D.C. asks from Peckville, PA on October 19, 2008
Teen Not Wanting to Be with Family
My oldest daughter turned thirteen in June. Recently she does not want to spend time with her family. She doesn't want to go out with us for dinner or to other family gatherings and doesn't even like spending time at home with us and when she is home she is in her room. She is a good kid, active in cross country and track and is an A student. I feel that I have been letting her get away with to much lately. So today I demanded that she go to a family dinner at my cousins and told her she would not be going out every night during the week. She says she hates her family and doesn't want to be around us. I don't know why she feels this way. My husband and I work very hard and try to give as much love as we can. Does anyone have advice on this matter?
4 moms found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Thank you for all your responses. It really makes me feel good to know that it is all about being a teenager and going thru life changes and finding herself. I am glad I am not alone. I will continue to work with her and hope that we could agree on some things. I will also try to give her a little space when needed. Here is a quote I read and oh how true it is - To become a mother isn't hard, being one is....
Featured Answers
M.S. answers from Phoenix on December 11, 2008
Thanks for asking. Teen years, in the throws too--I find comfort in www.parentingtodayteens.org I appreciate the daily advice and his website.
2 moms found this helpful
K.F. answers from Washington DC on December 11, 2008
Yes, hormones! This is a late response, but I second that! I went through some horrible attitude adjustments when I was that age - but in the end, you're the mom! It sounds like you did a good job making her go to the family dinner. I would not let her go out with her friends all the time (they could be negative influences as well) and make certain times for family and certain times for friends....so there is a 'norm.' Like she HAS to eat dinner with her family 3 times a week - she can choose the days...and then if she is good, she can go out with friends on the weekend. If she knows what is expected, then she will at least do the minimum until she grows out of this hard stage. She does not hate you and she will appreciate you sticking with her through this hard time...even look back on it and be amazed at how you put up with her! :)
1 mom found this helpful
N.C. answers from Harrisburg on October 21, 2008
I teach 7th and 8th graders, and I hate to say it, but she sounds like a teenager. there is a time in their young lives that they are embarrassed by everything that is family. Most of the time they grow out of it, just continue to be consistent and don't let her tell you how it will be.
Good luck (I know these can be trying times) =O}
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
L.L. answers from Dallas on December 11, 2008
I am sorry, but I have to disagree with the notion that a 'teen will be a teen' notion.
There are MANY teens who are disproving this idea, and proving it FALSE. My husband and I feel that a family should be close, and communicative, and show God's love to each other and all our children are not spending all their time in their rooms, enjoy talking and spending time with us (most of the time), and continuing to disprove the notion that a teenager will rebel against parental authority and parents in general.
Our kids also get along with each other most of the time and enjoy playing together most of the time as well.
Check out this website:
http://www.therebelution.com/
and (hope that I am NOT stepping on anyone's faith here) emerse your child in the principles of family set forth by God.
Now I wonder how many flaming emails I'll get on this one....
5 moms found this helpful
W.S. answers from Los Angeles on December 11, 2008
I know this is a very late response, but I had to write.
When I was your daughter's age, I did the same thing. I did not want ot be around family, only friends and I was also a good kid, but sometimes good kids do bad things and then they fall in to this resentment phase that makes them rebel even more. Your daughter is very young still and should not have the freedom to make her own choices on family dinners, etc. Be very careful in believing that because she is active and seems to be a good kid that she is OK and it is just a teen thing. I was 13 and started to want to experiment with boys, then 14 came and I wanted to experiment with drugs, I was so lost and had my mom so fooled that I was a "good" kid. My mom wanted me to like her and would let me be and by the time I was 15, I had already had sex, tried Cocain, Crystal Meth. etc. my parents had no idea. I only share this with you because I applaud you that your daughter does not like you right now, I hope that when my kids are teens I can say the same thing because I don't want to be their friend at that time, I want to be their parent. Thankfully, by the grace of God, I was saved through my brother's death and the Lord put me on the right path and today I am happily married 11 years with four amazing children. Although, it was not because of my parents, they remained wanting to give me my freedom, being my friend and letting me live, etc. Check up on her, don't let a day go by that you don't know where she is or who she is with. My husband was raised that way and though he struggled with it at times as a teen, he ended up having great respect for his parents and never broke their trust and never got in to the things that I did as a teen.
Always remember without rules their is no respect and without respect, their is no relationship!
God bless you and your family!
W.
4 moms found this helpful
M.C. answers from Daytona Beach on December 11, 2008
I pretty much agree with all.
If you have a minute or two and enjoy "self-help" books,
Try "Reviving Ophelia" (I'd give you an author, but I'm not sure... Mary Pipher?).
