L.C. asks from Albany, NY on March 08, 2007
Losing Things
My daughter is 11 yrs old and she CONSTANTLY loses things. It can range from everything from her snow boots to her cell phone. She is constantly leaving her lunchbox at school. Forgets her clothes at her Dad's or Aunt's when she spends the night. And no matter how many times I tell her she needs to be more responsible, she still forgets something the following week. I have yelled, I have told her she is too old for this and last night I even went as far as limiting her TV time to an hour because she forgot her cell at school. I don't know what to do. It's not even just the fact that she loses the items, but the WORST part if it's usually something she needs, ie:hat, scarf, gloves, etc and I end up having to purchase new ones. I have threatened to take her allowance for the items but she just says it's ok, I know I shouldn't have lost it. So that doesn't seem to affect her. HELP! :o(
So What Happened?™
I got a few possitive ideas, however I felt some of the mother's were "judging" me versus trying to help. One pointed out the fact that we are a single parent home and said that may be contributing to my daughter losing things and one was in my opinion somewhat offending saying......Here's a theory .......don't buy an 11 Yr old a cell phone. I came here for advice, not to be judged.
Featured Answers
A.M. answers from New York on March 10, 2007
She is pretty old to be so irresponsible. I know this may sound harsh but if it is things that she needs like a hat or gloves you should make her go without for a little wild to try to teach her a lesson. I would not keep buying those things I would make her find them. And if you have to treat her like a 4 year old and tell her to put those things in her jacket sleeve when she takes her jacket off then do it. If she loses or forgets a cell phone maybe she needs to go without it for a while until she learns resonsibility.
More Answers
J.F. answers from Albany on March 09, 2007
Hi L.-
One of the ways my son's AD/HD manifests is VERY similar to what you've described. I would certainly speak to your pediatrician about it. It's really frustrating because kids with ADD or AD/HD are able to focus on certain things, and not others. It may not be her fault, and you are right to hold her accountable, but maybe you can find some ways to be proactive.
If I could make a few suggestions, I would start with Dad keeping his own set of clothes for her. It didn't work for me, but my sister's ex does, so you might try it. After dealing with missing clothes for too long, I always wrote out an index card with what I was sending over and stapled it to the bag. That put Dad on notice that I was keeping track, and it made it very easy for him to say "do you have your striped shirt?" or check the bag himself. And don't send her in stuff you will miss if it doesn't come home (been through THAT).
I know she's 11 but label the heck out of EVERYTHING, like you would if you were sending her to kindergarten or summer camp. That way you are enlisting the help of teachers, bus drivers, etc. without singling her out that she's losing stuff. They'll find it and just naturally return it to her. You can run off a set of computer labels very easily and just start sticking them.
Also, make sure to help her keep REALLY organized. I keep a bin by the front door with only ONE set of hats & mittens per kid, that way you know quickly if they are there or lost. Chances are good you'll have a stash of spares, but keep them someplace else, or she will rely on you to just replace them all the time without looking around first. I would scale her room down, too and again label EVERYTHING. It will help her to keep herself organized if she knows exactly where everything goes and where to look if she can't find it. Also, too much stuff is really chaotic for kids in general, I think.
Also, every night, together check her backpack and make sure it is REALLY organized and keep the extra stuff down to the bare minimum.
With this kind of problem, and you being a single mom (again...been there!), you really have to choose your battles, so if it means that she doesn't get a cool lunchbox anymore and has to use brown bags, so be it. I used to have my son color on and decorate his bags while I made dinner, it kept him busy and made the bags a little more fun.
Also, I know it really matters to girls her age, but take an inventory of how much stuff she really has, like shoes and bags and hair stuff. If you took a Saturday and together picked out say 3 sets of each to keep out and put the rest in a bin in YOUR closet (or whatever, just not where she has access to it), then she can use those for a while and when she wants a change you can "go shopping" in what she has and make a one-for-one trade.
I hope this helps! Again, I would check with the pediatrician just to be sure there isn't something else going on. If it's causing upset in your household and you've done everything humanly possible on your end, ask your Doc.
Best of luck-
Jen
1 mom found this helpful
C.H. answers from New York on March 09, 2007
Honestly, it seems like a pretty trivial issue in the grand scheme of things. As frustrating as it might be, because my husband is the same way, it's just who she is. She's not doing it on purpose or to upset you and it's not that she really doesn't care. She seems more like a go-with-the-flow kind of girl, which is exactly how my husband is. He never thinks anything is a big deal, he always says it will all work out - and guess what? It really isn't a big deal and it WILL all work out. I wouldn't go so far as to buy new things that you think she NEEDS, if you stop buying new stuff, she may realize to remember those things because there won't be another one. No kid ever died from not having a scarf or gloves. Stop being mad and punishing her over something that's not the end of the world. Maybe with less stress on her, she will remember her things.
C.B. answers from New London on March 09, 2007
make her go without she'll learn
J.D. answers from New York on March 08, 2007
L.,
If she is willing to pay for replacements out of her own allowance, then you can try taking her up on that, and see if the reality of that makes a difference. Of course, it can't be done with essentials like a scarf or gloves, but take away things she isn't responsible enough to take care of. Cell phones are expensive. If she can't take proper care of it, then maybe she's not mature enough to have one.
You can also let her go without, occasionally. If she leaves her homework at home, let her get a zero for not handing it in. If she forgets her lunch, then let her be hungry that afternoon. Sometimes we need the consequences of our actions to remind us that we have responsibilities.
Jess
A.M. answers from New York on March 10, 2007
She is pretty old to be so irresponsible. I know this may sound harsh but if it is things that she needs like a hat or gloves you should make her go without for a little wild to try to teach her a lesson. I would not keep buying those things I would make her find them. And if you have to treat her like a 4 year old and tell her to put those things in her jacket sleeve when she takes her jacket off then do it. If she loses or forgets a cell phone maybe she needs to go without it for a while until she learns resonsibility.
K.C. answers from New York on March 09, 2007
I don't suggest taking Tv. for cell... It doesn't have to dso with the issue. Set a boundary where she can't take the cellphone to school for a couple of days and it has to be used on the the spot it belongs. She can't walk around with it. She has to use it with the outlet charger connected to the wall. That would be a real punishment and constantly remind her why she is having to talk on the cellphone that way!!!
Don't purchase anymore!!! SHe needs to use the same hat and scarf for the week and have her tell you where she is going to keep it outside of home and where she will return it when she arrives at home. It seems as if she doesn't have aroutine or place for things. Consistant routine is an organized and well thinking person. Practice memory exercises. Give her a checklist of things she takes away from home and make her check them in and out. SHe will never lose or forget things!!!!!!!! Let me know if any of these suggestions work. HArsh but will work.
M.C. answers from New York on March 09, 2007
I had a similar problem with my daughter, she would loose things the same way when she was about 9 or 10 she is now 12 and I don't have that problem anymore, well it's not as bad she's become more responsible...the technique i used was to not replace the items, one year i ended up buying 5 school uniform sweaters one year, when the new school year came in i refused to buy her a new one, the same thing with hats, scarfs, gloves, jewlery etc.. it was painful to watch her suffer thru it and listen to the complaints but it taught a lesson and she got alot better a keeping up with her things. i know it's a bit harsh but it worked!
C.K. answers from New York on March 09, 2007
well here's a theory, don't give an 11 year old a cell phone. Also, aren't they not allowed to have cell phones in school anyway? Especially if she is that irresponsible why would you reward her with something that she is obviously to young to deal with the resposibility of?
Email