A.P. asks from Barnegat, NJ on March 23, 2009
Ocd
My lil' guy is 22months and sometimes very obsessive. He won't wear a bib that is dirty, or looks dirty....If I leave a dirty diaper on top of the changinhg table it HAS to be thrown in the trash. He'll just cry dirty dirty dirty over and over or trash..trash....until I throw the thing away. Also we'll be walking up the stairs and he'll stop to pick up little pieces of fuzz. Or when we're out walking or at a store and he sees trash he wants to pick it up and throw it away. Is this just normal toddler behavior or should I be concerned? Also..what are some ideas on how to break him of this now so that it doesn't become a real issue later in life?
So What Happened?™
Thank you all for your responses. I think I do really KNOW that he's not OCD and that this behavior is normal for a toddler, but I just needed to hear it from other moms as well. Thank you.
Featured Answers
A.B. answers from New York on March 24, 2009
My 22 month old is very similar... especially with the fuzz and cat hair on the stairs! She gets totally obsessed with any pice of hair... she can't just shake it off her hand... she has to yell "hair mama, hair mama!" Until I take it from her.
She also has to close hubby's dresser drawers and if a piece of clothes makes it not close perfectly, she gets upset until I tuck it in so she can close it...
Anyway, I am thinking it's ok. OCD is really only a problem (later in life) if it is gets in the way of living a fulfilling, and stress-free life. I think we all obsess over certain things the way we like it....
As far as how to help him not be so obsessive.... I was told to try to get her dirty with things like play-doh and sand boxes. So, you can try that.... but really, it sounds like all toddlers go through this.
T.H. answers from Syracuse on March 24, 2009
My little guy was a little ocd at that age too. He had a thing with doors, they all needed to be closed all the time. He also was very compulsive about things being neat and clean. Now he is 3 1/2 and all that has gone out the window. Don't worry, this like most other things will pass and change to something else.
More Answers
A.A. answers from New York on March 24, 2009
Hi A., I don't know if you're still reading responses, but one thing it might be helpful to know is that this kind of behavior is, I believe, an age-appropriate developmental phase. Your son is at the age where mastery and control become really important issues. He is having his first experiences with learning that he can have an impact on the world by what he says and what he does. It is very normal and is how kids learn, grow and develop. OCD is an anxiety disorder and the symptoms you describe, while common to popular descriptions of OCD, really do not meet the criteria for such a disorder, so you can rest easy on that score. Hope this helps.
1 mom found this helpful
G.S. answers from Utica on March 24, 2009
Hi A.,
Be thankful for your little guy's fastidious behavior. Perhaps this is just his personality shining through and there are big plans on the way for his future that are only possible with his attention to detail and desire for environmental cleanliness. My four year old son exhibited similar behavior (would want to change clothes if they got wet from a little splash, etc.). He no longer seems bothered by those things he once was, but by letting him be himself, he knows that we respect him and understand that we all have our own preferences. My daughter, who is 10 now, was also very particular about clothing (texture) and sounds. She was "high needs", definitely. Luckily, she was the first child (out of soon to be 6!) and we had the time and attention to help her find comfort in the environment. Now she is an exceptional student and doesn't exhibit any of the particular high needs behavior she did as a small child. We all change and grow. Perhaps we challenge one another for a reason?...All my best to you and your sweet family.
G.
1 mom found this helpful
D.M. answers from New York on March 24, 2009
Most likely he will grow out of it, as it sounds like a phase. And even if he turns out to be a 'neat freak', SO WHAT?? -- I wish even just one of my kids cared about cleaning up ANYTHING.
1 mom found this helpful
N.B. answers from Jamestown on March 24, 2009
You'll appreciate this behavior when he's 16.
Seriously, my 2 1/2 year old is the same way, but I trained her to be that way. I have OCD and her watching me has got her into the cleaning habit. She had crackers on the floor and went to grab the broom to clean them up.
I know you are concerned because you do not want to raise an anal retentive child. Try getting dirty with your child and make fun out of it...then clean up. This teaches them that you can still enjoy being messy. Remember "Monkey see, Monkey do".
Nanc
D.P. answers from New York on March 24, 2009
Completely normal. I was worried with my first son too. He would freak if I left a cabinet door open or a top off of the ketchup. At that age they LOVE routines and find comfort in them and by you breaking it (not putting the diaper in the trash like you usually do right away) it does freak them out. Also from their vantage point things on the floor are very close to them and they can spot them much more easily than we would. Don't worry, enjoy b/c soon enough you will be reminding them to throw things away and pick up their trash...lol : )
Good luck!
D.
A.J. answers from Albany on March 23, 2009
He is being a typical toddler. There is absolutely no reason to be concerned. All of my kids have exhibited the exact same things your son has at one time or aother and like most things it is a phase. Let him have this form of control in his life now. He is simply learning about his environment and looking for ways to control it.
When my kids refused the bib I just let them eat topless . . . it actually is quite nice not to have to wash bibs anymore!
So again, there is no reason to "break him." He is completely normal.
J.B. answers from New York on March 24, 2009
I have 18 month old twin boys and one of them is obsessed over pieces of lint, crumbs, etc on the floor. At an early age we taught them to give the "kaka" to mommy or daddy and thought it was great since they don't eat it like most children try to do. But now he is nuts over it. We went to a play gym and he walked around pointing to all the dirt on the floor and screaming. We went to the Dr office and he went crazy because there were leaves on the floor in the waiting room. I don't think it is OCD, I think it is toddler behavior. I am trying to teach him that it is okay. When he sees it and cries or points, I just say "it is okay".
Good Luck.
S.L. answers from Binghamton on March 24, 2009
My 2 year old was the same way and has grown out of it.
Email