C.F. asks from Allen, TX on December 02, 2009
Asperger's Syndrome, Gifted Child
My son recently turned 4. His preschool teacher seems to think he may have Asperger's syndrome. I, a former teacher, do not agree with this diagnosis. He is very smart - knew all capital and lower case letter names before he was 2, knew letter sounds and memorized many books shortly after he turned 2 and began reading just before he turned 3. He can count past 100, can do simple addition and subtraction, knows odd and even numbers, counts by 2s, 3s, 5s, 10s, etc. He has memorized many street names around our house and can tell you which streets to take to various locations and has recently started writing the names of the streets. He makes "lists" of things, reads, writes, "orders" things in his play time but shows no conventional creativity. Instead of drawing a picture, he'll write a list of words. If I press for him to draw something, I can usually get him to draw shapes or something that he "knows" - he doesn't "invent" things on his own. He will NOT try new foods (even cakes/cookie /desserts) He DOES make eye contact, he does show empathy for others and extreme sensitivity to others' feelings. Does anyone have any ideas or experience with a child like this? I don't really want to have him formally evaluated by a physician because he HATES the doctor's office and shuts down whenever we have to go to any doctor.
So What Happened?™
thanks for all of your advice -- the only thing his teacher told me about WHY she thought he may have Asperger's is #1 she's currently taking a class on autism/asperger's and it made her think of him. As I mentioned before, she does not currently have a degree in teaching (or medicine ;) ).#2 She mentioned that he doesn't interact with the kids in whole group settings (doesn't participate) and 3 has noticed he sometimes covers his ears when there's a loud (or even not-so-loud, but annoying) noise. He repeats what she says at calendar time - sometimes right along with her and sometimes even before her - He knows what she's going to say because it is routine and he says it along with her as if in her voice (her perspective) like ... "what number do we put up today?" at calendar time. I tend to think that, because he already knows the numbers and can count forward and backward (subtract, add, etc.), he doesn't really understand the purpose of calendar/circle time so he's just having fun predicting what the teacher is going to say. I think he thinks the purpose of many things in daily life is to memorize those events. Or maybe it's just fun to memorize it?? Yesterday, after school, I found him at the kitchen table - writing lots of words that I didn't recognize. He told me they were street names. My husband had to use google earth to confirm what I suspected.....he was writing the street names (which he must have seen out the window) IN ORDER of our route home from school. These were not the main roads we traveled on, but side streets we drove PAST on our route home. I will have some type of evaluation done - i'm just not sure when/how. Thanks again for your advice and positive comments!
Featured Answers
M.S. answers from Dallas on December 02, 2009
My son was evaluated by Dr. David Falkstein who has an office in Allen and one in Sherman. He's a diagnosing psychologist & school counselor. My son, who has a medical phobia, LOVED this guy and was ready to wrap him up & take him home. He used games to do tests and it wasn't at all like a medical doctor's office.
1 mom found this helpful
C.F. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
sounds like a wonderful student that I had for three years in my Montessori classroom.
he had aspergers...very high functiining....i suspect his mom did too...very sweet family...just quirky....the more training I take the more I see of many things in us all. lol...it is important to have the same expections and work with everyone to suceed...mpntessori seems to work well as there are different ages to social with and while there just enough going on to practice manners most are good hearted kids....like a family...
A.F. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
Hi CF, I know moms wiht asperger's syndrome that I can have you speak with on a 3 way conference to see if there is any similarity. These moms are happy to share information to help others.
Let me know if interested.
A.
###-###-####
More Answers
T.T. answers from Dallas on December 02, 2009
It sounds like he could be on the spectrum. You can go other places to get him evaluated such as Our Children's House Baylor where he would be in a more child-friendly atmosphere. It sounds like he is doing very well academically, but you really should get a professional opinion to know what you are dealing with. As he gets older the social and imaginative issues will be brought to the surface and more of that will be required of him at school. With an evaluation you can get the tools you need to help him through.
