N. asks from Saint Paul, MN on September 01, 2009
At What Age Do You Stop Doing Birthday Celebrations?
I have a 4, 11, and 13 year old. I know the 4 year old is still in the birthday party phase. But it seems my older two and just looking for money and presents from relative, when we have parties. It seems a little cready to me. I think it is time to just maybe go out for dinner or have a family dinner without presents and such. What are your thoughts? Does everyone still have family gatherings or is there an age when parties are kinda out. Please let me know your thoughts. thanks for any advice
Featured Answers
S.U. answers from New York on September 01, 2009
I think its ok to let them have birthday parties because they need to enjoy life to the fullest. But if they decide they rather go out and eat wiht their friends or just go to the movies let them do that because at least you know you let them do what they wanted on tehir birthday.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
S.G. answers from Youngstown on September 01, 2009
Never,stop having birthdays. Teach them the feeling of saving money so they can buy a present for the next person in the family, maybe they will have more respect for the gifts they receive if they know the feeling of also having to give.
1 mom found this helpful
R.C. answers from Minneapolis on September 01, 2009
I say never stop celebrating. Celebrate life, love, family and friends, oh yeah, and birthdays, every chance you get. :)
1 mom found this helpful
S.U. answers from New York on September 01, 2009
I think its ok to let them have birthday parties because they need to enjoy life to the fullest. But if they decide they rather go out and eat wiht their friends or just go to the movies let them do that because at least you know you let them do what they wanted on tehir birthday.
1 mom found this helpful
V. answers from Minneapolis on September 01, 2009
Never;)
Have them save some of their money and
teach them manners! Have them WRITE out
Thank you notes!
1 mom found this helpful
J.G. answers from Milwaukee on September 02, 2009
Hey N.,
Even if they just want money...that's just the age they are in.
My nephew just turned 15...my brother isn't a big planner and he doesn't have a lot of mmoney because he lost his job a while back. He hasn't had a BP for our nephew in close to three years.
Our nephew lives with his mom...and the only time we see him is at birthday parties! So I rounded up our family and we surprised him BIG_TIME with a BP. My family wanted to see our nephew!
Yes we gave money. I remember being that age. I loved getting money.
He wasn't expecting anything. To see his face was just all the thanks enough.
I think it's a good idea...it's up to you. If you feel you need to change it up a bit...they might appreciate the money the next BP. Who knows. I know my nephew did...;-)
Best wishes!
J.
H.M. answers from Minneapolis on September 04, 2009
Hi N., Never stop celebrating a birthday. You don't have to go all out on the party. A small family get together is great and shows your kids that birthdays are special. Always give a gift. It does not have to be big or expensive. It can be something home made and still be totally appreciated, It makes the child feel special on that day, it is "his" day, and I think that is important. My cousin never had birthday celebrations and is still bitter about it today.
K.T. answers from Minneapolis on September 01, 2009
I say definitely by the time they finish elementary school. A 13 year old doesn't need to have a party with a bunch of friends, balloons, activities, the works. After elementary school a simple birthday meal and cake or going out to a movie and a gift from their parents should be enough. Maybe even sooner. If your eleven year old is smart enough to look forward to a big party because more people=more gifts, then I say it is perfectly okay to tone it down at that point. From 13 on you could still allow them to have one or two of their closest friends over for dinner and a movie.
J.L. answers from Minneapolis on September 04, 2009
I see a couple of things going on here. You have boys and you're probably seeing an early manifestation of "machismo" going on here. And to complicate things, two of them are approaching and/or well into their "Tweens". I think you're dealing with classic pre-teen angst. They probably really do want to have a party with all of the hoopla young kids like, but they're probably worried about what their peers are thinking. Who knows maybe the kid "Travis" from down the street said "Parties are for babies" to your sons, and now they're torn because they may still enjoy the parties and/or they don't want to disappoint you, and don't know what to do now, so they're just asking for money etc.
I'd ask them specifically what they want to do for their birthday. ASk them what other kids their age are doing? Have they been to another "tween" party lately, that was fun? Have them help plan their special day. Of course set a budget and reasonable expectations on your part of what you'll find acceptible...but otherwise, let them take over and call the shots.
This will help take some of the pressure off everyone. The boys can decide who they want to invite and how the party should go based on what "they" think is cool and acceptible with their crowd.
Email