31 answers

My Husband Wants a Dog! (I Don't)

OK so DH wants a dog, a big to medium one, nonetheless, and I don't. He wants a companion to walk and help him exercise (force him to). He wants a pet for the kids to grow up with. I don't want one because DH works all day so it would end up being me who takes care of it and has to clean up after it and train it. I have no time for this, 5 kids, and a house are enough to take care of let alone a new pet. If we already had one and it was already part of the family etc.. that's different. But to have a new pet to raise along with a 9, 6, 5, 3, and 10month old and all the activity associated with it that's too much for me. The kids of course really want one too, so I'm the bad guy. But it's not up to them to feed it, I can make it their job but it's ultimately up to us to make sure it was done. I say wait till the youngest is 3 or 4 and then the oldest will be a teen and the 2nd boy will be around 9-10. But no one wants to wait that long. What has been your experiences with new pets? We're kind of settled on waiting right now, but I'm afraid the subject will come up sooner than later! I'm not a perfectionist, I just don't want any extra jobs on top of everything else thats going on! Thanks for your help!

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Well, thank you for all your insights! Just to update you all and respond to some of your thoughts: my DH and I talk about this without the kids around so we put up a united front with the kids. We all agreed to wait at least for now. I think our ideas about waiting differ right now especially as soon as it gets warm and the baby seems older and less work (a 1 year old less work??!!). BUT with the temps being what they have been my point has been made I just don't know if it will last! My dh is so helpful and a hands on dad with the kids. He would take the majority of the responsibility but again he works all day and I'm home so during that time the dog would be my responsibility of course. The kids are great at doing thier chores they all have something(s) to do. I have a chart and everything. But here's my theory about kids and chores: you either do it yourself and the kids grow up not being cabable adults but its less work on you ultimately on the other hand you give them responsibility and they grow up being good adults, BUT its 3x as much work for you, because you have to issue the directive, TEACH them how to do it, and then make sure they do it! Of course we have to pick the latter we don't want dependent lazy adult children living with us till they are 30, but for a few years its hard work for the parents!!! I think we're doing ok maintaining things right now, but I don't want to add more stuff, especially a living thing. We are done with kids and now I want things to settle down. But I know you all understand that. QUESTION: for those of you dog people what type of dog would be good for us? We have little/no yard but a wonderful neighborhood in which to walk it (we have to pick up poop) and a house that fits us but not much more. Active lifestyle but going here and there not home all the time. let me know! Any advice would be appreciated!
A.

Featured Answers

My advice is that you get the dog. Look for an adult dog that is already trained and good with kids. Puppies are a lot of work.

The reason that I say that you should get the dog is because animals teach children responsibility, caring, and unconditional love. Children need to learn to cherish life, to respect it, and that with life comes responsibility.

Hi, We have a great "big" dog and although I would not trade him for anything now, I will tell you if you have the choice, wait. I am the one who takes care of him and cleans up after him, etc. Another thing to consider is having to take him for a walk with the kids, can you keep trach of all of them while you walk? Mine is so strong, I can't walk him by myself and it is hard to watch him look at all the other doggies walking while he is stuck inside. I will suggest that you get a fence if you do not have one, so at least the dog can run around outside and play with the kids and get his exersize if you do not have time to walk him. Believe me, being the bad guy now is a a lot easier that having to try and suggest finding a new home later on when you realize it is too much for you to handle, and the kids are really attached. Don't feel bad, a dog is a LOT of work. K

Hi A., Wow you must be busy ! I have a suggestion which may work as it did for my sis in law. Do you have friends who have a dog? If you can have them leave the dog with you for a weekend when they are away. Put the entire responsibility on the kids and hubby. They may see it is a lot of hard work and effort in it.That worked for my nieces who were 9 and 5 at that time. I do have a dog and completely agree that it will be too much responsibility for you on the top of everything. Hope things work out
A.

