T.F. asks from Marshall, MI on April 23, 2010
What to Do When Baby Refuses a Bottle
Hello ladies, you have been so helpful to me before, I wanted to ask this quesiton for a friend of mine who isn't on Mamapedia. She has a new little girl, who did occasionally take a bottle until about 9 weeks of age. Since then she has taken a bottle two times. Mom needs to return to work soon, so she is looking for advice on what else she can try - this is what she has already done:
Playtex, Medela and Dr. Brown bottles and nipples
Different people giving her a bottle
Warm, cool, hot bottles. She has even tried formula.
Different times of day
She even tried giving it to her while she was swinging in her swing. Comical but didn't work.
She also called the breastfeeding center and they told her that the baby is just stubborn and to keep trying. They have tried everyday for the past four weeks - no luck.
She has even tried letting her crying it out or waiting until she is "really hungry".
Any advice is greatly appreciated. I know someone out there has dealt with this before, and will have some good ideas. Thanks!
Featured Answers
S.T. answers from Grand Rapids on April 26, 2010
I had the same issue with my daughter. I finally tried the Breast Flow brand that you can get at some (but not all) Target and some other stores. That was the only bottle she would take until 4 mos old. At six months, she started taking a Gerber Nuk sippy cup...sometimes the sippy nipple on the larger Gerber bottles, which is how she takes it now at 12 mos.
More Answers
S.T. answers from Grand Rapids on April 26, 2010
I had the same issue with my daughter. I finally tried the Breast Flow brand that you can get at some (but not all) Target and some other stores. That was the only bottle she would take until 4 mos old. At six months, she started taking a Gerber Nuk sippy cup...sometimes the sippy nipple on the larger Gerber bottles, which is how she takes it now at 12 mos.
L.S. answers from Chicago on April 24, 2010
Not sure how old the baby in question is, but when weening my kids (who were about 12 mos. at the time), i put a little bit of chocolate powder into their milk. Prior to this, neither one would take a bottle, no matter what I put in it, who gave it to them or how hungry they were. It worked, however, now at 3 and 4-1/2, neither of them drinks white milk ... only chocolate! Good Luck!
K.F. answers from Detroit on April 24, 2010
My kids have all tested me when it comes to the bottle. At about 9-12 weeks, they pick a preference and my breastfed babies preferred mom over any bottle. I tried dozens of different nipples and bottles, etc. There is a new one that I bought last time (it's by "The First Years" and looks like an actual nipple placed on a bottle). Depending on how stubborn the child was (and mine are very stubborn) it took a bit of coaxing. I had to pump and leave the milk at room temp to get them to drink. Someone else (my husband usually) had to give the bottle when I was nowhere to be found. My firstborn never did take a bottle, and I had to just switch her to a sippy cup at 3.5 months. Amazing, but she was fine with it. Mom is such a comfort item at that age that it is hard to hear your baby scream and it often seems easier just to give in and feed them. So, tell your friend to enlist help and leave the house so that she doesn't hear or isn't tempted to step in and help out. Babies are aware of all those things.
S.H. answers from Honolulu on April 23, 2010
For my son, whom I breastfed and gave bottles to, I used the "MAM" brand bottles, which I got from Amazon.
It is great! And it is BPA free.... and my son loved it!
I swear by these bottles.
And it accumulates no air bottles in the bottle as the baby is drinking.
all the best,
Susan
K.M. answers from Detroit on April 24, 2010
Has she tried the dr brown bottles or theres another one where they have made it to actually resemble the breast i think Johnson and Johnson make it. he only other thing is maybe try giving the baby a massage before a feeding some time it tires them out enough ey don't care what there sucking on. She needs to watch formula.... It will give them gas more and breast feed babies dont like formula and some do. Also have her start storing some babies who are breast fed need to be either cup feed or spoon fed. Good luck!
K.F. answers from Kalamazoo on April 24, 2010
I had the same problem with my son - it ended up that we kept trying different bottles until he finally took one (ended up with MAM bottles) and it wasn't easy! We tried different people, times, everything - eventually we had to just take him with the bottles to daycare and he did take them from the day care provider. It was almost as if he realized that was it - when we tried at home he knew I was there and he saw me leave at day care?!?
Good luck!
S.H. answers from Detroit on April 24, 2010
oh do I feel for this mom! I had the same problem, but my daughter would not take a bottle, not even one time until she was 7 months old! I have heard that the mom has to actually leave the house because they can still smell if their around (although this didn't work for me)... we held out for almost 8 hours hoping she would get hungry enough to drink the bottle... that was torture and didn't work either! THANKFULLY, my husband wasn't working a normal type of job at the time, and my work was flexible enough that we actually met up in random parking lots (I worked in 3 different places) so I could feed the baby. It was really hard on him too, because he spent a lot of time with a baby that wouldn't drink a bottle!! At 7 months, she grabbed the bottle (we kept trying) and started chugging away like a pro... and would never breast feed again... which by this time, was fine by me!!!! Because we both had more flexible schedules, we just worked it out... I don't know what we would have done if this wasn't the case... but I do wish your friend luck :-) Either way... this moment will pass, and will become another funny story to tell in the future!
G.S. answers from Detroit on April 24, 2010
We had this problem with my grandson and found that sucking on a botttle was to difficult, he had a slight ear infection at the time, so I tried dipping a straw in his juice or milk until he got the hang of sipping thru the straw and he has never taken a bottle since. He still breast feeds when Mom is there but prefers a straw the rest of the time. I have done this with other babies and had the same results. It is worth a try.
Email