S.S. asks from Philadelphia, PA on December 14, 2007
6 Month Old Wakes up 2Xs/night to Eat
My 6.5 month old daughter still wakes up about 2x's/night to eat. The pediatrician said that if I can take it, I should continue to get up to feed her. I am a full time working, pumping mom who is out of the house 12 hours/day. My daughter is a breastfed baby and although she takes a bottle, she likes it when she eats off me. Now that she is getting bigger, so are her pees and I not only have to get up to feed her, I have to change her diaper since they are so full. We've tried letting her cry it out to see if she would go back to sleep but after 15 minutes, but she still cries to eat. Everyone I know says that she should be sleeping through the night. I am still VERY sleep deprived and would like to see Audrey sleeping all night, but I don't know if I should be just accomodating to her individual eating patterns. I personally like the Dr. Sears books and even he says that babies should be sleeping through the night by now, and it may be possible that I am keeping Audrey in a bad habit. Does anyone have any suggestions?
So What Happened?™
Thanks to everyone who responded. I recieved a lot of support from 20 moms! I had an instinct that I should continue to get up to feed Audrey, despite the difference of opinion I've been recieving from my colleagues and my family. Mamasource moms responded they went through the same thing and continued to do night feedings, and their babies naturally stopped without any intervention. I will continue to get up and feed Audrey during the night, and I feel much better that I am not getting her into bad habits.
Featured Answers
H.L. answers from Lancaster on December 23, 2007
Have you tried to add cereal to her bottle? If not then I would try it. I think that the cereal is more filling.
B.D. answers from Pittsburgh on December 16, 2007
Both of my girls were exclusively breastfed and did not sleep through the night until they weaned at 2 years. We found cosleeping to be a huge help. They both sleep through the night now so no it did not create any bad habits.
More Answers
M.R. answers from Philadelphia on December 14, 2007
Maybe I'm just heartless, but have you tried letting her cry a little longer? She's old enough to be let cry more than 15 minutes--my pediatrician claims my 4 month old can be let cry for "as long as it takes". Or you could try reducing the amount you are letting her eat at night gradually and see if she'll give up. The Baby Whisperer would tell you to try a pacifier (ok, your SO will have to do the pacifier, you smell like milk) when your daughter wakes at night and see if that will help her learn not to eat/wake. Not that either of the latter has worked for me, but those are things that are out there in the parenting ether.
1 mom found this helpful
S.C. answers from Philadelphia on December 17, 2007
Hi S., My first daughter woke up a lot until she was close to one year old (she's now 4 1/2) and my second til she was about 10 monts. I wanted to let you know that you're not alone! All kids to not sleep through the night at 6 months. I stayed home with them, so I didn't pump at all. I think, like you said, that while your daughter does take a bottle, she may enjoy the closeness with you. My pediatrian was really great, very knowledgeable about all topics and not judgemental at all. If I had really wanted to change their habits, I bet he would have supported me. But he didn't really seem to think their waking was that out of line until they was closer to 10-12 months. He seemed to say that all kids are different. The thing to try to figure out is if she's really hungry, or just wanting a visit from you :) Once he felt that they were "working me" :) to get a visit, he had a suggestion that worked pretty quick (again, my oldest was about 11 months, so developmetally at a different place) and that I could live with (I didn't like letting my kids cry it out for too long and gave in, messing up the whole thing). He said to go in as much as I wanted, but not pick her up out of the crib during the night, and to stay no more than a minute at each visit. I would hug her through the crib and tell her I knew it was hard but she could do it and I love her, etc. Then I'd lay her down and go. She did cry between my visits, but she figured out that, altough she could see me, it wasn't as satisfying/ worth all the work to get me in there and she got the message pretty quick. With my oldest it only took one night! With my second I did this when she was about 9 or 10 months and it took a few nights. She would still wake sometimes, but it'd be a quick in and out. If your reading this thinking you can't do it for another few months, I think you should feel comfortable to do what works for you and your family. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
R.B. answers from San Antonio on December 14, 2007
My son was 14 months old before he stopped getting up 2 times a night. We are still struggling as he is 18 months now and still gets up 1 time and his little sister is 5 months and she gets up 2 times as well. The only thing we have found to help is keeping him up a little later and letting him have a snack before bed. this seems to help a little and moves the time he wakes up closer to morning wakup time.
You may want to ask your pediatrician about health concerns as well. If your little one has tonsels or adnoids that are too large she may be waking up because she stops breathing. We had to put our son on antiobiotics for 30 days just to get him down to waking up 1 time a night. We may have to have his adnoids removed to solve the problem completly, but we hate for him to have surgery so young.
Just remember that it will get better. Hope this helps.
1 mom found this helpful
J.M. answers from Philadelphia on December 15, 2007
I know you probably don't want to hear this, but her sleeping through the night is not normal for a 6.5 month old. And the fact that you are gone for 12 hours a day, she is just making up for it by wanting to be close with you. I understand that you are tired, it just really sounds like your daughter just wants to be with you. You definitely are not setting Audrey up for a bag habit. If you can tolerate it, I would really suggest co-sleeping. You can get the sleep you need without having to wake up so much to feed Audrey. If you're not comfortable, try putting a pack and play in your room, that way, you don't have to go too far when she does wake up.
Hope this helps.
J.W. answers from Scranton on December 17, 2007
Maybe you should try to feed her more baby food during the day and about an hour or so before bed so that she isn't as hungry during the night. I have a 2 year old who still doesn't sleep throught the night. It's rough, I know.
B.D. answers from Pittsburgh on December 16, 2007
Both of my girls were exclusively breastfed and did not sleep through the night until they weaned at 2 years. We found cosleeping to be a huge help. They both sleep through the night now so no it did not create any bad habits.
M.N. answers from Lancaster on December 15, 2007
Your baby sounds COMPLETELY NORMAL. MOST babies do NOT sleep through the night at 6 months, their stomaches are still small and need to eat. It's not a bad habit. Dr Sears warns against sleep training, he's certainly not for it.
I know how rough it can be.
If you want to try something else try "The No-Cry sleep solution" by Elizabeth Pantley. When the "experts" say "sleeping through the night" they mean 5 hours.
Hang in there. You are doing the right thing by responding to your baby's needs.
N.T. answers from Pittsburgh on December 15, 2007
My son was breastfed and had the worst sleep until a year...he only really got up to eat, but he wasn't sleeping without a feeding for a very very long time. I stuck with it despite everyone urging me to let him "cry it out" and now at 2 1/2 he is an EXCELLENT sleeper despite their dire warnings. Seriousely, he's happy to go to bed with his routine, only occassionally needs the whole "stop playing and go to bed" speech, and even then it's usually once, 20 minutes after his lights go out. He sleeps from 9pm to 11am (yes, 14 hours on average) and even holds in his pee all night to use the potty in the morning.
If yours is in Daycare I assume your bedtime will be earlier (as well as wake time!) but really my point is just that every kid is different, and at your daughter's age her pattern is temporary no matter what it is. Continueing to wake up with her (if you can...I understand just how dificult everything is when you are chronically sleep deprived) WON'T instill any bad habits in her that last throughout childhood. When she becomes a toddler you'll be able to recognise the manipulative wakings as oppossed to the feeding ones you seem to recognise now. Don't despair that this is forever no matter what you choose to do here...no 6 month old has the same sleep pattern as a 1 1/2 year old and kids are more adaptable than you think!
Email