How Would You Say This to a Defensive Friend?

Updated on December 20, 2012
A.J. asks from Norristown, PA
19 answers

I have a friend who is sort of harsh in some ways. Like, she's my good friend, we've never had a fight, she's smart, funny, we have tons of friends and interests in common. I'm nice by nature so I don't phrase things in ways that are offensive, so she's never been mad at me, but she's often in "tiffs" with other people who have offended her...she's abrupt and "mean" at times (to everyone) but I just let it roll off, because I don't really mind. That's just her. For an example, she has proof-read a bunch of my work and I never get offended at her unnecessarily snarky corrections, but she would never in a million years even let anyone critique her work because she would "know more" if you get what I'm saying. I actually did once say, "Hey, just fyi, I don't mind since I know you, but for OTHER clients, you should watch the tone in your corrections, people want to be corrected, not insulted" which she actually took OK because she was trying to build a freelance client base for proof-reading, and I said it really carefully with attention to detail..more so than here... She really is a good friend, but I'm just setting the stage here.

***Let me edit to add a little, since this is sort of skewed to look like she's HORRIBLE, since it's only pertaining to the problem I'm asking about...but she has been there for me for many problems, I'm close to her whole family, she's wonderful to my kids, comes to every birthday, I'm not "submissive" as suggested in one post, I'm just not very uptight unless people do something wrong to me-which she never has. She's just a bit snippy at times and now addicted to phone...:

SO back to question: She has become that person so glued to her phone that it's full on rude. At firs it seemed like it was because the phone was "new" but now months have gone by...Like, we met for girl's night out, and we were the first two to arrive, and for the whole half-hour before people came, she would literally take her turn talking, and then when it was my turn to talk, it was time to check her phone, so there was no way to make eye contact. I'm that type of person who leaves the phone in my purse and only checks it when there is a lull in activity and no one's talking to me-in case something's up with my kids. She's doesn't have kids, she's on FB and checking messages and texting. This is the new NORM for her as of the last six months or so when she got her first iPhone (we've been friends for 6 years) and she ALWAYS does it. She comes over, she's glued to the phone, zumba is over, she's looking at her phone right away, so I give up and just leave instead of chatting after class, you're out as a group for dinner, and she's looking at her phone the whole time, looking up stuff online, reading everyone funny texts people are sending her......etc. You start to feel like sort of a nerd just biding your time while this person tends to her phone.

So ANYWAY, due to her very defensive nature, I don't see a way to mention it, so I haven't. Would any of you? And if so, JFF, what would you say if you didn't want to poke a snake so to speak? I've sort of resigned to just accepting it...but I'm just curious what you all would do....

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Hanover-I have done the stop speaking thing-sometimes she notices :) But texting her-now that's FUNNY!

Oh, Cheryl, I'm sure your nicer to your real life friends than you are to the people who hold mutually antagonistic and opposing political/gun beliefs on this site.

Yeah, Dawn, the distancing is sort of happening. I guess I was sort of letting it slide because she does it to everyone...and she doesn't speak meanly to people so much as abruptly or snappily (very opinionated and knows the most) at times...hard to describe, but I know some people like that. But yeah, it's getting a little old...

Nice assumptions Leticia. Probably the reason it annoyed me so much is because I've had exactly two girl's nights out this year, both when I was able to put the kids in a holiday Kid's night out program. So I really wanted to talk. My time out with people is EXTREMELY rare. Yes, I go to the gym, another selfish outlet, and that a rare place I see friends in person other than in child-related activities. I am a FT homeschooling single SAHM mom of 3. I do spend time with my family.

Featured Answers

S.T.

answers from Washington DC on

that's a tough one. i too have no patience for people who are so involved with their smartphones they ignore people in front of their faces.
but i've actually caught myself doing it sometimes. switching off care for my terminal mom with a brother means we are constantly texting the other one with updates and questions, and i'm too paranoid to let it go.
this post is a good reminder not to let it become a habit.
the obvious answer is to have a light but honest conversation. it does get to be more of a pickle with a prickly person like this. i think i'd be opportunistic, looking for just the right opening and throwing a suggestion out there. if she's as sharp a cookie as you say, she might just get it. if not, i foresee a drift.
good luck!
khairete
S.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from St. Louis on

use humor.....the next time she's on the phone, lean over & pretend to cut with a scissors. & then say, "time to cut the umbilical cord. Let's talk!"

