33 answers

Wondering About Formula...

I just recently switched my 3 week old daughter over from breastfeeding to formula.; Since doing so she has been considerably more fussy and gassy. I'm using Similac Advance formula. This is my first experience with all of this. Is it just inevidible that she will have more gas and discomfort from formula feeding or shoudl I make some changes to see if something else works better. I have already switched from Avent bottles to Playtexx nursers with the drop in bags. She seems to suck much less air with this bottle...but she is still more fussy than she was when she breastfed. Any suggestions???

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks to everyone that responded with such great advice. I switched yesterday to Gentlease formula and Dr.Brown bottles. We will see how it goes. It is so nice to be able to ask advice this way...and I really appreciate all of you that sent your tips and support!!!

Featured Answers

Most all babies do have some sort of fussy period. My second son was a little bit more fussy than my first and that did pass by about 6 weeks. We were going to try switching formulas but what really helped us was the Dr Browns bottles. Good luck!

L.,

i did not breastfeed and my sons did have the gassy and fussy issues also. I was switched from the Similac formulas to the Isomil soy formula and also used mylicon drops. With the combination of the two, my sons both were much more calm and able to relax

I breast feed for about a month i did not have enough breast milk... i had to put her on the same stuff, and the same thing happend. I then switched her to the SOY based milk till she was about 3-4 months old then went back to Similac Advanced and it worked out so much better. NOW the air part I used Parent choice nippled for Collic LET ME TELL YOU she hates all th other nipples i have tried on her lol. She is now a year old and she is now about off formula she eats food, and LOVES milk, and is VERY active. I hope this helps a little.

More Answers

Hi L.,
First off to the mothers out there that are repremanding mothers that do not breastfeed...STOP!!! Some of us tried and for whatever reason cannot continue. It is discouraging enough to know that your body isn't capable of providing for your child naturally, we don't need other moms in our 'support' group telling us we are wrong. We shouldn't be scrutinized for how we choose to feed our babies. Secondly; in response to your question, here is what I found worked for my son. I too chose to breastfeed my son, but for whatever reason he did not enjoy it and I wasn't producing enough milk to keep him satisfied and healthy. We found that the combination of Good Start Formula or Enfamil Gentlease and Dr. Brown's bottles worked extremely well for us. A week after we started this combination, our son slept through the night and was an extremely happy baby. I hope this helps you.

1 mom found this helpful

I have to admit I know ABSOLUTELY nothing about formula. I breastfed my kids until a year when they went to cows milk. At the time it seemed like an inconvenience to breastfeed and the first 6 weeks...can you say "ouch"?!?!? But I will agree with what one other lady on here said. If you can get past the first 6 weeks you are golden and breastfeeding becomes much more convenient and easy and FREE!! Not to mention it gets easier with each kid (if you decide to have more). I may be out of line here but it seems like your baby is telling you that she doesn't want the formula, she wants her Mommy's milk back. At this age especially it is harder on your baby to switch food sources, If breastfeeding is difficult or inconvenient even sticking it out until she starts cereal where you can mix in formula to get her used to it would be better. If you are having trouble with breastfeeding and that is why you are making the switch, there are so many women out there who are so willing to give advice and help, myself included. Good luck and I hope everything works out for you!!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi. I've always breastfed my baby and, even with 100% breastmilk, I noticed she was more gassy and fussy between 4-12 weeks. Babies' intestinal systems are doing a lot of developing during that time so you may not escape the gas fussiness entirely until about 3-4 months. I'm sure finding the right formula will help, but just wanted to give you a heads up that some fussiness is expected and normal during that time. Of course, if it's extreme, definitely talk to your doctor. Hang in there and enjoy the precious moments!

1 mom found this helpful

When my daughter was first born, she would projectile vomit at least once a day for several weeks. I had to lay her down at an angle. She was breastfed. Whenever I have to supplement her feedings I use Enfamil Lipil. I also used that with my son when I couldn't breastfeed. This may be something that your daughter will outgrow, or you may need to change formulas. I personally found that the bottles made no difference at all. Just remember to stick with only one formula at a time for a couple of weeks before deciding that that one doesn't work.
PS-Thanks Katie. I couldn't have said it better myself. This is supposed to be a support group. We are all doing what is best for our children & don't need others making us feel bad about our decisions.
Good luck L.!

1 mom found this helpful

If you decide to try another formula, I would try Enfamil Lipil. It is terrific!! I had trouble with my son when I went from nursing to formula. He had terrible reflux and I finally tried Lipil and it worked great.

I highly recommend Good Start as well. All formulas that you see on the shelf at the stores HAVE to be approved by the FDA - if it's good enough for them, it's good enough for your baby! I switched to Good Start with my middle son because I kept getting tons of coupons for it and it seemed to work fine. He was the same, slept thru the night for about 6 weeks, then stopped! The Similac didn't seem to work and a friend recommended Good Start - now it's all I know!

I would try switching to a soy formula, or even trying Nestle Good Start. All my kids used good start for the same reason, and if you are buying it yourself, it is much cheaper too.

I agree with Allison A.- try a Soy formula (lactose and milk free) such as Similac Advance Isomil Soy combined with Dr. Brown's bottles. I do this exact combo with my 5 month old- who was VERY gassy and it helped IMMENSELY!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.