3Yr Old Doesn't Talk or Potty Trained , Why ?

Updated on July 27, 2017
C.K. asks from Boston, MA
5 answers

This is about my little brother from my dads side , I know this is supposed to be for moms but what I've witnessed worries me a lot. I have a 3 yr old brother who lives with my dad and his wife. He doesn't know how to talk just babble like babies and to tell us he wants something he crys , I assume he does this because when he does they give him what he wants . He isn't potty trained either, I've noticed when I come to visit them that they only feed him junk food like candy sweets chocolate milk etc and when it comes time to eat he crys because he doesn't want to eat his really food like chicken veggies rice beans etc but grabs a candy bag and wants to eat that and if they don't let him he will cry and they end up letting him get his way. Also they try to potty train him but he starts crying because he doesn't want to. He's always on his tablet as well although the watched a lot of kid educational stuff it's still worries me because he still can't speak and it's like all his time is spent on that tablet rather than them reading to him singing abc's etc . I try to do my best to help by reading to him and talking to him and thankfully I taught him how to sing his abc's and count but I don't live here so I can't give it my all . and I try to talk to my dad about it but he brushes it off and I don't really want to say anything to his wife because I feel like she will think I am telling her how to parent her kid and make her mad or feel bad . She has an older daughter who is such a good girl and I know some kids naturally delay in certain things but can this be becaus lack of doing their part as a parent or what can I suggest to my dad he does so he can help my little brother learn ? Thank you in advance.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

D.B.

answers from Boston on

You sound like a concerned sister, and you are to be commended for doing what you can (reading, singing the ABC song, etc.). I do want to caution you that it's not important to give a child academic skills at 3 - you should read for pleasure, put some music on or tune in to a kiddie TV show with sing-along fun, maybe go to the public library to take out a book (kids think this is amazing, a new book each week!). You can ask questions like "What does the cat say?" and "What is that dinosaur doing?" to see if he will converse with you when he's not stressed out and trying to get his own way. But make this fun - don't make it about learning to count to 50 if a child is this young. If you want to count to 3 while playing hopscotch or play an age-appropriate board game in which you roll the dice and recognize the "4" and then move 4 spaces, fine. But make it light, and fun.

I don't know if your brother has a speech or hearing problem or not, but there are early intervention services for kids who need it. The question is, will your father and stepmother check into anything? He may just be using what works - crying and tantrums. That won't last forever. This is beyond your control.

A child who isn't potty trained at 3 is less of a concern. Many kids with active and involved parents don't train until closer to 4, and that's just during the daytime. So I'd let that go for now. Eventually he will get tired of being wet, or they will get tired of paying for diapers, or he will not be able to go to pre-K or kindergarten if he can't use a toilet.

As you have noted, your brother has a parenting problem - he has parents who don't want to make the effort, who don't want to do the hard work of parenting. That means saying no and not letting the child run the show. Your brother is going to have problems in preschool and public school if he thinks crying is the answer to everything. So unfortunately, his parents are going to have to deal with this at some point. And of course he's going to have physical problems and dental problems if he just eats junk food.

What you CAN do, on your own, is write a letter to your brother's pediatrician. Maybe you can quietly find the name and address in the house - on an appointment card, on a list posted for the babysitter, on an enrollment form for a preschool, anywhere. Quietly write this down. Then when you get back to your house, write down your concerns with specific examples. What words CAN he say? Is he interested in reading? Does he sing along with you? What words won't he use? What does he eat? Do say to the doctor that you are a concerned half-sister who lives elsewhere but who visits occasionally, and you are very worried. Now, you have to understand that, legally, the doctor cannot respond to your letter nor can he/she talk to you if you call. But the doctor can (and will) use this information to guide the types of questions asked at the child's physicals and any sick visits, and to check for things like weight gain, developmental delays, dental issues and so on. Even asking about discipline and social skills is part of a regular physician's visit, so the pediatrician can put a little more emphasis on things as needed. A doctor might, for example, recommend some sort of hearing test or see if your brother can do certain tasks - often a doctor will just ask the parent, but in cases like this, the doctor may go a step further. It may be that this boy's parents need some parenting classes or some warning from a person in authority that some areas are being neglected.

If you do write this letter, my suggestion is that you not inform your father that you have done so - that doesn't mean to lie if you are asked outright, but just not to volunteer information. From what you've said here, I don't think there is a reason to involve Social Services (no matter how annoying and frustrating you find the situation). And you are only seeing his behavior on the weekends when you visit, not all the time. So perhaps he's not this way all the time.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.G.

answers from Portland on

If it were me, I'd just sit down with your dad and his wife, and say you have concerns - the speech one is the one I would focus on. You can bring something up without making it a big deal - you just say "Are you guys concerned at all that he isn't speaking? What does his paediatrician say?".

The food - I would let go. The potty training - not a concern.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.Z.

answers from Los Angeles on

Diane B.'s suggestion is a good one. If you go to www.cdc.gov, and search milestone chart for 3 years, it'll give you a list of what can be expected of a 3 year old. The website also has charts for one year, 18 months, 2 years, etc. that you can use as a guide.

I think you're an amazing sister for being so concerned about your little brother and doing what you've been doing with him! You are making a HUGE difference in your brother's life!

2 moms found this helpful

B.C.

answers from Norfolk on

I read somewhere that kids who spend a lot of time on phones/tablets/etc suffer from delayed language skills.
Language is picked up from interacting with parents/adults - not devices.
So taking away the things that are meant to keep the kid quiet might help him some in that department.
As far as the toilet training goes - some train later than others.
Our son was trained at 3 1/2 - we let day care take the lead on it (they had these tiny child sized toilets that were not intimidating, every one in the class went at the same time (yea peer pressure)) and one day he came home and showed me what he could do!
If his parents are treating him more like a pet, I've got to wonder how interested they are in raising him.
By your description it almost sounds like they are tired and done and don't realize they still have one more child left to go.

There's not much you can do if no one is willing to listen.
It might be worth having him evaluated for development delays.
Ultimately your brother isn't yours to raise.
Just file away this info and be a different sort of parent when it's your turn.

1 mom found this helpful

W.W.

answers from Washington DC on

C.,

Welcome to mamapedia. You don't have to be a mom to ask questions!

At the age of 3, most children are potty trained for the day, not night. A 3 year old child SHOULD have about 200 or more words he/she is able to say, even in sentences.

The pediatrician SHOULD be catching up on this. If you are that concerned? When you are there. Work with him on potty training and eating. DO NOT just give in when he throws a fit. If your dad and step mom don't "allow" you to do that? The next step would be calling CPS and lodging a complaint - it's anonymous. But I doubt they'd do much because he's not being physically hurt.

You can talk to your counselor at your school and tell him/her what you are witnessing and you are concerned that your brother will be developmentally delayed if he doesn't get help.

You can tell your dad that he's NOT helping him but not getting him to talk. EVERY TIME he gives in when your brother cries? Is REINFORCING your brother's behavior.
You can tell your dad that he needs to work with him on potty training so that he can play with other kids and not be made fun of.

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions