K.S. asks from Tampa, FL on May 20, 2007
My 5 1/2 Year Old Won't Try New Foods.
I have a 5 1/2 year old daughter who likes the following: Grilled cheese, cheese in and of itself, bacon, hot dogs, whole wheat bread, waffles, peanut butter, cheerios but also trix, milk, juice (no soda), water, crackers (with cheese of course), tofu (sometimes), breakfast bars (like yogurt ones or nutrigrain), yogurt, chicken nuggets, french fries, pizza, turkey, and fruits, such as apple, grapes, strawberries, watermelon, cantaloupe, melon, sometimes plums, raisins. Of course, she likes junk food which we minimize. I am concerned because she will not eat one single vegetable and will be very stubborn when trying to get her to open up to new foods. Sometimes she actually gags if I really insist on her trying something. My husband says don't force her to try anything, just keep offering which we do. Any suggestions? At this age, she is about to go into kindergarten and also is going to be staying over at some friends house for a couple of nights while hubby and I go away for the 1st time in over 2 years alone. I would like her to be more open to trying new foods. She knows healthy foods, etc, has done food pyramids at pre-k but still she won't try anything new. I am a vegetarian, my husband is a carnivore. We like almost everything (except me and the meat-thing). Meals at home are a bit frantic but we do get to sit down at the table on the weekends and a couple of nights during the week. Thank you!
So What Happened?™
Well, I appreciate all the advice. Now that she has started kindergarten she is even more selective. She doesn't like hot dogs now (good), but also some other things, like peanut butter. I think she is just saying she doesn't like something but then if given no other alternative, she eats it. I tried shredding some carrots in her grilled cheese like one mom suggested and that worked. So we will plug along...thanks again!
Featured Answers
C.C. answers from Tampa on May 22, 2007
run some veggies through the food processor, some greens maybe like green beans, spinach, or broccoli....then make the cheesiest mac and cheese you've ever made and add the veggies...this is gonna sound wierd....add green food coloring and mix well and say you're having "green mac and cheese" like "green eggs and ham"....see what happens! Even wear a Dr. Suess hat to make it a fun event! Gotta get creative with these little munchkins!
Also, if she'll eat muffins of any kind, add some small bits of veggies (or even run through the food processor again). Blueberry muffins are good with a splash of carrots. te he.
More Answers
A.G. answers from Jacksonville on May 22, 2007
My son was the same way. What worked for me was a gave me like a teaspoon of a kid friendly veggie like corn, peas and carrots, if he ate just that little he could have a little extra with his dessert. Like one extra cookie or a hershey kiss he loved those. I didn't like promoting extra deserts but as time went on the portions got bigger and by six and a half years if he didn't eat his veggies he got no snack. Hope this helps, can't hurt to try. Have a great getaway!!
C.C. answers from Tampa on May 22, 2007
run some veggies through the food processor, some greens maybe like green beans, spinach, or broccoli....then make the cheesiest mac and cheese you've ever made and add the veggies...this is gonna sound wierd....add green food coloring and mix well and say you're having "green mac and cheese" like "green eggs and ham"....see what happens! Even wear a Dr. Suess hat to make it a fun event! Gotta get creative with these little munchkins!
Also, if she'll eat muffins of any kind, add some small bits of veggies (or even run through the food processor again). Blueberry muffins are good with a splash of carrots. te he.
S.B. answers from Tallahassee on March 20, 2008
Honey, you should thank the Lord she eats all the different foods that she does, especially the fruits. We have a 5 year old grandson who won't eat anything but chicken strips, hamburgers, pizza, grapes, french fries, and Ramen noodles. His daddy makes him try veges, but he does the gagging thing. He also will not take medicine; we have to make suppositories to give him fever meds. I wouldn't worry about your daughter.
