M.L. asks from Irvine, CA on October 29, 2011
Teaching Piano to Kids - Advice
My girls are 4 and 5 and LOVE music. I am not musically talented though I do know how to read music from learning the flute, bells and hymns etc when I was younger. I do not play anything anymore. My girls are obsessed with pianos and I really want them to learn. I am on a very small, fixed income and also am military so we move frequently and are limited on the pounds the moving company will move. There is a possible overseas move in our near future as well. In other words buying a piano, even used, isn't possible quite yet. I am looking for advice on what kind of portable electronic piano would be good for them to start learning on. Also, is a piano lesson in someone else's home maybe once a week enough for them to start learning? Or are they too young to even start that formally? I know many kids start playing instruments at 3 and take lessons. I have not done this with my children mainly because I can't afford the instrument and lessons. But they love it so much I am really making it a priority this year to get them started as much as I can. So I'd love to hear what other moms with limited resources have done to teach their kids piano? One more note - I live in a very remote area right now. I know in my old community I could have taken them to practice at our church for free or signed them up for lessons through the community center but I don't have any resources like that here. I will have to do something at home myself or in another wife's home. There are other moms around who play. Just not many community or city resources. And if we go overseas I will have NO community!
Featured Answers
V.W. answers from Jacksonville on October 29, 2011
My daughter started on (and still uses) a Casio 88 key keyboard. It has weighted keys, and her piano teacher is fine with it. You can pick one up for around $200. An X folding stand runs about $15-20. You can buy a sustain pedal and plug it in as an accessory later. They won't need that right away anyway. My daughter didn't need it until almost year 3 of lessons.
More Answers
T.A. answers from Los Angeles on November 01, 2011
My daughter is 5 and started lessons about a month and a half ago. She loves it and is learning so much from her weekly 30 minute lesson. At this age it is adequate.
We do not own a piano, however we have borrowed a keyboard and at one point borrowed one of those roll-up keyboards as well. When we can clear out some space and have a few extra bucks for a mover, we'll get a piano - so easy to find on free cycle or craigslist. We've already found a bunch (just make sure you take someone who knows about piano tune when you go to look at them) so far. Piano movers cost around $150, give or take.
If they are wanting to play the piano, allowing them to take lessons is one of the greatest gifts you can give them. It is a wonderful skill to have, and I've heard that being able to play piano makes it easier to learn other instruments as well.
S.G. answers from Los Angeles on November 01, 2011
I'm not sure, but 4 and 5 seem a little young, unless they just really pick things up easily. But, check with an instructor.
My daughter started taking lessons in January - she was 8. She started with an electronic keyboard and our instructor said that would probably serve her well for several years. But, eventually we would need an actual piano. And then several months ago, a friend gave her a real piano.
She takes a one hour lesson once a week. And, I can't believe how awesome she plays already! They really do learn fast :)
Good luck!
S.H. answers from Honolulu on October 29, 2011
Google search: "learning piano online."
Or, if you get an iPad... there is an app on it, in which you can learn musical instruments. My friend's daughter, does that. We have that app too. My kids use it.
The app is called "Garage Band." Even pro musicians use this.
An iPad would be a way for you and your kids, to learn musical instruments. Right from home. This app has everything you need to learn how to play musical instruments.
R.J. answers from Seattle on October 29, 2011
We RENT a piano... $55 per month... which is also what my mum did when I was a kid (navy family), although it was much less back when. The first tuning (after free delivery) was free, which saved us a couple hundred dollars right there. It was a minimum of a 6mo commitment. So if you've got the space... that's something to consider.
As far as lessons go... check with MWR. There are often lessons on base for a fraction of what civillian lessons go for. If not, you can try posting an ad on base. Lots of young sailors/soldiers/marines are excellent muscians who would LOVE to trade an hour a week of lessons in exchange for a little beer money and a home cooked meal. Ditto, there are a lot of stay at home spouses who would like the extra income... the Wive's Club would be where I'd look for those types.
Best of luck! :)
T.R. answers from Los Angeles on November 01, 2011
These things are important when purchasing a keyboard:
That it has "weighted keys" meaning it is touch-sensitive, and also that it is full-sized. This will give your girls a closer feeling to a real piano. I have a Yamaha P-70. Yamaha is very reliable and durable. Get a good case - it is worth the money. My keyboard has been on a plane 4 times and moved three times with my flight case. I had to save money for it, but it will last me forever. When not in use my little son plays on it or we use it as a coffee table because we don't have much furniture.
Good Luck!
P.S.: I disagree with the "learning keyboard" that has notes light up. It will end up as a crutch. A plain keyboard is a better investment if you don't have much money and will serve you for a very long time.
V.W. answers from Jacksonville on October 29, 2011
My daughter started on (and still uses) a Casio 88 key keyboard. It has weighted keys, and her piano teacher is fine with it. You can pick one up for around $200. An X folding stand runs about $15-20. You can buy a sustain pedal and plug it in as an accessory later. They won't need that right away anyway. My daughter didn't need it until almost year 3 of lessons.
N.W. answers from Eugene on October 29, 2011
My daughter has a good portable electric piano with 88 keys and sustain pedal, plus a folding stand. We got it at Costco around Christmas for under $200. It was easy for her to take to college because it folded up.
My sons were using an electric keyboard that we borrowed for free from church. The music pastor had several and loaned them out for worship team members to practice on. Every now and then he put out an announcement for used keyboards and would get them free from people who weren't using theirs. So you might want to ask around or put a request on freecycle or craigslist to see if someone has an old keyboard they'd like to pass on to a good home.
If you can read music, you can teach your children using a beginning method book. Lesson books from Alfreds, Musictree, and the Fabers have enough step by step instructions that you could probably use them for the basics. Just teach them one new thing at a time, let them practice and make sure they also PLAY and enjoy making music. Since you don't consider yourself musical, why not find another musical mom who would like to team teach, and get together once a week for a group lesson and some social time?
M.M. answers from Los Angeles on November 01, 2011
I started lessons when I was in the first grade, and for the first couple of years I practiced on a PLASTIC keyboard. It was really to get used to the fingerings, practicing scales, etc. Eventually, we did get a used piano - we too were on a very very very tight budget - but the small plastic keyboard, plus weekly lessons, were all I needed. Also, I started with group lessons (I was one of 4), and progressed to smaller group (2) and eventually solo lessons as I got older. In the end, I took lessons for 8 years, so starting on a plastic keyboard was NOT a detriment. My first job was playing the piano for a church!
Email