2 moms found this helpful

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.K.

answers from Philadelphia on

I'm not very confrontational, even with my friends. If she started checking her phone while I was talking, I would find it rude and just simply stop speaking. I'd actually probably text her my part of the conversation, so she gets the point but its maybe a little funny. Well, funny to me at least.

14 moms found this helpful

B.C.

answers from Norfolk on

Next time you are standing there waiting to get a word in edgewise while she's glued to her phone, try texting her:

"Hel-LO!!! I'm right over HERE! YOO HOO! Larynx not working?!? LOL :-)".

If she doesn't get it after that then I'm afraid she's just not that into you.
I find it difficult to hold up one end of a friendship when the other is just not interested.
Your only option at that point is to look for new friends and let this one go.
She's largely absent as it is.

13 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

☆.A.

answers from Pittsburgh on

Hmmm...tough situation.
You know her better than anyone here.

I think when people get iPhones they get carried away with being "plugged in" and "connected" at all times.
It usually fades over time. So maybe give it more time maybe? But 6 months...

The friendship--Is it worth giving it more time? If not, text her after you walk away at Zumba next time, something like "call me when you're not busy with your phone!"

(Oh--it also sounds like some people need to reach around and get the stick out of their butt! But that's another topic entirely.)

7 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D..

answers from Miami on

Added - Btw, A., I'm glad you aren't submissive on this site to people who are nasty to you.

Original:
I couldn't be with a friend who, after spending every moment I am talking after she has had her say, gets on her phone and ignores me. It's a very selfish thing.

And why do you really want to be friends with someone who talks mean to people? I don't get it...

If you feel you MUST be friendly with her, then cursory friends, okay. Friends who you are close to, no. Do you really WANT to be with someone who thinks so much of themselves and so little of you? Why live life like this?

You don't have to "break up" with her, but you can be "too busy" to go anywhere with her. If she asks why, tell her that you are tired of being last on her priority list, with her phone even taking priority over you. If she gets defensive, for heaven's sake, walk away.

I mentioned in an earlier thread that there were worse traits in friends than tardiness. This is OH so much worse.

Dawn

7 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.W.

answers from Portland on

I think Dawn kind of said exactly what I would have suggested.

It *is* rude to be so connected to the phone when one is out. I don't think it takes any special skills to concentrate on a conversation if you care about the person. We have a friend who texts constantly, and he's someone we don't see much because of it--he's simply not interested in extending himself beyond engaging about him.

If you do want to address it, wait for her to invite you out and then let her know what's up. "I'd love to go out with you, but not your phone. It seems that it gets more face time than I do!" Say it in a friendly, upbeat way and then, let her sit on it. If the friendship is important to her, she should 'bite' and ask a follow-up question; either 'what do you mean?' or "yeah, I know, I'm really bad about it".... something. If not, let her be huffy and pissy alone.

6 moms found this helpful

J.B.

answers from Houston on

I say go direct, if she is a bit feisty, I think that's all she'll get. I mean yeah, she will get mad, but so what. That's friendship right? You tell the truth and your good friends stick around :) I mean I get that you are not going to tell her off or would even want to, but this right here is leading to friendship death anyway. So maybe just straight to it 'Hey, it's getting on my nerves that you are constantly on your phone when we are together. What's up with that?" See what she says. Maybe she isn't aware of how much she is on it since she puts it down some to talk and she hasn't realized that she is being so selfish, it happens. I would try to keep it to the point and void of emotion, kind of like how you told her about the critiquing thing, just fyi, this is ticking me off ALOT girl! I have had a friend mad at me before and she would never tell me why just pulled away etc, now that I didn't like. I can take someone who shoots straight and loves me enough to tell me what's up. Good luck!

5 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.F.

answers from Boston on

I love the idea of texting her while she is in front of you. Thats just brillant to me. I am going to do that too!
I also keep my phone put away and just check it to see if my son needs me.
You can text, Oh hi I am having dinner with ......... and she is constantly on the phone. I would love to talk to her and have a converstaion like we used to. I miss her.

