Why No White Flour for Babies?

Updated on March 16, 2009
L.W. asks from Santa Ana, CA
5 answers

I have a friend who excludes white sugar and white flour from her childrens' diets. I understand the sugar, but why no white flour (or wheat flour)? Her children do not have allergies...she is just very intent on giving them good nutrition.

I applaud her and want to follow in her footsteps for my 10 month old. Anyway, what are the disadvantages of wheat/white flour in a baby's diet who has no allergy to wheat or gluten? It seems to be in everything....so it makes it hard for me to shop for snacks like those Gerber puffs and teething biscuits.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.D.

answers from Las Vegas on

I think the theory is that the wheat that we have available now has been highly engineered to make it more glutenous and, therefore, more appealing for baking, etc. It is not the same wheat flour that our parents (at least mine) and grandparents grew up with. Unfortunately, our digestive systems have not evolved enough to handle this new type of wheat. There are a number of conditions, not necessarily childhood conditions, that are believed to be -- or known to be -- associated with wheat/gluten consumption like celiac disease, crohn's disease, hashimoto's disease. And then there are a number of parents whose children who have ADD, ADHD, autism, asthma and allergies who swear that their children's health improved after they removed the gluten (and other things like artificial colors, etc) from their children's diet.

Now, there's a distinction between food allergies and food intollerances. Some food allergies do take time to build up but they usually end up being an immediate reaction type of thing like what you see with a nut or shellfish allergy. With food intollerance issues, this is a little bit more commonplace and they are a little bit more subtle in how the sypmtoms end up manifesting. Tell-tell signs that a food intollerance are an issue include the following: Red checks not long after eating the offending ingredient; Diarrhea or constipation issues; Excessive gas; Kind of out of behaviour; Bits and piece of the offending food in the person's poop that was not able to be digested. Food intollerance issues come and go throughout a person's lifetime and it just basically means that your body has a hardtime breaking down the food and using it as energy. For some, excessive exposure to these kind of foods can be very destructive to their digestive track and can be leaked into their system and end up being perceived by their body as an antigen that needs to be attacked and destroyed.

I know this all sound very convoluted and, frankly, it wasn't more than a year ago that I thought this was all a lot of rubbish but my son has been gluten free for almost a year now and it has really helped him with a number of developmental delays that we were experiencing with him. There have been a couple of times that we have allowed him to have something with wheat in it during the last 11 months and had lived to regret it. If you wish to learn more about this issue, there's a very good book called Gut Solutions that is available at Whole Foods and probably at Barnes & Noble and Borders as well.

I hope this answered all of your questions. Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from San Diego on

Hi L., there is nothing wrong with white flour, or wheat flour as far as that goes, the ggerber puffs and teething biscuits are just fine. I would not follow in anyone's foot steps, just to follow, and not really know why they are or why they are not giving something to their child. If those items were bad, your peditrician would have told you to avoid them, never go by what some one else says or doing unti you have done the reseach yourself. Being a SAHM is the best ( my opinion ) you don't miss anything like first step first step, all the first's just live one day at a time, enjoy your kids, discipline, teach and reward, them as well, and enjoy and take care of your home and you have masterd being a SAHM. J. L.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

Y.H.

answers from Los Angeles on

Hi L.,

I think your friend excludes white (I'm assuming bleached all-purpose) flour because it is highly processed, glutenous, starchy (main source of bad carbs), and addictive. A good alternative to white flour is whole wheat flour or buckwheat flour - it is highly nutritious and gluten-free (which are what I use). Cutting flour out completely could keep someone from getting essential nutrients (if they are not getting it elsewhere). Good carbs are okay and needed in a healthy everyday diet.

As for sugar, virtually everything has natural sugars in it like fruits and veggies - I hope she is not cutting these out. Other sugars in candies, sweets and soda's are not healthy so I can understand her taking these out (I don't eat these myself). I don't use aspartame because there aren't enough studies on it. I would suggest using Trulia - a new natural sugar, or something like organic or raw cane sugar (again, which is what I use instead of regular granulated sugar).

You know whats best for your baby girl so read up on these things yourself as well as how to provide a healthy, balanced diet. Moderation is key, in addition to exercise. Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.Y.

answers from Honolulu on

Hi Ann,

I understand that you want the best for your children. I have found that the closer you are to the source in processing, filtering etc the better off the products are. Our bodies do need some of the "bad" stuff but need to find it as natural as possible.

Please feel free to check out my website below.
D. Yamamoto, Rep. #4054
Wildtree~Always the better choice...Naturally
###-###-####
e-mail: ____@____.com
www.Nolayoffs.MyWildtree.com

Wildtree….A young, direct sales company with a full line of all-natural, preservative free, delicious food products, from appetizers to desserts! Home tasting parties are fun, simple and tasty! Now is the perfect time to give us a test drive. $55-115 to start! Call…….

Eat For FREE! ~ Earn FREE PRODUCTS!
Culinary Club Member ~ Wholesale Prices
Fundraisers
$$$ Opportunities ~ Ask me NOW!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.P.

answers from Los Angeles on

It is likely that she is trying to cut out white flour form her diet as well. There are recent studies out that indicate white flour is more likely to cause diabetes than sugar... Like everything else, be moderate...
Good luck
R.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches