29 answers

How Bad Are They?

My 17 month old, has started refusing protein. I mean every protein. Beef, chicken, turkey, eggs, beans. We've tried cooking them every way, adding different spices, EVERYTHING! Everything he used to love, he know refuses to eat. I took him to a new pediatrician Friday and he has lost quite a bit of weight. He is now in the 45th percentile. It wouldn't have been a concern, if he hadn't weighed a lot more before. I really think it's because he will only eat fruits and vegetables and some cheese. He's not getting enough fat. (The pediatrician, who I really liked, agreed with this.) I don't know what else to do. The pediatrician told me rejecting foods is a normal developmental thing, at this age.
SO...I got a jar of those Gerber meat stick things, at the store a few minutes ago. (the turkey ones) We don't eat processed food here and I'm wondering...how bad are they, REALLY? They are kind of a pieced together food and it really creeps me out. I REALLY need to get protein into this Dude and it's kind of a desperate effort. I don't want him to only want these stick things and I want him to return to his normal diet. Is it OK to give him the Gerber stuff, while he gets over this phase? Will he only want processed meats, if I give them to him?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

He wouldn't eat them, so I guess I don't have to worry about it! He can't have milk, unfortunately.

Featured Answers

my daughter went through a faze where she LOVED Vienna sausages and wanted them all the time. Since she wouldnt eat any other meat, I let her have them. Now she'll eat chicken, so we've phased them out and she only eats them very rarely (twice in the last 6 months). They arent super bad for you, and he'll get over his meat aversion, or he'll become a vegetarian.

You might also want to look into peanut butter or vegetarian diets just to get a feel for how they get in the protein. Good luck, mama!

3 moms found this helpful

Instead of the Gerber meat sticks why don't you try the Hebrew National hot dogs? Aren't they made from the better parts of the animals?

2 moms found this helpful

We buy a protein powder at the health food store. It has a short ingredients list, which we like. You could try a fruit smoothie with the powder or peanut butter (if no allergy) in it. We use frozen fruit or cocoa powder, cinnamon, peanut butter and juice (to make it thinner and easier to drink). If you make a chocolate smoothie, maybe you could use rice or almond milk instead?

More Answers

my daughter went through a faze where she LOVED Vienna sausages and wanted them all the time. Since she wouldnt eat any other meat, I let her have them. Now she'll eat chicken, so we've phased them out and she only eats them very rarely (twice in the last 6 months). They arent super bad for you, and he'll get over his meat aversion, or he'll become a vegetarian.

You might also want to look into peanut butter or vegetarian diets just to get a feel for how they get in the protein. Good luck, mama!

3 moms found this helpful

Instead of the Gerber meat sticks why don't you try the Hebrew National hot dogs? Aren't they made from the better parts of the animals?

2 moms found this helpful

Bad is a relative term. If your child needs protien they are not at ALL bad. We try to stay away from processed foods to but sometimes you just gotta feed a child what they will eat. My daughters nutritionist put my daughter on a high calorie diet when she was about 18 months, believe me I felt horible standing in the grocery store trying to find the waffles with the MOST not the least calories and fat. Protien is protien, processed or not. You may have to go with processed foods and keep experimenting until you can find something that he will eat. Also you can enrich foods he has with protien, make a white bean puree and hide it in puddings, smoothies, mix it up with mac and cheese etc. (You can supplement with pediasure or carnation instant breakfast starting at age 1).

1 mom found this helpful

I actually went to two different lectures about a year ago by these two authors: Jordan Rubin "Patient Heal Thyself" and "Perfect Weight America" and Brendan Brazier, "Thrive: the Vegan Guide to Optimal Performance in Sports and Life."

They both created protein powders. I believe Jordan has sold his product line called "Garden of Life" (?). When I heard him speak, he was excited about a new micro-nutrient called "Fucodain" only found in sea plants. Brendan is a professional tri-athlete and his protein powder, VEGA, is made completely from plants. I've been mixing the Vanilla Chai flavor with fruit juice combinations (ex. apple + orange), and I love it.

1 mom found this helpful

How about drinking soup? There doesn't have to even be anything in it. Just the soup in a sippy cup. It could be as easy as canned soup... or home made. You just strain out the solids.

Milk also has quite a bit of protein in it (ahhhh milk, the super food - fats proteins carbs vitamins and minerals). If straight milk is being boycotted... hot chocolate made with whole milk and syrup (or melted chocolate on the stove in a pan with milk) I've only ever seen turned down by one child, ever.

Here's a few other options just on the fly:

- avocado
- marrow bones
- butter in *everything*
- protein powder or formula
- cheese in all of it's various forms
- deep friend whatever (like chicken katsu, tempura - can be shrimp or veggie)
- biscuits & gravy
- nuttella
- quorn chik'n nuggets (made from mushrooms)

But as to your original Q... not they're not THAT bad for you. Especially for kids who need high fat diets (to coat the axons of their nerves with myelin, which is almost pure fat, and to build bone marrow for their immune system... which, again, along with the majority of the immune system -like antibodies... is almost pure fat). Processed foods are about 1000x worse for adults than children. I mean, you don't want a diet that comes entirely out of a box or can, but those self same products are ideal for "fattening up".

1 mom found this helpful

I can't answer your question about the Gerber meat sticks because they grossed me out too, but have you tried a rotisserie chicken from the grocery store? I really don't like chicken too much and my kids (2 1/2 and 12 mos) won't really eat it, but they LOVE the rotisserie chicken. It is very moist and tender and it is easy for my 12 month old to eat. My 2 1/2 yr old daughter only ever wants mac and cheese or buttered noodles so the chicken is the only way to try to get something nutritious in her. I know you said you tried everything but I figured I just ask anyway. Oh, what about beans? They are great for you and have protein. My son likes when I mix them with rice and some diced veggies and then toss with some cheese.

1 mom found this helpful

We used to give our daughter bones to chew /suck on like pork chop or steak bones. People thought it was weird, but she loved them and would happily sit and suck on 1 while the family ate.

1 mom found this helpful

REALLY, they are that bad. Frankly, all meat is.

But you can get protein from green peas, spinach, or broccoli. And protein is not what will put weight on him anyhow. If he drinks even 1 glass of milk a day, you are going to be fine. You mentioned beans, but have you tried chickpeas? If he wont eat them whole, get some hummus and he can dip his veggies into it. Also Tahini (sesame seeds), which is super high in protein and 100 calories a TBSP! Great for weight gain. There are pastas made from soy also which have tons of protein.

http://www.13.waisays.com/protein.htm (a neat protein article)

You mentioned that he would eat some cheese, how about cottage cheese or yogurt? Try the Greek Gods yogurt brand available at Sprouts or Whole Foods, and get their full fat variety in Pomegranate or Honey, if you give him honey. They have 270-250 calories per jar and he should def eat a jar at a time, no prob. Also, Sprouts has a "pasture" butter in a bright green foil wrapper which has 110 cal per tbsp (vs reg butters that have 80-100) so that is a great additive to any food to boost cal for weight gain.

If you email me back I can help with lots of other ideas as our 2yr old daughter was below the 5th percentile and is only now below the 10th. So in comparison, you have nothing to worry about. ;-P

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.