28 answers

Texting...... - Bethesda,MD

Hello moms!
I know by posting this I'm going to open a can of worms but I really need to understand the different sides of this story.
My daughter is almost thirteen. Even though she is one of five girls in her classroom, she has managed to get along with all of them, in spite of a few incidents where my husband and I had to addressed them to the principal. The problem my daughter is facing these days is that "texting" is what apparently the coolest thing to do while parents are sleeping. I have a cell phone for my daughter that she takes with her when she has a sleepover with other friends, but she never uses it as toy to be calling or texting other people like the way these other girls do.
According to my daughter they are using this to show off and make her feel bad for not being part of the crowd doing it. When she's been asked why their text messages bounce them back, (I set the phone to not receive only to send text messages), she tells them that we don't approve the waisted time that "texting" requires when she could be reading, doing something more productive or sleeping, but if she wants to do it, she could do it but she will have to pay for them. Besides, if they have something they want to tell her, they could call on the phone.
Now, what I would like to hear from you moms is if am I being "not cool" for limiting this way of "communication" to my daughter with her "so called" friends.
My husband decided to block text messages from our cell phones. We both have been tested by other grown ups about texting, but we don't find it necessary. If he needs to say some thing he call, same with me. Some moms have tried to get me into too but they stop after realizing that if they were asking me something in the text, I called them right back.
Besides that it so disrespectful, tasteless and rude from the person thinking that he is having a conversation with you while texting at the same time.
But, I do want to understand the reasons you moms give your kids "unlimited" or "free" texting.
I do want to understand your reasons for giving Internet access 24/7 on their cells / Blackberry/ I-Phones to your "kids".
Why is it important for "you" parents, that your kids have to have the whole package.
What is the benefit?
One of my good friend's daughter who used to be a model to be followed by all, started to spend so much time posting, sending, receiving, texting and writing on facebook that she ended up being expelled from 7th grade.
When I talk to my daughter about all these gadgets she agrees with me that it does not do any good the misused that a lot of kids do to them.
Before I blocked text messages from her cell phone. The sound of text messages, that I could not get rid of, could have been interrupted piano practice, reading, homework, dinner, you name it!, by lots of text messages. That, by the way my daughter showed them to me later, with only "non-sense" written....
I have a excellent student, and avid reader, a gifted piano player, a great sports player and a very humbled daughter.
Do you think that I am harming her by denying her the _______?_______ of not being part of the group?
Thought?

J.

Just for the record, we do give our daughter entertainment time of their choice. But always in a healthy way.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I want to thank each of you for taking the time to write the side of your story. It seems that all posts have their validate reasons weather they support it or not. There’s not doubt of the benefits and pleasures for texting for some. Like someone said: “What it’s ok for a family might be absurd to another…”
As for myself, I will keep doing what I’m doing. My daughter’s school has a policy that all cell phones must go to the office and they can be picked up after school is over. If parents need to reach their kids, it has to be through the school office and vice versa. If one gets caught with a cell phone will be expelled. The two girls who mainly led the others into the texting at night dare each other to defy the school. They were expelled last Friday.
It’s obvious that the creation of this new “need” is here to stay for a long time but for what I’ve seen and experienced, I think it’s important for people to know why, I still feel the way I feel.
As a mother and as a teacher I see that the creation of this instant way of staying in touch is leading to a number of problems. This new need leads to anxiety (Would you survive without a phone two days?), failing grades and sleep issues not to mention a collective increase of attention deficit disorder. A difference of texting, interrupted task takes longer to complete and seems more difficult, and that the kid doing it feels increased annoyance and anxiety.
With this trend we already authorized a culture of ongoing interruptions and enabled the continuous partial attention as a substitute for full attention. I worry about the effect of texting on your kids as future communicators as well as the bad social habits it seems to encourage. If this is the future, don't you think we "desperately" need new manners about texing to be explicitly introduced at home and at work?
When children, teenagers — even parents — text during dinner or other activities we should be doing as a family, it sort of defeats the purpose of “family time.” In the past I’ve had to asked a few kids, who had joined us for dinner, as young as 10 up to16, to put away the phone because they were texting non-stop under the table. These kids and others still like to come and have dinner with us. They love to talk about their day, the sport they play, their favorite subject…
It’s depressing to hear teenagers trying to run a “romantic” relationship purely through texts and sexts. As a 16 year old was doing it. She told me that her parents rarely talk, they text each other. She was right! Her mother was constantly texting him giving him the steps on how to cook the meat on the grill!, from my kitchen to the patio where I could see my husband annoyed already for trying to have a conversation with him! And she thought she was having one with me. All I could get from her was: Ugh… aha… yeah…
However, I still agree that individuals should be free to text . . . just as others may be free to decide not to associate with them on future (informal) occasions because they would not be missed if they were absent.
Do I worry about my kid behind in texting skills in college? Not in a millions years! When they’re in college or grad school, they will still text, but much more selectively and subtly. Nothing compared with the average of 2,539 text messages for boys and 4,050 for girls in a month between 12 to 17 years old. It’s 85-135 text messages a day (2010, Nielsen Analytic Company). You’ll be surprise about how the numbers drastically reduce in college students and older groups. Besides how long did it take your kid to learn how to text? Years?
Now think about the ridiculous sidewalk/malls accidents that occur as a consequence of texting. Funny right? Now think of an accident your carpooling friend caused for texting while driving with you child in there. Not funny right?
Wouldn’t you then, raise the question as to whether the general population is sufficiently intelligent to use texting effectively and safely! I would.

