22 answers

4 Week Old- Need Help!

My 4 week old wants to be held all the time! I know that babies enjoy the comfort of being held but as soon as you put him down he is screaming! It's even to the point that he will not sleep unless he is in our arms, which is so dangerous! Is it ok to let him cry it out at this age?

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

Try swaddling him and putting him in his car seat. I have had several kids that just didn't like to be laid down. I used to put them in their car seats and place them anywhere I was. If they began to fuss I could rock the car seat a bit and keep them happy.

2 moms found this helpful

Hello A., are you swaddling him before you try to put him down for sleep?

My younger son would only sleep (when not in my arms) if he was very tightly swaddled, then in a cradle swing (seat belted as best I could with him in swaddling blankets.) I also had to use lots of white noise, like a fan, to help him sleep.

2 moms found this helpful

More Answers

Get a baby sling and wear him when ever you can. But make sure he's not all scrunched up so he can't breathe. When my son was very little, I'd put a small pillow in the bottom of the sling so he'd rest on top of it, and he loved it. It won't hurt him to cry a little (you've got to shower and use the bathroom sometime), but a 4 wk old is not going to understand being left to cry for long periods. They need cuddling and human contact. I know it can leave you pretty touched out by the end of the day, but they grow fast. Next year you'll be wondering where your tiny baby has gone as he's learning to crawl and walk and climb!

5 moms found this helpful

I had a co-sleeper when my son was an infant. I don't know if they make them anymore, but a bassinet right next to your bed would be the next best thing. He was basically in a bassinet with a let-down side that slid under my mattress. He was in his own little area for sleeping and I could not roll over onto him nor throw the covers over him, but he was still right there in arms reach. I could lie down and pat him or rub his tummy until he fell asleep. I would nurse him in the evening lying on the bed and then slide him over into his co-sleeper and he would go right to sleep. Newborns want to be near your and feel your warmth and presence. They are just out of a symbiotic relationship with you and are adjusting to being a single entity in the big world.
Swaddling is also a very good way to go to ensure warmth and security.

4 moms found this helpful

He is too young for cry it out, but that doesn't mean he can't cry at all =) I would put him down for short periods, maybe swaddled or in a bouncer/swing and let him fuss a bit. Let him fuss a bit if he's hungry too or tired, a few minutes longer to wait for the bottle/breast--that isn't going to hurt him. Cry it out is used for sleeping training and that doesn't really work til about 5 months old, but that does not mean you are a slave to baby's every utterance. If he is fed, burped, and clean than letting him fuss a bit is not going to hurt anything. In my opinion, you can't go to every fuss or you start to become the one man entertainment act and you will be completely worn out by the time he is 3 months old! If he is just colicky and you are at your witt's end, swaddle him and lay him down in his crib and leave the room for fifteen minutes to collect yourself. You know he is safe and sometimes you just need a breather! Babies cry and scream sometimes no matter what you do---it is just the way they express themselves =) Try not to let the crying get to you or make you feel bad. The idea that babies are just happy and smiling all the time is BS. Best of luck, you're doing great =)

3 moms found this helpful

Have you tried swaddling him? That may help. Also if you put him on an eat/play/sleep schedule so the same things happen at the same times every day, he will become used to being put down to sleep (which you definitely do want). How about using a bouncy seat (they make them that vibrate, which he might like)? Does he like to be in a swing? Some babies just like constant motion - my older daughter was that way as a newborn. We'd turn her swing onto its highest setting, and she'd fall asleep immediately, swinging like crazy. Also maybe you can try a pacifier. Some babies need a way to comfort themselves when they are in a new situation (like being "by themselves" in the bassinet).

If none of the above works, you may need to put him down but keep your hand on him, speak softly so he knows you're there, and keep increasing the amount of time that he is laying down on his own - and as time goes by you will be able to remove your hand from him, and eventually you'll be able to step away from him and he won't cry.

Newborns are just so new to the world, and some are way more demanding than others. It will take him a while to get into a rhythm, with your help.

3 moms found this helpful

have you tried wearing a sling? Your baby is a smart guy, wanting to stick close to mom. I know it is hard now but it isn't so bad once you're used to it. Once it is all over you will miss it more than you can imagine.

3 moms found this helpful

I second the happiest baby on the block recommendation - some libraries also have the DVD which is very helpful. WAY too young for cry it out. He's not crying to "test" you - it's the only way he has to communicate. At this age they cry when they need something. Right now, it looks like the need is for physical comfort. Holding them a lot at this age will NOT spoil them. (I did the carrier thing for my little guy, and co-slept as well - he's now 3 and very independent, confident and social.)

Swaddling will be helpful, as he's used to being all snug inside you - babies have a startle reflex and they wake themselves up; they also feel like they're falling cause the world is so OPEN now. If there's a carrier you love, try that. It'll free up your arms so you can do stuff and still give him snuggle time. Good luck!

3 moms found this helpful

Crying it out is not recommended for babies in their first several months even by most CIO proponents.

Please read The Happiest Baby on the Block by Dr. Harvey Karp. He gives several really valuable tips on how to comfort needy babies during what he calls the Fourth Trimester – the first three months during which babies are still adapting to the outside world. Your little guy is right at the typically fussiest stage, and will gradually settle down over the next six weeks or so, so hang in there. Please remember that he didn't ask to be born.

In addition to the book, you can also google for a whole bunch of Happiest Baby videos, talking about and even showing his techniques.

Lots of moms "wear" their babies in slings a lot during the first months, leaving their hands free and their babies content.

3 moms found this helpful

Try swaddling him and putting him in his car seat. I have had several kids that just didn't like to be laid down. I used to put them in their car seats and place them anywhere I was. If they began to fuss I could rock the car seat a bit and keep them happy.

2 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.