It is exceptionally difficult to become a woman because we tell our daughters they can be anything they want to be - but then they see the glass ceiling and they see the rampant sexism and they experience unbelievable harrassment in school (some of it from even well-meaning teachers) - and - well - they are angry. (At the world. And - mother is a safe person to take it out on.)
A little psychobabble perhaps - but - in my daughter and my case it fit the situation pretty darn well.
Good news: we are very close now and I'd say she is my best friend...
3 moms found this helpful
T.G. answers from Los Angeles on December 11, 2008
D....I sooo feel for you! I have a 13 y/o and she is "busy" all the time, too. There have been so many helpful responses already, so I'm sure you have a good plan in place. I just wanted to add a little to what "Mom C" said about the book, "Reviving Ophelia." My husband and I read the same book and I highly recommend it. My husband is a psychologist and he thought that this book is a must read for parents of girls. I believe (along with a strong Christ-focused family unit) that we as parents can do a lot to remedy the situations with our teen girls if we just have a "gut-check moment" before we respond to some of their behavior. It's so easy to see our teens as rebelious or hateful, when in reality they are just trying to express hurt or frustration...they just don't have the tools to do it. Some of the best conversations I've had with my daughter started with her saying or doing something that I just wanted to wring her neck for! But I took a deep breath and had her elaborate or explain. We as parents always want to talk and give direction or advice, and a majority of the time it just helps to listen :o). My husband and I are no softies, either! We have high expectations of our children and their behavior. We don't tolerate disrespect and we value our family time. We pick our battles...We give her two or three options that are good for us and let her choose between those. It gives her a sense of control in her life and it has lessened the conflict. She enjoys our family outings more and she has even chosen family over her friends on a few occasions :o).
I hope this helps...
Good Luck!
3 moms found this helpful
M.S. answers from Phoenix on December 11, 2008
Thanks for asking. Teen years, in the throws too--I find comfort in www.parentingtodayteens.org I appreciate the daily advice and his website.
2 moms found this helpful
J.H. answers from Boston on December 11, 2008
Hi D.
As a mother of boys(already in their twenties)-my situation was definitely different from yours-but one tip that I think works with all teens--take them for a LONG ride. ALONE. I don't know what is it about the car but my boys seemed to spill it all in the car. Whenever I felt the need-if I thought there might be something important I needed to find out about-Go for a ride.
Hope this helps.
J.
2 moms found this helpful
J.J. answers from Phoenix on December 11, 2008
does " house of hormones " ring a bell? this is all normal. you and i probably did it too we just dont remember. i have boys 2 bio and 5 adopted. we got the 5 as teens but regardless they alos have hormones. my oldest also went throught the hating me and not wanting tolive withme because i had rules and all of a sudden they were stupid rules. the only good thing about being divorced is that i was able to offer him to go live at his dads even thought it broke my heart. he lasted 2 weeks then wanted to come home but i made himstay until the end of the semester. that cause him not to be able to play ffotball the next season when he moved back and of course that was my fault too. he also moved out a month before high school graduation to his girlfirends house. i didnt condone thay type of behavior inmy house and her mom did he was 18 and thought he was an adult and could do anything he wanted. after a week he came over and appologized and wated to come back home and i let him because he was going to be going away but there were more rules then. he was an angel when he came back to a clean house and meals on the table 3 times or more a day. we still ahd occasional tiffs but when he turned 21 he miraculously became my friend. now that he has a baby ( he is 30) he thinks we are best friends. but dont tell his wife that. my youngest bio had some depression problems so he had a harder time but he is my baby boy and we have always been close. that was a big part of the problem with my oldest he thought Jay got more atention than he did.jay and i have always been close and really we always have been friends. he worries about me and is such a good kid. i dont know if it was because i spent a lot more time with him or because he saw me go through chris. always obeys the rules and gets good grades but when he started spending a lot of time inhis room, sleeping etc i knew there was aproblem. he would go through weeks of sleeping all the time, covered his windows and would lie in the dark, not be with firends then when that was over he would run a lot, like 100 miles a week. the docotr thought he was bipolar but finally was convinced that he felt so bad aobut losing time that he was trying to make up the time he lost. he is also a cross country runner and got a full scholarsip to run cross country and also a lot of academnic ones. he is studying nursing and i miss him so bad. he has been coming home about once a month and i go up there about once a month too. thankfully his step dad has no problem with us being so close and fully supports it. the adopted boys all came with a lot of problems but i think that having consistency and rules really helped. that and a lot of love. they all tried to test me so much but it didnt work. now they all congregate here as much as possible. i always wanted a big family but was only able tohave the two and now sometimes i think " what was i thinking" when they are all at home along with