Just food for thought…

Featured Answers

I have a 12 and 13 year old that both do not even have cell phones. They have no reason to, at that age they are still children and need a lot a supervision. My son got an ipod for Christmas and started using it for texting, however we got rid of that App.
I don't care if I'm considered a cool mom or not. I'm a good mom who looks out for her kids and does what she thinks is right for them. I want my kids to be more attached to their family then friends.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

you are not harming her one single bit.
i work part-time at a restaurant, and i teach enrichment classes at the local community college. texting is not allowed in my classroom. i tell my students that they are certainly welcome not to pay attention to the class i've worked hard to prepare for them, but they need to ignore it from outside the door. i will not raise my voice to talk over conversations taking place in my class, and i will not have homer and gilgamesh competing with OMG hes 2 hawt!!
i'm appalled at how many kids sit at a table in a restaurant and text the whole time. i had two last night, ages about 7 and 9. no conversation, little attention to their food or the surroundings or the event currently taking place in their lives. little people just texting away non-stop.
no child is damaged from being denied participation in something that eats their lives.
you're a good mom.
khairete
S.

4 moms found this helpful

I have to say that I'm personally not a fan of texting. I also prefer a phone call. But kids these days (even my 24-year-old) regularly communicate by text. It's just the way they like to chat I guess. And I've gotten used to texting my older daughter. Sometimes it's nice to be able to chat with her when she's working and on break and can't take a call, or if we're somewhere where I wouldn't be able to hear well, like a sporting event.

My junior high-aged daughter has unlimited texting, and uses it alot. But the phone is shut off at night and during school hours. If your daughter is basically a good kid and tries hard (which it sounds like she does) I'd think about relaxing your rules a bit. You can always monitor what they're texting, but like you said, it's mostly nonsense. It's really important at that age not to be the one on the outside. I don't think you're "harming" her by prohibiting it, but it's not helping either if she's the butt of jokes or feeling bad that she is left out. With such a small class of girls, it's going to be obvious that she can't participate. And this doesn't seem like such a big deal that you couldn't give her the priviledge of trying it out.

3 moms found this helpful

I think it's a personal preference. I didn't allow texting til my oldest was in 10th grade---but he has siblings 4 years younger--so they were in 6th grade. But you need to understand it wasn't such a big deal as it is now. My oldest (19 and in college) just got the internet access on his phone for Christmas. The reason my other kids don't have it is because they have no way to pay for it--and I'm not paying for it. I didn't have an opinion about texting one way or another. But the day after I put it on their phones--I was at the high school waiting for my oldest (who couldn't drive at the time). No one was coming out of the school for over 20 minutes and I received a text "In lockdown". You don't know how relieved I was to get that text. He obviously couldn't have called in lockdown--but he could text. So for that reason right there--I have allowed texting. If it ever effected my kids' grades or anything like that (sports, music etc..) I would shut it off. But it hasn't--and I have 3 high schoolers and a college student. It's all personal preference. But I haven't regretted it. It REALLY is this generation's way of communicating.