More Answers

Why would you want to get a dog? Because in exchange for getting a dog, they are all going to pick up some slack for you. Your nine-year-old is old enough to take all the childrens' dirty laundry and put it in the laundry room for you. And he's old enough to put clean childrens' laundry away properly. He's old enough to be the one to feed the dog. You will have to tell him to do all of these things. He can also let the dog out into the backyard and let him back in. You will have to tell him to do this, every time, but by the time he is 12 or 13 he will do it without asking, but only if you take it for granted that he must do this, like getting dressed in the morning. He can also clear the table. He will also have to make his bed every morning and put his toys away. You will probably have to show him how to clean his room, one corner at a time. But he is going to have to do it to show he's responsible enough for a dog.

The six year old can put the clean towels in the linen closet if they're kept low enough. She can also set the dinner table. She can put her toys in a toy box and pick up her room and make her bed.

The three year old can use a feather duster and pick up the toys in the family room and put them in a toy box.

Your husband is going to empty the trash every day. He is going to be the one to clean the toilet in the master bathroom. If he wants a dog, he is going to do these extra chores. Period. Or you pick other chores you think he can do that you hate. One or two chores.

This is what they're going to have to do for six weeks to earn a dog (by that time it will be a habit). Not that they stop doing it after six weeks. It's that you privately are going to tell yourself that they have to do these chores for six weeks without arguing before you will consider a dog. Tell them they have to earn a dog by showing increased responsibility at home before you get the dog, not after.

If they refuse to pick up the slack for you, you can say, "Look, the dog adds work. You guys won't even do your own chores."

If you have a fenced-in yard, half the work is already done. Then you need a crate. For the first couple of weeks, you will be supervising a puppy (gate the kitchen, in case of "accidents"), and putting the puppy outside every half hour. When she pees or poops outside, praise her and give her a treat. Give her attention.

As for breed, that depends on the size of your yard. We got two dogs because border collies can be high-strung and they make it their job to keep each other in line. And if the cat slips out they shepherd her back in. But I wouldn't recommend a border collie for everyone. Just don't get a beagle. They're small but they're definitely outdoor dogs for folks who are always outside.

Some of your smaller dogs are pretty stubborn, like Dachshunds.

Newfoundlands are great dogs, although they drool and shed.

You are right, though, the kids are too young to be relied upon to take care of an animal. That's simply not realistic, unless you live on a working farm.

Who walks the dogs? Me. About 15-20 miles a week (except THIS week! Brrr!). It does wonders for their behavior. Even though they poop in the back yard, they still need a walk. It also does wonders for the waistline.

It really adds to the joy in the house to have pets.

2 moms found this helpful

Sorry to say but, I vote YES for a dog. I think every child should grow up with the love and friendship a dog has to offer. I also look at a dog as a built in security system. You could have a 5 pound or 75 pound dog. It is proven that "bad guys" will go to the house that doesn't have any dog-even a little yippy thing. Don't get one until late spring/early summer. Nothnig is worse than standing outside with a 10 week old puppy trying to pee in zero degrees!
Now, I HIGHLY recommend getting an adult dog 1 to 3 years old from a rescue organization or shelter. Most come trainned to some degree and now "piddlle" on the carpet to clean. Rescue organiztions can match up the ideal dog to your family.
Now,will having a dog really make your husband walk him???? Only time will tell.
Good Luck!!

1 mom found this helpful

A.
I'm exhausted just reading about all you have to do! It's a shame that you're the bad guy - this should have been something discussed b/w the two of you w/o the kids to avoid this - now if your husband says no then the kids still blame you - I don't blame you one bit - it's so much extra work - we have 2 cats and 3 fish - the cats came before the kids - I love them but it is another worry, esp when we want to go away - and they don't involve as much as a dog - I remember my mom not wanting more pets and it took maturity to understand that not only did she have to do the work but they and she got most attached to each other and it was hard on her - I'm also thinking - your husband wants a companion?!!!!!??? it seems he has lots of wonderful companionship right there - assuming he's an involved dad - having said all of that - what if you waited until summer - the kids will be off school and he can take some vacation to stay home and help w/ training the puppy - tell them it's on them and don't let them slack - or what about a slightly older dog that's alraedy trained - so many of them need good homes and are good w/ kids - good luck - please post so we know what happens!

