Photo by: PBS Kids

Television- A Wider View

Photo by: PBS Kids

Television: I could write about its impact on kids and families for days! The issue of how much, when, what kind and how often has been high on my personal agenda for the past two decades. I have achieved “expert” status in this arena, having run a non-profit called FACT (Focusing Awareness on Children and Television) for over four years, spoken to parents, programmers and medical personnel around the world and kept Mr. Rogers on air.

I definitely have a perspective. I am here to tell you that young children do not need to watch TV at all. They need to move, to develop their eye-hand coordination, to communicate, to fall down and get up, to feel, to express themselves. Putting a child in front of a TV is limiting their development, their human potential, their quality of life and can lead to other addictions. While kids watch the tube, they do not use their eye muscles which go from right to left, the very muscles they need to exercise to read!

My youngest son was first a television addict, for which I now assume full responsibility; I often asked him to go to see what was on TV, when I was involved with his two older brothers.

Watch a small child watching TV and you’ll see a child zoned out, in an alpha state, unavailable to respond to others around. TV is build to attract, to keep the viewer connected, to impact him. That is exactly why advertisers spend millions of dollars on their commercials, telling kids they will be happier when they eat a certain cereal or buy a certain toy. Adults have been learning that owning stuff does not make them happy. But our kids are being taught continuously that buying and owning is good for them, will give them more friends, make them smell and look better, and be happier.

There are reams and reams of research available about the effects of TV viewing. Harvard’s Baker Children’s Center shows that corporations are marketing to infants: it’s called “cradle to grave loyalty.” Have you ever heard of the drool factor? Corporations have found that babies can be imprinted with brands by six months leading to their nagging for parental purchasing!

I honestly believe that drastic measures are called for, as we’re all living in drastic times. You’ve got too much on your plates and not enough time to do it all! Put the old play pen back in operation, if you need some time outs. Give yourself permission and make arrangements to exchange times for “personal needs” with other parents, conscious family members, neighbors. Give your kids “open-ended” toys which can give them some stretch and personal imagination opportunities. Ration any kind of screen time. Choose special programs to watch on PBS, cable stations and DVDs. If you decide to be a commercial TV watching family, sit with your kids, be available to explain certain actions and behaviors to them. Answer their questions. Watch for their emotions: fear, anger, aggressiveness, hyper-ness after they watch.

Three bottom line rules:

1. Do not put TV sets in children’s rooms.
2. Choose programs wisely.
3. Do not permit endless TV watching; be aware of what your kids are not doing, while they’re watching TV.

The biggest gift we can give our kids is our attention. This comes out of documented research also! Our kids want it and need it. Consciously determine what kinds of attention each of your children wants. Try asking an older child what kind of attention he/she wants from you. Every child has different needs; some kids are visual, others are auditory or physical. The same kind of attention does not satisfy each one of your children.

Parenting is labor intensive and sometimes not very easy. But, when you know that your kids want and need your attention more than toys, TV, special clothes, other stuff, you become positive and conscious parents, providing the environment which your kids need to grow into their potentially creative, healthy, actualized adult selves.

Alice Aspen March founded and became Executive Director of the non-profit organization FACT, (Focusing Awareness on Children and Television) playing a key role in keeping Mr. Rogers Neighborhood on the air and on PBS. She also created and produced the Emmy nominated documentary, Latch-Key Kids. This show was responsible for the development of extended after-school programs funded by The California State Senate. She has served on the board of directors for KCET-TV Public Broadcasting in So. CA, the Center for the Improvement of Child Caring, and the International Institute of Los Angeles. Her latest book Secrets to Making it Through College and Beyond is due out soon. Read more

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

9 Comments

While this is all well and good, I know when I am at home trying to put a HEALTHY meal together for my child, I need them to be doing something else-not pulling on my shirt in front of the stove. So, she will watch Baby Genius-which is a wonderful program full of kids dancing and singing. The idea of no TV at all is a great concept-but I think it's a bit far fetched for a working family.

YOU ARE SO RIGHT. The true bottome line is ''' raising children is labor intensive'' - . It takes hours and hours of interaction to even begin to allow a child to become who they can be. The BEST gift my 10 year old grandson ever got is a day-care where tv didn't exist. Being the child of a teenager ( my youngest daughter) - he spent more than a few hours in front of a screen before starting day-care at 20 months...

See entire comment

I completely agree!! My extended family believes that I am cruel because I don't allow my children to have a tv in their rooms. I do let my kids watch tv but I limit how much and what they are watching. The commercials are definitely out of hand and they work! My daughter was 5 and wanting a closet organizer and she doesn't even have a closet!

I agree w/ the article as well as the posters (I did no TV when they were infants and limited educational TV as toddlers.. like when I was making dinner). But one thing not touched upon and I feel very strongly about (and no - I'm not a Hippy mom!!) is that children today don't need the gross over-stimulation from all their infant toys either. EVERY toy (bouncy seat, sit and stand table, etc) I mean EVERY toy has lights, noise, flashing stuff all battery operated...

See entire comment

Thank you all for writing; seeing your thoughtful, honest comments is most gratifying. I've spent mega years studying the impact of attention on everyone, old and young. Bottom line is that our kids need our attention more than anything else. Watching our kids and listening to them is vital for them and for us. Eventually, they have to learn how to give themselves the specific kinds they need. We want people in our lives to tell us what they need. This is a life-time process...

See entire comment

Ms. March, I love the very clear message you've given here. You are right on!

Fortunately, I was reared without television, and I learned to love reading. Not a coincidence.

Every parent should hear this message. It may be "impractical" to expect parents to keep children from all television, but even limited time periods when children are encouraged to read, not watch (public libraries are still open, last I heard) can have a tremendous influence on a child's development...

See entire comment

I am in wholehearted agreement with Alice. What I wonder is why, if the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends no television for children under two years old, don't pediatricians ever bring this up at well-baby visits? I think advice coming from one's pediatrician might carry more weight than on-line advice or even that of friends and family...

See entire comment

Dear Joanne,
Hurrah!
Your plea is totally familiar and really deserves mega attention!!!
I've been after Pediatricians to talk about TV for 30 years and for a while, this issue did appear on their agendas. I ask, now, that parents bring this item(your concerns) up to engage in conversation with everyone who interacts with children and families.

Your suggestions about cooking and kitchen time/toys is totally terrific...

See entire comment

Okay I see what you are all saying, but my daughter watches TV and they are not zoned out little zombies. Half the time it is just background noise. My oldest daughter, Miki is very into Dinosaurs so I buy DVD's that she watches. I do not have her watch sitcoms. As for Mr. Rogers, I grew up watching him when I was a child. I enjoyed his show and his calm voice.

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive

Related Questions

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all