M.W. asks from Riverton, UT on February 13, 2008
Too Much Music?
My 12-year-old girl is absolutely into music (bands like My Chemical Romance, Linkin Park, Shiny Red Guns, etc). Sometimes it seems like she can't live without the music, and when we ask her to turn it off or get off the computer (where she looks up music videos on My Space or You Tube), she begs to remain online and drags out her time with the music for hours. My husband and I are deaf so we don't listen to music nor have we had experience during our teen years wanting music. Is this normal, and how do you control/regulate the amount of time kids listen to music?
Featured Answers
J.P. answers from Phoenix on February 14, 2008
That is completely normal. Music is very emotional to people and they feel a connection to it in times where they feel lonely, or happy, or many other moods. People with creative minds tend to have an even stronger connection to it. If she is spending more time online than you would like, however, you might want to suggest that she start taking guitar lessons or something similar. It helps create complex connections in her brain and can give her something to do besides wasting away in front of the computer. Also, she might like writing poetry, you could put her in a poetry class.
H.M. answers from Fort Collins on February 14, 2008
I have a 13 year old girl and she is the same way. Music is a way that kids in the teenage years deal with creating their own identity. Music has been proven to help kids multi-task and helps with memory. I think it is much better to have a music hungry teen than a couch potato.
Hope this helps.
H. M
M.P. answers from Salt Lake City on February 14, 2008
It is normal for teens and preteens to want to listen to music. My advice to you would be to talk to her about the music she listens to and have her (or you) get the words to the music so, since you can't hear it, you will at least know the messages she is getting. Watch her moods and talk to her about how the music makes her feel. Some of the music my kids were listening to was depressing or moody and the songs weren't doing anything to promote good feelings. If she wants to be on the computer are listening all the time, set some boundaries. Her room should be clean, homework should be done and she should at least help at around the house. She could even listen while she cleans! You are still the parent so don't cave in to the begging. If she hasn't held up her end of the bargain then she doesn't get the music. I'm not a perfect parent, by any means, but I do know that music can play a huge roll in a teenagers life.
More Answers
K.H. answers from Grand Junction on February 14, 2008
I too loved music when I was your daughter's age. I now have a 12yo son and he is really in to music as well. I agree with the other posts regarding limits and making sure there is other interaction with the family. I would also set limits as to what type of music she is allowed to listen to. I would reccommend that you look up the lyrics on the internet and see if they fit the values you have in place for your family. Since you have two younger children, this is a good time to establish the boundaries you want to have around this influence on your children individually and your family as a whole. I don't like everything my son likes. There is some I just won't allow him to listen to but we have discussed why. We talk about the lyrics and the message and I ask him what he thinks about it. I ask him if he agrees with it or if he thinks it is either evil or sexist or racist, etc. I ask him if the language is something he should be feeding his mind with. I remind him that what he puts in his mind, becomes thoughts and actions. Is this the kind of thing he wants in it? Most of the time he chooses wisely. Sometimes I have to over-rule and I can because I am the parent :). He has even come to me and said "This song is great Mom, but it has one bad word in it. Can I listen to it anyway?" I like having that type of connection with him. When he is away from me with his friends, I realize I have little control about what he listens to. But he has no doubt what I believe is appropriate for him and the reason I want him to think about what he feeds his mind. I love him too much to let him make these type of decisons on his own, but I respect him enough to give him some freedom to find the way that works for him. I applaud you for reaching out for guidance.
1 mom found this helpful
S.S. answers from Pueblo on February 14, 2008
Let her listen to music, I think it is there way to express who they are and what they like. I have a 17 year old daughter, she has been listening to music since i conceived her. Her love for music is great, she listens to everthing not just one type, she is in choir and sings through the house. Freedom of expression, do not tkae that from them. I could not even imagine not having some kind of music playing in my house. I fyou take her music away she will find something not productive to do, I think you let them express there feelings.
A.H. answers from Grand Junction on February 14, 2008
I recommend getting a portable music device and a stack of blank journals. Sitting on the computer watching videos seems like it may be 'wasting' time, but if she has an outlet for her own creativity, it will be very valuable to her psychological development and identity.
And, many people never grow out of the need for constant music immersion. My husband and I always have sound on, and own upwards of 15 instruments in aiding us produce our own. I think the key is to learn to have normal functioning lives and let the music be the background comfort. The only thing I would regulate is dedicated music time.
J.L. answers from Pocatello on February 14, 2008
I think listening to the music is just fine. As the other mothers have said, it's normal and there is no harm in it. It may be a good idea to set time limits on her computer use. If she knows how long she has up front she will know what is expected and although she will still not be happy about the limitations, knowing exactly what they are helps. Let her be involved in the decision as to how much time she is allowed to spend and tell her why you don't want her on the computer for so long. If she doesn't know why she is having limitations put on her she will really resist.
F.B. answers from Fort Collins on February 14, 2008
I haven't read through all the responses, but in case nobody else brought it up, there is a danger of hearing loss if one listens to loud music for many hours a day. The damage occurs pretty slowly and may not start to be annoying until they're older, but with the prevalence of ipods many more people may be causing themselves hearing loss.
One example I saw was that if you were mowing the lawn and the ipod was turned loud enough to hear over the mower, a safe listening time would be about 15 minutes.
So while you're making agreements with your daughter, you might bring up the issue of volume control.
M.P. answers from Salt Lake City on February 14, 2008
It is normal for teens and preteens to want to listen to music. My advice to you would be to talk to her about the music she listens to and have her (or you) get the words to the music so, since you can't hear it, you will at least know the messages she is getting. Watch her moods and talk to her about how the music makes her feel. Some of the music my kids were listening to was depressing or moody and the songs weren't doing anything to promote good feelings. If she wants to be on the computer are listening all the time, set some boundaries. Her room should be clean, homework should be done and she should at least help at around the house. She could even listen while she cleans! You are still the parent so don't cave in to the begging. If she hasn't held up her end of the bargain then she doesn't get the music. I'm not a perfect parent, by any means, but I do know that music can play a huge roll in a teenagers life.
H.M. answers from Fort Collins on February 14, 2008
I have a 13 year old girl and she is the same way. Music is a way that kids in the teenage years deal with creating their own identity. Music has been proven to help kids multi-task and helps with memory. I think it is much better to have a music hungry teen than a couch potato.
Hope this helps.
H. M
M.B. answers from Missoula on February 14, 2008
you can go and read the lyrics , that will give you a little insight as to the type of music she listens to..
our 13 yr is just now getting into music and we have always kept that watchful eye and did put stops to some music as for ,in our household its not acceptable...time limits and follow through when you say thats enough...
Email