Looking for a Toddler-size Baseball Mitt

I would suggest Play It Again Sports. Used equipment at great prices and when your DS has outgrown it, you sell it back to them. My baseball playing son used to use a "toy" glove when he was age 2-4. It was easier to grip the ball with the glove, because it was more pliable then a heavy leather glove.
Play Ball!
S.

I got one for my daughter at Academy in the T-ball section. She is 3 and it fits her good.

I thought we saw some small mits in Target...not sure.

Wal-Mart has T-Ball mitts, they are very small. Hibbet Sporting Goods has T-Ball mitts too. I don't know if there are any in your area but any sports store should ahve them, they can be a couple different sizes if I remember correctly.

walmart had them last year, they were super cute, a blue one with a blue baseball, and a pink one with a pink baseball :) i think they were less than $10

I just got a cute pink one for my 5 year old from Walmart.

The TJ Maxx in Denton has gloves and bats for toddlers. We bought the Strawberry Shortcake one for my daughter. They also have some that are plain. I like the bats because they are padded (which is a good thing to have at my house.)