astring of friends but then my hsuband reminds me how happy i look when i am cooking huge pans of lasagne or whatever or cuddling on the couch with one of the boys and the others are standing in line for their cuddle time. being a mom is so rewarding but we have to pay a price. just keep the lines of communication open and have plenty of time alone with them whether they like it or not. it may not be your idea of fun but its easier if its a fun activity for them. i always scheduled a time of the week for only one of them we could do whatever he wanted. and the others were not to bother us unless there were borken bones, mass amounts of blood or fire involved. for example. on monday evenings i had onehour of interrupted time with one and on wednesday the other. with my oldest we went for drives out for ice cream and even watched a movie just the two of us. my youngest liked ot go to the park or to go throw a baseball or football around. later on i started runnign with him, ok behind him. the other kids some of them just wanted to lie on my bed and cuddle and talk about anythign they had on their mind. another liked to cook with me another wanted me to teach him how to drive ( that was scary) another went riding horses with me and another would ride behind me on my harley . when you set up time to be alone make sure you tell them they dont have to do anything , maybe just taking a nap in her room . you would be surprised . and for you, silence makes them really nervous. dont interrogate. if they dont want to talk they wont but if you dont talk they find something to talk about. even if it is just " what are you doing in my room?" just smile and say i miss you and i want to be around you so im here. if they say they dont want you there just smile and stay. that drove my kdis nuts. smae with discipline. the rule is that if you lie to me the consequences will be worse because mom ALWAYS finds out. if youtell ther truth it will be less . but i hve to think about the punishment for a while, i make them sweat and once in a while there is no punishment at all but they worry all the more.for example. sean was getting bad grades even though we did homework together he didnt tunr itin. i found it in his back pack 2 weeks later and kept it. i would leave it in there for a bout 2 weeks and so forth. when it came time for parent teacher conference he got "deathly" ill he thought i was going to stay home with him. i left him with my neighbor and he told me before i left that he had an f. i didnt say anythign and jsut took al the assignments to the teacher and explained she put his grade up but we never told him. he creeped around the house wondering if i was going to do anything and turned all his assignments in on time after that. hedidnt find out till report card cam but he is now21 and still wonders if im going to ground him.if it was bad then they got punished right away. mikey one of the adopted boys was caught shoplifiting. walmarts policy is release minors to their parents and not prosecute. while we were in the walmart office we called the police and had him " arrested" they couldnt really do anythign because walmart didnt press charges but the cop was really good about cuffing him and taking him in. we let him stay for a couple fo hours.if we had been able to let him stay overnight we would have. tomy knowledge he has never shoplifted again and wont even go into walmart to this dy. he is convinced that evryone in walmart knows he is a criminal. he is now 22. and he was gounded for a long long time and still remembers he didnt go to his senior prom because he made a bad choice. so good luck. and jsut dont take kids too seriously. they wont talk to you on your terms but if you are there they will eventualy have to talk to somebody. also at that age, having rule is a good idea like not going anywhere every night of the week and if she doesnt want to spend " quality" not scowling" time with the family then she " must be so unhappy" that she shouldnt even tlak to her firends on the phone or hang out with them for a while.
2 moms found this helpful
K.T. answers from Sacramento on December 11, 2008
I sure sympathize with you. i'm sure you are giving your daughter a lot of love. Parenting a teen daughter myself, my oldest is 14, I can relate to the separating from the family thing. I try going in to her room each evening for 5 to 20 minutes (depending on if she wants to talk) and asking her, in a private setting, how her day went and asking some spedific question like, who are you hanging out with at school lately? Or, how are all of the girls your class getting along. Like your daughter, she is an A student and is very self-motivated. I know that she loves us all, but she has definitely reverted to having more alone time. If your daughter says she hates her family, she may really be saying, "I don't think I can be known by anyone in my family". From what I understand about teens is that they are trying to separate to form their own identity, but the contradictory thing that they don't know--and it won't help to tell them in words-is that they need to have a good relationship with their family in order to develop a healthy identity. Have you read the FIVE languages of Love? (Or, "the five love lanauges"). I can't remember the author. It details these love languages, and relates then to our marraige relationship but also, maybe in a separate book, it relates it to parent child relationships. you can google the title and see if you can find it (it may be 10-15 years since publication). Ideas in the book are presented to help you understand your loved one's personality and what kinds of reaching out they will recieve as love. As parents, we are all doing the best we can. I tend to read a lot, b/c my parents sent me away to a boarding school at age 14. So I don't have a lot of family life myself, at that age,to draw upon. I wish you the best. --K. T
2 moms found this helpful
Email