5 moms found this helpful

A.M.

answers from Kansas City on

i would take it as a hint that she wasn't that interested in me. which it kinda is. so i would stop talking if she wasn't listening. if it continued i'd probably politely excuse myself. i mean really, don't you have better ways of spending your time than by being ignored? if she asks why you're leaving, just politely say, "oh it's fine, i can just tell you're really busy...we can catch up sometime when you are free." you can so totally be nice about it. just very matter-of-fact. that's the way she is. but i wouldn't keep hanging around waiting for her to give you thirty seconds. (PS, i love the texting her, too! or wait until she's telling a story and then do it...lol!)

5 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.H.

answers from Chicago on

I'm totally shocked you wouldn't speak up about how you feel. You've been on here a while and you don't hold back, EVER; that is not a slam, so don't take it like that!!!!

If it were a good friend of mine, I would say: "What are you in high school, put that thing away". My good friends wouldn't be offended by that at all. I of course can be much more *free* with my words to good friends.

4 moms found this helpful

R.H.

answers from Houston on

It is soooooooooo hard keeping close friends in adulthood. This would hurt my feelings. I would not go out with her anymore for a while. When she invited me or asked of my absence--I would tell her of my hurt that she gives the phone more attention than she is giving the friendship. Good luck, I repeat--close adult friendships are soooo difficult to maintain.

I have been at lunch and have seen three people ALL texting rather than communicating... Why go out at all!!!!!!

4 moms found this helpful

C.V.

answers from Columbia on

Every time she picks up the phone, abruptly stop talking, mid sentence. Just stare at her.

When she says "what's wrong?" Simply say, "I was waiting for you to check that important text."

She'll say, "Oh, nothing's wrong, I was just looking at Facebook."

To which you should reply, "I wasn't finished telling you about _______."

Then she'll probably apologize and ask you to finish. Do so.

The next time she does it, and she will, say the EXACT same things, except after her apology say, "I accept your apology, but I need you to know that it really bothers me when you pull out your phone while we're talking. It makes me feel like you aren't listening and care more about Facebook than our friendship."

Unless she is completely selfish, she will change her ways. If she doesn't, it's time to find a new friend.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.B.

answers from San Francisco on

My boss is exactly the same way. I can never have a complete conversation with him because he's always texting, e-mailing, etc. on that stupid phone. I've even seen him do it in court when he has a witnesses on the witness stand! Doesn't get any worse than that!

I spoke to my hubby about it the other day and I decided that the next time he starts with the phone while I'm trying to have a business-related conversation with him, I'm just going to reach out and take the phone from him like I would a child and continue talking. He's actually quite a bit younger than me; he's only a few years older than my daughter so I DO feel comfortable doing that. It is just sooooo frustrating!

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.V.

answers from San Francisco on

Back away from this person...she is NOT a friend...she is a liability. What's happening with you, that makes you feel like you need to be so submissive?

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.C.

answers from Atlanta on

Personally, I would just say, "Oh, I can see you're busy now" and walk away.

Either she'll put the phone down, or you two won't have the chance to talk anymore. Which would be sad, but I predict that's what will happen.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.

answers from Augusta on

I can not pay attention to one thing for very long, so when I am not doing anything else and just standing there or sitting there talking I HAVE to do something else with my hands. If I don't have my phone I'm fidgeting with something. Maybe your friend has this problem too. I also can't just sit there and look at someone's face , it makes me nervous because that means they are looking strait at me too. I can feel my face turning red when someone is looking at me strait in the eye, when I feel I'm the center of attention. Or maybe it's the novelty of the phone. Just say something like hey can you put ath down for a minute?

1 mom found this helpful

M.L.

answers from Erie on

It is kinda rude IMO. But phones these days are really an addiction! People's entire life is on a little device that you throw in your pocket! I'll share something that my friends do when we go out together and it seems to work, although it's somewhat cheesy :) We meet for dinner and all of the phones go in the middle of the table, face down, on vibrate. The first person who touches their phone has to buy a round. It's kinda wierd if it's just the two of you but if you're with a group, try it!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Philadelphia on

This honestly sounds like something out of high school. Why don't you put this energy into your family, whose bond should be stronger than any. All this time worrying,writing in to this forum etc. could be time that you focus on your family.I am sorry, this is going to sound harsh, but you mention work,zumba,girls night out. When we get older, I have found, its best to have a few low maintenance friends than many high maintenance ones. We all feel bad about
friendships that decline but sadly it's a part of life. That is why I say to put this energy into your own family.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions