12 answers

One Year Old Feeding Issues

My daughter is going to be turning one at the end of this month. Since she will be moving on to real milk, I want to know how other Mom's dealt with the issue of ending the formula and starting with the milk in a cup or sippy cup? Is there an easy way to transition? Should I keep feeding her 1/2 formula, 1/2 milk or go cold turkey on her? Any advice is appreciated.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks for all the advice! I did what everyone generally told me to do which is slowly add the milk in. So far she is drinking 1/3 whole milk with 2/3 "next step" formula (from a bottle). She seems to be taking it easily. I had another side issue though. She never drank from a sippy cup effeciently so I can't get her to drink the milk from one. I am hoping to get that all worked out though. I really don't want to deal with her getting attached to the bottle and not using a sippy cup. Wish me luck!!!

Featured Answers

I have always switched over to all milk and only put it the cup. If she wants a bottle then she would only get water in it.

More Answers

Cold turkey didn't work for my 13 month old son. We had to start with 3/4 formula, 1/4 milk and make it warm (the way he was used to formula after breastfeeding). Over about 2 weeks we slowly changed the mixture until he was on only milk. At 13 mo, he LOVES whole milk and drinks 2-3 sippy cups a day, usually at meals. If your daughter REALLY doesn't like milk, you might try the drinkable yogurts (Stonyfield Farms makes a baby version with whole milk). My son loves those and would take them from a sippy cup before learning to drink milk from there.

1 mom found this helpful

well the first quetion would be does she drink anything else out of a sippy cup? if the answer is yes - then start putting formula into a sippy cup now - then ease her onto milk. try to get her down to one bottle a day (maybe the nighttime bottle) and then slowly ease her off of that. I never mixed the formula and milk - but you can - just mix up the formula like you normally do - then add the milk - and yes start at 1/2 and 1/2 and then go backwards. i actually sort of did it cold turkey - and it worked for my kids - but i kept formula as a back up so that if they refused to drink the milk that i could "give in " a little bit and make sure they were still getting their nutrients - make sense? Hope that helps -= and feel free to email me directly with any other questions: ____@____.com

Good Luck!
S.

1 mom found this helpful

I think the way you go about the transition to milk depends on your child. My oldest took his milk straight from the cup opposed to formula from the bottle on the first try and I had no problems after that. My middle child however was very resistant, he would take juice from the cup no problem but not milk. If I put his formula in the cup he was fine though. Even when I would mix half milk with half formula he wouldn't take it! I started with 1 oz milk and the rest formula and gradually weened him from formula. Also, when the cup was becoming more full with milk I would heat it just a titch because at first he didn't like the colness of it. Just cater a method to adapt best to your child and if problems persist consult your doctor. GOOD LUCK AND GOD BLESS!

1 mom found this helpful

I started by getting my son used to water and juice in sippy cups. I would also give him milk in a bottle during the day, and formula for his nighttime feedings. I slowly eased him into less and less formula feedings. Then I started giving him his milk in a sippy during the day, and bottle at night. When he was sleeping well at night, and fine with his sippy cup, I cut the night bottle out, and I just give him a sippy with water.

I have always switched over to all milk and only put it the cup. If she wants a bottle then she would only get water in it.

By the time my son turned 1 he had already tried milk. I gave him milk if we were visiting family and ran out of formula, or if I was getting low, I would but 1/2 formula and 1/2 milk in his bottle. So when his birthday came around I just stopped buying formula. I think I did have th buy a can of that "next step" stuff (you know the kind for toddlers) and transition him a little for gradually. But if you daughter lets you just switch her straight to milk then do that. I warmed my son's milk and put in in a bottle-which I wouldn't suggest. It made it harder to get him off the bottle and he still likes his milk warm (he's 22 months!). I did that b/c he wasn't taking well to cold milk... and I thought I'd do whatever it took to get him to drink it. Good Luck.. your daughter will tell you what she wants and doesn't want.

I had the same concerns with my little boy and it was a non-issue for us. I went cold turkey one day at lunchtime and he did pretty well. He took a bit of milk out of the cup but wanted his bottle. I always started lunch with a cup first then went to the bottle - it took a little less than a week & he was only on the cup. I called it success. I continued his bottle at other feedings until he was comfy with the lunch cup - then did the same for dinner, brkfst and late night was the last to go. He had been using a sippy cup for water/juice for a few months, so the cup wasn't a new experieince. I think that is a big factor! Also, I bought 4 clear blue cups specifically for milk. They look different than his juice cups. After a while he knew that milk was always in a blue cup and could decide which he wanted, juice or milk when he needed a sip between meals.

When we switched from formula to milk we went cold turkey in a sippy cup. Formula was for bottles and milk was for cups. Although I will admit that mine were off formula before their first birthday...as our doctor instructed.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.