3 moms found this helpful

Wow, I could have written this post! I haven't read any of the other responses yet, but I can totally see where you're coming from. My husband and I recently spent an evening with some college friends--people we haven't had a chance to get together with in over a year--and BOTH of them were so busy texting, sending pictures to people, and otherwise generally being rude that we both felt quite marginalized. And these were adults!! Personally I do not text, I don't even have a phone that takes pictures! I know, I know, I'm in the dark ages. But hey, I'm happy here! BUT I admit, I don't yet have a teenage daughter. But I was, once upon a time, a teenage girl myself, and I remember keenly that desperation to "fit in." Now, in the '80's, in my junior high and high school, "fit in" had a different definition, basically it seemed to involve hanging out at the mall unsupervised and having friends over when parents weren't home. At the time, I loathed not being allowed to do what others did. Now I'm older and can see my parents had my best interests at heart. I was not permanently damaged by not fitting in. One could even argue that it builds character. But it's tough when you're in the moment! I would stick to my guns on this issue. And even if you were comfortable with her texting, I wouldn't allow it at night when she's supposed to be getting rest. Who needs teenage drama in the middle of the night?! Maybe, as a nerd myself, I don't feel pressure to help my kids be particulary "popular." Trust your gut. You sound like you are doing a great job. Keep it up!

3 moms found this helpful

I am my children's mother. I say NO phones until you need it. So my 18 year old son got one until he got a job. My 15 yo daughter got one when she stayed after school for clubs 2 years ago.
My next one, 13 isn't getting one unitl she goes to the high school. She is homeschooled and in 7th. No need for one.
And number 4. He's only in 4th and doesn't even have a Ninterndo DS.

My son graduated from hs with no cable, no phone, no computer access unless he had a report due, no car until the job and he paid for the insurance.

I am not their friend, I am mom and according to them I am mean, so be it. My son calls me every Sunday and texts me from his phone that he loves me. He thinks I am too lenient on the little ones.

3 moms found this helpful

My daughter is 14. She has limited text messaging. It shuts off during school hours and also at night time. This is how the kids communicate these days...times have changed. I also text message. She does also talk with friends on the phone and get together and have sleepovers and whatnot, so I don't see any harm in the texting. She knows when texting is not allowed, like during homework and at the dinner table. I think that if you limit them to what they cannot do, they may go behind your back and do it - I have seen it. So I make sure that there are limitations and I am very open with my daughter to make sure she makes the right decisions in everything she does.

3 moms found this helpful

If I was caught in school with a cell phone I would have been suspended. What happened to those days? Yes, and what happened to just calling someone? NO, I dont think you are denying her of anything. There is no way my 12 year old would have a cell phone with texting and internet. I dont even have internet on my phone!!! Its too expensive!! Those parents are crazy. I am so glad your daughter is on the same page with you! What a good kid! Maybe once shes older and has a job she can buy all that stuff herself, but then I would be worried about her driving and texting! Eeek!

3 moms found this helpful

This is something that each family has to decide what is best. What is ok for one family may be absurd to another, believe me, I've had hate mail over some of the most stupid topics.

Our daughter has had a cell phone since 4th grade. She is now in 10th. She did not do much texting at all until she hit middle school and even then it was usually to one of us and a few friends.

It is the primary communication now with her and her friends. Hubby and I text a LOT as well. It is nothing for the 3 of us to have thousands of texts per month. We all have IPhones with unlimited texting, data, internet, etc. Her school does not ban cell phones, ONLY during classtime they can be taken up.

I am one of those parents who received a text one day with "ld" meaning Lockdown. I was glad my daughter had her phone and could let me know what was going on. I also received a text once when she was at a party that got out of hand and she knew she did not need to be there and it was before she was driving. SO, I "called" her and said she needed to come home and I would come get her. That way, no one realized she "wanted" to go home.

So Yes, my daughter has all functions of her IPhone enabled. I like it for safety reasons as well. When and if rules are broken or not followed, the phone is the first thing I take away. Believe me, I've not had trouble with my honors student and athlete because she loves her phone and form of communication. I think we've only taken it 2 times since 4th grade.

You just have to do what is right for your family and not worry about what anyone else thinks.

3 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.