I end up holding her for hours while she sleeps in the night. But then I don't get much sleep. I'm exhausted! I'm breastfeeding her every 2-4 hours throughout the night. She doesn'l like to be put down much for any reason - she doesn't even like her car seat. I have to "wear" her in a sling!
Featured Answers
K.J. answers from Los Angeles on August 04, 2008
Hi K.,
My 4 month old was doing this at same age because her mattress was to firm. I tried placing a thick, firm quilt down to give her some cushion adn now she sleeps through the night like a champ!
Good luck!
M.M. answers from Los Angeles on August 03, 2008
Watch the dvd or read the book "the happiest baby on the block." It's the best sleeing/soothing book ever!
I thought that my daughter could only sleep on me until I read this book. She is 6 months now, but has been very happy sleeping in her crib since she was 6 weeks old.
Good luck.
M.M. answers from Los Angeles on August 03, 2008
I had this issue with my daughter. I realized that she just wanted to be held and comforted. Once I just accepted it, it got easier. I did sleep with her on top of me. I propped up my arms with pillows to make it safe. I had to sleep on my back and was always very aware of where she was. I was just very careful not to drink or take any medicine that would make me sleep deep. Everything was fine. My husband slept next to me but because she was on top of me and the pillows acted like a protection barrier she never rolled or moved. This was the only way I got any sleep. I was finally able to get her to sleep in her crib at 4 1/2 months. It took a month and 1/2 of trying every day and night. Some babies just need more comforting than others and I wanted her to know that she was safe with her mommy. That's all she wanted, so I couldn't deprive her of it. Good luck.
More Answers
M.C. answers from Honolulu on August 02, 2008
She is so young, you still have hope!!!! You need to decide on how you want her to go to sleep and "train" her to do so. I'm sure you have figured out when she is most tired (after nursing, or after tummy time or whatever) so swaddle her up and lay her down and don't go back. Yes, I know it is excruciating, but don't turn around!!! Time her -- I always gave my baby 20 minutes ("if she is still crying after 20 minutes, I'll go get her") but usually, it didn't go beyond 5 minutes. It just felt like 100 years!! You can help her out with music, or darken the room or whatever, but I would not add too many "crutches" if I were you, because then she may always need that music playing... which may not be as easy to replicate at grandmas house. Sleeping on your own is a very important skill that needs to be well developed for the entire family to live a happy and healthy life. (did you see how many of todays postings have to do with sleep issues????) Good luck. Make sure your husband is on the same page with you and if you need help, ask a relative or neighbor to sit with you during those "screaming moments" or at least call someone on the phone who can talk you out of going into that room. You can do this, and you will be much happier when you do.
1 mom found this helpful
S.H. answers from Honolulu on August 01, 2008
Each baby is different... my firstborn was very much like that too. My 2nd born is much more independent.
She probably likes your arms only, because it is nice and warm, cozy, snuggly, and like a cocoon (ie: like the womb). With my firstborn, we had to wrap her up...but still, it didn't always work with her. We tried all methods, even crying it out even though I don't like that method, but we were desperate.
What we did find is that my girl was just sensory sensitive...not in a bad way, but especially to noise and textures & temperature... this also made her fussy. And she had gas problems. She rarely farted. It was just something I/we dealt with... as she got older... it lessened. But, I did keep to a nap/sleep routine always. I always put her down for naps and sleep with the same routine, at the same times, and did the same thing everyday. This pretty much helped her to get settled down, as she knew the "schedule" and what to expect. Gradually, I could actually put her down, and after nursing, she would fall asleep.
Yes, it was very tiring, but this is what we discovered with our daughter. Thankfully, my son, my 2nd born is much easier. LOL. My daughter didn't even like the slings....she wanted ME to carry her in my arms. But after a time, I just could not... too tiring, and I would put her down... she'd cry, but I'd stay right next to her and play and get her distracted. It's a process....it takes time... and there is an adjustment period... but mostly, they just want the bonding and the closeness of Mommy. As they get older, you will miss that, in hindsight.
Maybe try a bouncy seat, a swing, or something that vibrates...
A couple of my friends, had this problem as well... with them, their baby wasn't getting enough intake.. .so the baby was clingier and never wanted to be put down, much less sleep or be away from Mommy. The baby was simply hungry and didn't get enough... one friend then found out she didn't have enough milk. The other, her baby was not suckling effectively enough...thus was not getting much in. Once they solved that problem and their baby was getting more intake and feeding... the crying and fussiness stopped and their babies slept better and was less clingy. This is just their experiences...
Try different things... I know it's not easy....but what will work for one baby, may not work for another.
She will grow, get bigger and heavier... and it will get harder and harder to carry her in your arms just to get her to sleep....but by then, she will get used to this "habit." Also, at this age, they still don't have control of their arms/legs or reflexes...thus as they sleep, their appendages will flail... and this ALSO startles them awake, thus screaming. They call it the "startle reflex." But this is developmental and will go away once their reflexes matures.
Breastfeeding is on demand, so yes, I did that too and woke up many times a night to nurse. I know this adds to the exhaustion....but it will pass.