My older son was/is much like you describe, but not quite as extreme. He started reading very early and has had a complex understanding of the way computers/electronics work from a very young age. He showed very little creativity or unique thinking until he was close to 5 years old. Even now, at 7, his interests and creative thinking is very different from his peers. He has a difficult time making friends much b/c he is so different (wasn't an issue when he was younger).
Remember, you are your son's advocate, and sometimes that means doing things that are difficult for both you and him. You need to know what you are dealing with, whether its a child on the spectrum, a extremely gifted child, or both, there are issues with all of it.
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
H.V. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
Wow, a lot of armchair doctors with broad opinions.
Does your pre-school teacher have a medical degree, degree or is she just a teacher? If you don't feel there is anything wrong then move on.
1 mom found this helpful
L.A. answers from Reno on December 02, 2009
Most kids with aspergers are gifted. You might check with your local school district. Ask for special ed child find and they can either evaluate him or find you a nice , non-threatening environment and specialist to do the evaluation.If he is on the spectrum, catching it early will make a big difference in the quality of his life. Good luck!!
1 mom found this helpful
M.S. answers from Dallas on December 02, 2009
My son was evaluated by Dr. David Falkstein who has an office in Allen and one in Sherman. He's a diagnosing psychologist & school counselor. My son, who has a medical phobia, LOVED this guy and was ready to wrap him up & take him home. He used games to do tests and it wasn't at all like a medical doctor's office.
1 mom found this helpful
J.T. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
First of all, when did teacher's suddenly get a medical degree? Yes, they come in contact with children on a daily basis, but can they really delineate between different diagnosis on the autism spectrum? If you're really concerned you can get him evaluated by a D.A.N. doctor, one who specializes in autism. Your son sounds like he's more left-brained, logical and number oriented, which can really be an asset for his future. My 4 year-old son doesn't like change, has to keep everything in order, but loves music and creative play. Would I call my son OCD? Maybe, but he is well-adjusted and makes eye contact and is the coolest kid on the planet, (and I'm sure your son is too!) Nurture his skills and take pride in your son's early abilities. But, again, get him checked out by the appropriate doctor to ease your mind. It could possibly even send you in a direction to get him into a new school to further nurture your son's mathematic/reading talents! God Bless.
1 mom found this helpful
A.I. answers from Tucson on December 02, 2009
i have a brother who is autistic and a sister with asperger .. my understanding of it is they are very high functioning..as a matter of fact my sister has 3 college degress and is super smart. she just has a difficult time with some social issues..it does not mean that your kid isnt smart..asperger kids are very talented and very creative and unique.
1 mom found this helpful
J.W. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
Call your local school district. WE have been going through a similar situation with my 3 year old daughter. They will set up an evaluation. This won't be anything like it would be at a doctors office. They will watch how your child plays and comprehends and all of that fun stuff.
P.W. answers from Dallas on December 03, 2009
CF,
I am not judging your teacher. She may or may not should have opened her mouth, but I am wondering why she mentioned it. Have you read about Asperger's? It is a MILD form of autism. It is not the "autism" you have seen in the movies. Quite often people with Asperger's are at a genius level intellectually, have no problem making eye contact and because it is not easily "seen" struggle for many years before a diagnosis is made. Textures and foods can be a problem, but that is not a defining reason to label your son. An Asperger's person will have problem with social cues.....a hard time reading them. He will hear your words and take them literally whereas you and I can interpret from tone to decipher the true meaning.... and early intervention you can make a difference.
I certainly don't know the whole story, but I would keep an open mind though. If your child does end up having Asperger's you can help him. He can grow up, go to college, drive, have a career and a family. But I do believe starting early can make a huge difference in his success and in his emotional adjustment.
I'd recommend you do a little research and see where you can start with an evaluation of some sort. It may be just finding a pediatrician that is familiar with Asperger's. There aren't many out there, so check around.
Sounds like you have a gifted child. Whether he has Asperger's or not you can help him to succeed.
All My Best,
P.
Email