I.W. asks from Norfolk, VA on August 31, 2009
White Noise - Norfolk,VA
Any opinions about white noise machines? Trying to get my 3 mo old to nap in his crib, but it is kinda difficult w/ a 23 mo old in the house. He loves the sound of the dryer, bathroom fan, etc. so I was thinking about purchasing a white noise machine to soothe him and drown out his noisy big sister. But I am worried about him becoming dependent on it...
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
K.S. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
I.,
I'm a big fan of "white noise"! I used it with all 3 of my kids and not only were they all great sleepers as a result, but I was a lot less stressed out about noise. This translated into a more relaxed mommy and when mom's happy everyone is happy. Even adults feel lousey when their sleep is interrupted and a disrupted sleep cycle can translate into a grumpy baby who has a more difficult time sleeping. As for becoming too dependent on it, I don't think there is any such thing for a 3 mos. old. I have 3 kids (9, 11, & 14) and only one of them still sleeps with white noise. Good luck and happy sleeping for all of you!!;)
D.A. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
LOVE it! try a fan too! me and my family sleep with them! can't sleep w/o a fan for noise! you don't have to face the fan on him but just for noise! Good luck with that!
Danni
L.W. answers from Norfolk on September 01, 2009
try simplynoise.com its great, I use it when I'm at the library to block people out. You can set up a speaker to the PC and put it in his room. He won't become dependent on it.. you can always slowly fade it out in time. But nothing beats the traditional bath and stories to get them to sleep. Good luck
More Answers
R.H. answers from Norfolk on September 01, 2009
my opinion on white noise isn't good. In my opinion i like to move things around change things up. I give my children something to sleep with but it's not always the same the only thing i can say is the same is the bed. I don't use pacifiers i don't believe it's a good thing to make them reliant on things. It only makes things harder as time goes on. You have to rush around the house for a pacifier or certain animal or blanket at bedtime or when you leave the house for extended amounts of time. With my kids i use a fan when it's hot, it grab any stuffed animal or blanket. I don't use the same thing every night. That way anything will do. Babies will conform. They can't yell as loud as their counterparts. I believe in breaking in first and not having the prob. when they are older and can yell your name from bed and say i want this certain thing. It avoids alot of trouble when they are older.
1 mom found this helpful
J.L. answers from Washington DC on August 31, 2009
We have been huge fans of the white noise machine since our 19 month old was born. It really does help drown out the noises of the house, and I think it's comforting to my daughter. My favorite is the Marpac Sound Machine, which I found on Amazon.com. It's expensive, but it's loud enough, and very simple to use. The other thing I like about it is that it's not a digital loop of sound that just repeats over and over again (and can be annoying, if you ask me) like some of the cheaper ones. Hope that helps!
Oh, and as to the "crutch" issue that the previous poster brought up, we've forgotten to turn it on before, and we don't travel with it, and our daughter still sleeps well. It just makes us more comfortable doing stuff around the house during naps and at night, because we're not afraid of making noise.
1 mom found this helpful
C.S. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
If it was me, I wouldn't get him used to the noise machine at 3 months, otherwise he may still need it at 3 years. I had the same situation when my kids were young and I found the best thing was to let the younger one take a nap when he was tired enough to fall asleep regardless of the noise his older syster made. If he wasn't sleepy enough to take a nap, I didn't force it.
Maybe try having your 23 month old daugher do a quiet activity (like looking at books or watching a video) as far away as possible from your 3 month old's sleeping area. If he doesn't fall asleep quickly, maybe wait for a later time when he will.
Also -- If you discover later that your child has ADD, white noise may not help at all and could even potentially keep someone with ADD awake. Just something to consider if you have ADD in your family, as we do.
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
S.M. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
We have a homedics sound machine and like it on Ocean Waves. I have always had the same sleep routine since our son came home from the hospital. Story and rocking, a CD played one time through of Good night my angel by billy joel and then the sound machine goes on. It really sets him up nice cos the whole experience says "Day is over - it's time to sleep" I even take it along when we travel so he sleeps like he does at home. Funny, our dog barking which was VERY loud and frequent never woke him. But the phone always does which is what I wanted to block out. I don't know if we have just had an easy sleeper - or if we set him up that way with the routine. But now that he's 4 and we've had alot of storms - it's great to mask those sounds so he doesn't wake up afraid. We adress the storm sounds in the day when it's not the scary night and he just thinks it's a cool sound and undertands where it comes from.
M.C. answers from Washington DC on August 31, 2009
It should be okay. Its good to teach them to sleep while there is noise. My husband's family used to make the house completely quiet for him to sleep. Now he can't sleep if there is the tiniest bit of noise. Complete silence or no sleep! It kills me.
D.A. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
LOVE it! try a fan too! me and my family sleep with them! can't sleep w/o a fan for noise! you don't have to face the fan on him but just for noise! Good luck with that!
Danni
K.C. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
We started using a noise maker (rain setting) when our little one was tiny. At the time we lived in a small place and needed the background noise for her. 2 years later in our house she still uses it but she doesn't have a problem sleeping without it unless it's nap time and we're mowing the lawn. That will wake her up -it'd wake me up too! :0) Personally I think they're fine.
M.G. answers from Washington DC on September 01, 2009
We use the static on our alarm clock/radio. Just set it to a non-station, and voila! Instant white noise!
Email