L.F. asks from Newport News, VA on May 27, 2008
Is a Trampoline "Low Impact" Exercise?
Hi ladies,
we just bought a trampoline for our three children and it seems like a great way to exercise...my question, is it really low or no impact? I have a problem with one of my knees and I've been a little leary of jumping on the trampoline because I have further injured the knee before trying new exercise. My husband assures me that it shouldn't hurt my knees...it just seems to me that your legs would absorb alot of the pressure as you are jumping. Any smart mom out there know for sure before I try it again?( the only time I used it I felt that my knee was feeling some pressure, but I had bumped it earlier in the day, so may not be related).
Blessings,
L.
More Answers
L.R. answers from Washington DC on May 27, 2008
If you've already got a problem knee, and have injured it previously while trying new exercises, please ask a doctor for professional advice instead of taking our word here for whether this is OK for your body! The question here isn't "Is this low impact?" it's really "Is this appropriate for ME, even if it is technically low-impact?" Why risk your knee? A blown-out knee affects you for life and could end up requiring an operation. Besides, a trampoline may seem like great exercise, but how much time will you really spend on it, will you do it consistently, and how many calories do you think it'll really burn unless you do it frequently? Ask a doctor about the trampoline, but consider water exercise (like the person below recommended)instead. I've heard terrific things about it from people with bad joints and/or backs.
2 moms found this helpful
E.T. answers from Washington DC on May 27, 2008
I think a trampoline is low impact as the springs are taking the impact, but I would think that you could still put uneven pressure on your knee or you ankles.
If you have a prior injury to your knee, I would likely wear a soft brace on it when using the trampoline until you were comfortable with it.
Signing up for water aerobics or something along that line might be more appropriate though.
1 mom found this helpful
D.S. answers from Allentown on May 28, 2008
Hi L.,
Here are two web sites that may answer your questions:
http://bouncebackfitnesschair.com
http://www.starboarding.com/04_rebounding_solutions.htm
hope this helps. Good luck. D.
1 mom found this helpful
J.S. answers from Washington DC on May 30, 2008
I have read about the little type trampolines called rebounders. There are great benefits to using one but you just bounce gently, don't jump. You could do it on a big trampoline, but probably not while your kids were on it. J.
1 mom found this helpful
D.G. answers from Washington DC on May 28, 2008
I had both legs broken and both knees "renovated" and as a former gymnast I would tell you not to jump on that trampoline. Yes, the springs absorb alot of the bounce but your knees are going to have to do some major work to stay balanced and stable. Best case scenario you do a little bouncing and have a some sore muscles, worst case involves an emergency trip and an orthopedic surgeon. I am not trying to scare you, but you definitly need to consider seeing an orthopedist before you start bouncing. Sounds like an orthopedic visit might be in line anyway.
1 mom found this helpful
M.H. answers from Washington DC on May 28, 2008
Hi L. It is wild I checked this out today cause I was talking to my son about the trampoline.I learned in high school to stop on a trampoline you bend you knees and you almost come to a complete halt with out any damage to your knees.Try that and let me know how it works
1 mom found this helpful
A.P. answers from Washington DC on May 27, 2008
I imagine that it would be considered low impact since it has give when you jump, unlike say jumping on the pavement. Maybe you can try it again when your knee is feeling the best it can and start off easy. Oh and maybe when your kids aren't on it since it seems they are harder to jump on and its easier to fall when there are multiple people on it. Have fun!
1 mom found this helpful
P.F. answers from Washington DC on May 28, 2008
I would not consider the trampoline low impact at all. My legs hurt after I get off mine. I jump on it with my kids and it can be dangerous at times depending on how hyper they are. There have been times where I have jarred my legs, arms, and fingers just from me going down as someone else is bouncing up. I will sometimes just run around or walk fast around the outer edge of the trampoline. You could try that but I would avoid the bouncing. My mother-in-law has very bad knees and hips, her doctor recommended the gazelle for her exercise. It is the only equipment she has used that doesn't hurt her. She has seen results with it. I see these at yard sales and on freecycle all the time. Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
Email