S.D. answers from Tampa on May 21, 2007
I read your list and thought what a lucky woman you were. My daughter (who is now 28 and eats practically everything and continues to try new things) existed on a diet of basically macaroni and cheese and mashed potatoes (no gravy). Getting meat down her was painful. She would chew on a piece of meat forever and finally spit out any remains. She would occasionally eat chicken nuggets, but veggies and most fruit were never approached. I agonized also, but she has grown up fine and healthy and now will try to eat lots of new things. It took a long time though. If you can keep the junk food to a minimum, it sounds to me like she has lots of healthy things in her diet. The other things will come with time. Often peer pressure is the best motivator (or in the case of my girls, boyfriends). They'll try new things for a boy that they wouldn't try for their dad or I. Keep your head up, it will get better.
J.W. answers from Tallahassee on May 22, 2007
K.,
By the foods you listed, your daughter eats pretty well and I know she eats better than some. As for veggies, try giving them to her raw (carrots, zuchini, broc. cauliflower etc..). My daughter hates zucchini cooked but likes it raw. As for other vegetables, try cooking them differently to add more flavor. Add a little cheese or butter to them. Tell her that she needs to take one or two bites and if she doesn't like it then she doesn't have to eat it. If she keeps insisting she doesn't like a particular food, than more than likely she doesn't. Good Luck!
J.
J.M. answers from Pensacola on May 22, 2007
I agree with the rest of the posts that you should not force the food, but always offer it. I have been this way with my 3 1/2 year old since he was eating food and now he has no trouble at least trying one bite. Our rule is, take a bite and if you don't like it, you don't have to eat it. I can tell you that this has supplied many, many times of me catching food as it flies back out of his mouth but he eats quite a few veggies now. We make no big deal if comes back out. Just say it's ok, he doesn't have to eat it if he doesn't like it. Also, I read online that fruits have just as many vitamins and minerals as veggies. So as long as she's eating fruit she is getting good vitamins, just a little natural sugar with it. Best of luck to you, Jen
By the way, you are truly lucky that she eats so many healthy foods already! I know lots of people who have kids who won't eat more that 2 or 3 foods for weeks at a time!
S.G. answers from Jacksonville on May 21, 2007
K.,
I also have to agree with your husband. When I was young (the youngest, only girl with 5 older brothers) my "place" at the table was directly across from my father. I LOVED him ... but dinner time was so stressful. He CONSTANTLY commented on my "picky-ness" at the table. I didn't eat a pizza until I was 20! I believe my dad's attitude made me NOT to want to try anything. My 19 yr old son still eats green beans as if they are pills. :-) LOL I personally don't care for them either and don't MAKE him eat them ... but he wants to try. LOL When our daughter (now 9) was between the ages of 3-6 ... she would NOT eat meat ... except for Nonna's special fries and only at Nonna's house because we didn't know the secret. (My mom made her Mrs. Paul's fish sticks. LOL) I believe the less push ... the more likely to try more things.
Hope this helps.
A.A. answers from Albany on May 22, 2007
I'm so glad to hear that I'm not the only one! I have a 14-year-old and a 12-year-old son. My 14-year-old is fine. He eats anything and is always willing to try new foods. My 12-year-old son is incredibly picky and eat even less of a variety that your daughter! We have to count the tomatos in ketchup as both vegetable AND fruit; otherwise, he wouldn't be getting any nutrition from fruits or vegetables. He eats cereal but not with milk (however he drinks milk separately). He hates ALL fruits and ALL vegetables (except for french fries and rice). So I guess your daughter is WAY ahead of him. We don't force him to eat. We just keep trying to get him to try new things, but if he's not willing, we just let him eat the things he likes. I was a picky eater when I was growing up, so we're hoping that eventually he'll decide to try new things and eat better. We're in the same boat as y'all are: we rarely eat together as a family, so I generally play the short-order cook. I come home from work and make everyone what they want. It's easier to do it that way than to try to force them to eat something they won't.
Anyway, good luck! I hope it all works out.
Vicky K.
Email