L.E. asks from Hermosa Beach, CA on January 17, 2012
Shower/wedding Gift When the Registry Is VERY Expensive.
I don't know why I thought at a shower you get your friend a negligee or a gift certificate to Victoria's Secret.... Then again I guess I'm not very savvy since my husband and I had a tiny wedding and asked everyone for no gifts at all.
My cousin is getting married. I am thrilled that she invited me to her wedding. We don't see that much of eachother but I do like her alot and I hope we will see more of each other as we get older.
The problem is that she has extremely expensive taste. Like, more expensive than registering at Neimens for all the fanciest stuff.
I literally cannot afford to buy her anything off of her registry, and now I am beginning to see that I am supposed to get two presents from the registry--- one for the shower and one for the wedding. Can this be right??!!
I think it's greedy to register for crazy expensive stuff... I'm sure some people think that it's classy, but I just don't.
I usually get people some lovely kitchen stuff from anthropologie if all the good stuff is gone off of the registry (which is very nice, in my opinion), but based on her registry she wouldn't like anything that wasn't gold, silver, crystal or made by a designer.
I'm not sure what to do. I don't want to be rude but I seriously cannot afford any of the items. I have a cap at $100 but I still think even that is a bit much.
Her shower is soon. Can I get her a gift certificate or something?
I don't want to be rude.
HELP!
ps. She will also think that I just didn't want to spend the money on her since she knows that we were both recently given an inheritance. I put every cent of that into an account for my children's college fund- so I'm not digging in to that! Her wedding and shower gifts are coming out of our monthly budget which is super tight right now. But I can't tell her all of this--- and I don't want to offend her!
So What Happened?™
wait, what's the difference between a wedding shower and a bridal shower....? I thought they were the same thing!
also... there is nothing at this store that costs less than $100. It's like registering at prada. And yes, all her friends are wealthy and can probably afford it, so I will be the only one without a gift from this store....
I also don't know anyone else personally that's going.
Grrrrr.
Gosh. I really do wish a Target gift card were acceptable but I'm guessing not.
Thanks EVERYONE!!!!
I guess I'll just go to the store where she's registered (it's not a chain store) and get her a gift certificate. I feel like it's boring to get her a gift certificate but I guess it will actually go to more use in the end--- filling in on things she didn't get, like you said.
I think I just have a problem with the whole expensive registry thing. I know so many people who have crazy expensive registrys, receive loads of gifts, fill up their kitchen with crystal and then get divorced a year later. I'm thinking of one specific friend who sat in her kitchen unpacking all of her gorgeous new gifts and confided to me that she didn't really want to get married but said yes because she wanted to have a wedding and parties. It made me sad because my husband and I had seriously stretched ourselves to buy her a place setting of her desired china... They were divorced less than a year later.
I guess I just feel that weddings and registries have gotten out of control.
I'm not jealous of my cousin. I'm happy she's found someone she loves and I hope they'll be very happy together. She's had a rough life thus far. My life has been pretty easy compared to hers and I am very happily married with two wonderful kids, a home we flat out own, and plenty of ikea, target, anthropologie, and cb2 kitchen things! We entertain all the time and I have never once wished I had something crystal! Once you have kids, anyways, don't you just wish everything was plastic so it wouldn't break? Well, that's my mini rant.
Thank you to everyone who responded. I'm still not sure if I should get a gift for both the wedding and the shower because it seems that there is some question as to that. I guess I will get the shower gift now and see where we are within our budget at the wedding month.
ADDED:
The shower invite is quite fancy--- so I guess that means that the shower is fancy, right? The registry is right there on the shower invite--- the store she is registered at.
There is ONE thing, when I looked, that is under $100 but it is literally something that would cost $3-$5 dollars if it wasn't made by a well known designer. I cannot spend $85 on this one thing and wrap it--- it would be silliest gift ever (here's your $85 toothpick!)--- and honestly hurt my soul to spend so much on something so overpriced. But if, like some of you say, she will be opening gifts at the shower, then I should have something nice and not just a gift card to give her.
I like the cookbook idea.