1 mom found this helpful

Whatever you decide, please don't get a dog with the thought that you can "find a new home for it" if the kids won't take care of it. What is that teaching them? A pet is a living thing--not an extra-curricular activity that they can quit once it isn't fun or interesting anymore. Of course there are situations when it is necessary to find a new home for a pet--allergies, aggression, relocation, etc.--but it shouldn't be a built-in "out" for the family if things get too tough.

1 mom found this helpful

I always wanted to have a big dog and my husband didn't but since i was the one who i to care for it with two kids at the time i didn't think i could handle it so we settled on a jack russel terrier which can be easiely crate train then after we got the dog and adjusted i got pregnant with my third but the dog really isn't any more work but i got a dog that fit are families personality the dog is active but as long as it gets played with it is lazy...so with a five and a three year old to wear it out becasue it basicly runs around with them it also rest when they do ....the only problem i have with my dog is that he doesn't think my husband should sit next to me or hug me or anything.....

I completely understand your concerns. We have a 4 year old english mastiff (very large dog), and a 9 month old daughter. Our dog is a great family member and we couldn't imagine our lives without her, but if we wouldn't have already had her when our daughter was born I don't think we would have a dog right now. They are like having a new baby in the house and really require alot of attention in the beginning. We were cray enough to think of getting another dog after our daughter was born but once she was here we changed our minds. It wouldn't be fair to a dog if it couldn't get the attention it needs and it wouldn't be fair to you with so much on your plate already. I think you are smart to want to wait a few years. Maybe you could suggest to your husband to volunteer at the local animal shelter. They need people to take the dogs on daily walks. That way he can get his fix without all the extra work for you.

A couple of suggestions for you. I have read that kids younger than 6 or 7 are too young to be responsible for a pet, but your 9 year old is the perfect age and your 6 year old could certainly help out. If it comes up again, make sure that the oldest two understand that the dog will be their responsibility when they are home. I have both dogs and cats and a fenced in yard. The dogs are pretty easy, I just toss them out in the back yard several times a day so they can go potty and I free feed so there is always food down. The girls (10 and 9) change the dog's water every morning and make sure the water bowls are full. My son (7) makes sure the cat and dog bowls are full of food and the girls feed the cats their wet food in the evenings. We all scoop and change cat boxes when they get dirty but they are in the bathrooms so that one is easy. You would still have to be responsible when the kids are at school, but if you could fence in your yard, it wouldn't be too bad.

My next suggestion is to go to the pound and get a young dog rather than a puppy. Maybe even go to a rescue and get a greyhound or some other young adult dog. The rescue groups do a good job of determing the personality of the dog so they can help you find one that is good with children and not high-maintenance. A young adult dog or even an older puppy - say 6 months or so will not be as much trouble as a baby puppy.

I think it is doable for you and could be worked so you don't shoulder the whole load. You would have to also have an understanding with your husband that he would be responsible for walks morning and evening.

Whenever they decide that they are not waiting any longer for a dog, please consider adopting a shelter dog. Maybe one that is about 3 years old. Then, you will know the exact size the dog will be and there's a pretty good chance it will already be trained. Most shelters even provide backround info on the dog like how well it deals with children and other pets. I have a 21 month old, a 3 month old (and could possibly be pregnant again), a pitt bull/terrier mix, a siberian husky, and a cat. I couldn't imagine my life without my pets. My husband never liked dogs before we got them and now he would be broken hearted if anything were to happen to them. They really aren't an extreme amount of extra work and with a couple of your kids being a little bit older, they'd love to help. I personally plan on breeding my siberian either this fall or in the spring and will be keeping one of the pups. They are more than just a dog, they become part of the family. To borrow a phrase from a friend of mine, never underestimate the warmth of a cold nose :)

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.