Sorry I don't have a "magic" answer for you... just sharing what I and my friends went through, similarly.
Good luck,
~Susan
C.T. answers from San Diego on August 02, 2008
I had the same problem. It is likely a temperature difference and/or softnes issue. If you have an electric heating pad, put it on low on her bed, and remove it just before you set her down. Also try puting more cushion under her fitted sheet. One thing that also helped me was swaddling her with one of those Kiddopotamus velcro swaddlers you get from Babies'r'us. They can't wiggle out of them so easily. Just make sure you dress her lightly so she doesn't overheat. Especially during the time of her 2 month shots. Another thing I used to do at night was swaddle my baby and put one pillow on either side of me for arm support and hook her on to feed with her feet diagonal against my body. Sometimes that was the only way to get some sleep. It's tough but hang in there.
H.H. answers from Los Angeles on August 02, 2008
She is still so young and relatively unaware. What you do now can make or break your sanity for the upcoming months. I think a lot of moms fall into the trap of holding their babies to sleep because to do otherwise seems unmotherly. Trust me, you will regret it. My friends, my sister, and gobs of women from this chat form deal with this issue.
The swing worked miricles in our house to sooth our new born.
We even resorted to using it in the night. (Also a bit habbit forming, but at least a habit that gives mom some sleep).
Because of my difficulties with C-section infection and low milk porduction (resulting in 60 hours of week of breastfeeding and pumping, often a feeding took an hour and a half), I felt if I didn't put my baby down immediatly after feeding in her own bassinet, I was going to die.
I was so jealous of my friends who just held their babies to sleep. But I just couldn't. In the end, my baby was very good about just going down because we did it that way even from the first few weeks of life. I would stand over her bassinet and soothe her, but not always pick her up. I let her fuss, but didn't let her cry it out this young.
I don't have the answer for you but you are not a bad mom if you don't hold her every time she fusses. A good mom is a rested mom. Its okay to put your needs into the mix. You will be a better mom for it. Good luck. This is a trying time. I feel for you.
A.M. answers from Los Angeles on August 03, 2008
My daughter was the same way. The rocking eased her stomach problems (she suffers from acid reflux) and she liked the sounds of the rocking chair. We got a cradle swing at Babies R Us that did the trick. It rocks from side to side and back to front. I put my little one in and a few moments of rocking with my hand on her tummy does the trick. She's now 5 1/2 months and has slept in her swing since she was 1 month old.
T.C. answers from San Luis Obispo on August 07, 2008
Hi K.,
I read some of the responses to your request and I did not see one suggestion that I would like to add. If you believe it might be a reflux issue, prop up one side of her bassinett. Put a small towel or something under the mattress of the bassinett to elevate the head of her bed. Once her head is up a little higher than her chest, this could help her acid reflux. My youngest had this issue and once I elevated the head of her bed, her sleeping improved. Does she need to be held during the day to sleep? If not, I would try and figure out what is different about the day and the night. Best of luck...it is a challenge to get enough sleep, when you have small children...and working outside of the home only makes your sleep possiblity even less likely.
Take care and remember that this part of her life is just a brief time. Best of luck figuring out what it is you can do that can help your little one go to sleep.
J.D. answers from Reno on August 02, 2008
You are in fact, co-sleeping. It's just as unsafe to hold your baby while she (and you) sleeps as it is for her to sleep between you. She could roll off of your chest and either in between you or onto the floor.
You need to break the habit now, before she gets hurt. Try using a white noise machine, swaddling, etc. to get her to sleep alone. She doesn't know that she's supposed to be put down to sleep, you have to teach her that. When you take her out of the cradle to feed her in the middle of the night, put her right back in there and keep your hand on her tummy until she falls asleep. That way, she knows that you're still there, but she'll learn that she doesn't need to be in your arms to sleep.
Good luck! I hope you get some sleep soon. :)
E.N. answers from San Diego on August 03, 2008
I'll share some tips that worked with my two babies. Tight swaddling (we swaddled until about 6 mos or so with both babies - they loved it!) and a sleep positioner (we got ours at Babies R Us, it has a little memory foam pillow and two wedges on the sides to keep the baby nice and snug in place). I only have two kids so I am no expert, but from what I have experienced and the advice I got from sources I trust, babies will get used to whatever they are given everyday. I always put my babies to sleep in their beds (with some exceptions, of course, but the norm was to sleep in their beds) so that became the place they preferred to sleep.
I don't know if you are open to letting her cry at all (I've read great arguments on both sides of this issue), but during the night, if she is fed, burped, clean and is not sick, I would put her down in her bed to sleep. If she fights it and cries, it will probably only be 5-10 minutes (I had to do this with my second baby, he never wanted to go back into his bed after his 3 am feeding). She needs to learn that nightime is the time for sleep, not for cuddling with Mommy - I noticed you are working, but I'm sure you give her lots of cuddling during the day when you are with her. Of course, it's much easier said than done. It might be easier if you were able to move her into her own room now, if you think you're ready for that.
Maybe check with her daycare and see what sort of routine they use for her when she naps. If you can mimick that at home it might help her.
Email