Thanks, everyone!
ps. yes, when we got married, my husband and I asked for no gifts at all. We run in a sort of artsy, humanitarian, green-living type circle so it didn't seem odd to anyone that we asked for no gifts. We suggested that if people wanted to do something as a gift, then they could make a piece of artwork or have a poem to share at our wedding. Several people created works of art that we have now in our home and several people read poems or played songs at our reception. Best gifts ever, in my opinion.
Featured Answers
R.R. answers from Los Angeles on January 17, 2012
You're not obligated to buy anything off her registry, the items on it are "suggestions" and she should know that. Don't worry about what she will think, give what you feel comfortable with, like a $100 (or less) gift card to the store, and don't feel you need to buy a gift for both if you cannot.
5 moms found this helpful
R.A. answers from Providence on January 18, 2012
If you have a cap at $100( which is what most shower/wedding gifts fall into) I would do a $ 50 for the shower, and $ 50 for the wedding, or whatever amount you want in gift cards from the registered store. Then don't worry about it anymore. Enjoy the day.
4 moms found this helpful
B.B. answers from Missoula on January 17, 2012
You are not obligated to buy items from her registry, they are merely suggestions, nor are you obligated to spend more than you can afford and you do not need to justify the amount you spend to anyone. Choose a gift you can afford that you think she will enjoy.
When I got married I got gifts that cost $10 and gifts that were extravagant. Everything was genuinely appreciated.
4 moms found this helpful
More Answers
K.B. answers from Detroit on January 17, 2012
Get her a gift certificate in whatever amount you can afford and don't worry about it. I'm sure you are not the only one, and if she is offended, she's the one who is being rude. Gifts are not supposed to be expected - they are just that, GIFTS. You accept whatever you happen to receive graciously and not carp about it. To only register for really pricey items in the hope that that is what you will automatically receive is in very poor taste. When I registered for my wedding, I think the most expensive item was maybe $200 and if I didn't receive it, I didn't care. I had plenty of things under $100 (some were only $15 or $20) and I got a lot of gift cards too that I could use toward the items that I didn't get. I did that with my guests in mind, instead of expecting them to spend stupid money just because it was on my registry. And what you choose to do with your inheritance is nobody else's business.
8 moms found this helpful
R.R. answers from Los Angeles on January 17, 2012
You're not obligated to buy anything off her registry, the items on it are "suggestions" and she should know that. Don't worry about what she will think, give what you feel comfortable with, like a $100 (or less) gift card to the store, and don't feel you need to buy a gift for both if you cannot.
5 moms found this helpful
S.S. answers from Chicago on January 18, 2012
Get a gift certificate for her in whatever denomination you can afford from the store that has her registry. then she can purchase what she wants. and yes it is rude to have only things that are more than a hundred dollars.
5 moms found this helpful
C.O. answers from Washington DC on January 18, 2012
L.:
You do NOT have to buy her ANYTHING from her registry. Those are items she "wishes" to have - a suggestion. Do some searching - you might be able to find a similar item somewhere else.
it doesn't matter if you came into money and what you did with it. that is NONE of her business...none at all. If you offend her? that's HER loss - not yours. You stick to your budget and purchase what you think she'll like or what you think she'll need....
4 moms found this helpful
L.E. answers from Provo on January 17, 2012
Don't you dare break you budget just because she doesn't have a clue. Give her a check or a gift certificate for her favorite store and stick to your principles. It is up to her to be grateful for your gift and use it for good.
4 moms found this helpful
R.A. answers from Providence on January 18, 2012
If you have a cap at $100( which is what most shower/wedding gifts fall into) I would do a $ 50 for the shower, and $ 50 for the wedding, or whatever amount you want in gift cards from the registered store. Then don't worry about it anymore. Enjoy the day.
4 moms found this helpful
B.B. answers from Missoula on January 17, 2012
You are not obligated to buy items from her registry, they are merely suggestions, nor are you obligated to spend more than you can afford and you do not need to justify the amount you spend to anyone. Choose a gift you can afford that you think she will enjoy.
When I got married I got gifts that cost $10 and gifts that were extravagant. Everything was genuinely appreciated.
4 moms found this helpful
A.W. answers from Seattle on January 17, 2012
A gift card to the store the registry is held at would be prefect. That way she can fill in what she didn't get. Do what you can afford.
3 moms found this helpful
Email