S.G. asks from San Antonio, TX on December 15, 2009
Should I Tell the parent...or Let It Go?
My daughter is in kindergarten. So far this year, another girl in her class has done the following to my daughter: thrown food at her, threw her sandwich container under the lunch table, ruined her art project while I was volunteering in the classroom, saying mean things. Before school started, the mom invited us over for the girls to meet, and my daughter left crying, after she threw a toy at her head that she didn't want her playing with. Needless to say, we haven't returned the invitation. These episodes have gone on and off thruout the year. I addressed the incidences with the teacher, she said that she has some control issues. This week we are invited to this girl's bday party at her home. Today my daughter said that the girl was mean to her at school...she scribbled on her artwork and tried squirting water on her. She said she doesn't want to go to her party anymore. I told her that she doesn't have to go and I would support her choice of only atttending events where the kids treat her nicely. Which leads me to my question....do I tell the mom about the incident...or do I make up some generic reason why we aren't attending? We live in the same neighborhood and I don't want it to be awkward...but if it were my child, I'd want to know. Any advice?
2 moms found this helpful
Featured Answers
B.S. answers from San Antonio on December 16, 2009
I've read some of the responses, and I think you should talk to the Mom. Now to play the devil's advocate here. My son was eventually dxed with Aspergers. He would throw awful fits, and fitting in socially was so hard at that age. I am so grateful for the parents that had the compassion to help my son by helping him learn social behavior. So, maybe the other girl is just a bully with mom who is in the dark about her daughter, or maybe the mom knows and is doing her best.
So, talk to the mom, but in a non-judgemental way. If the child is helped now to learn proper social behavior, it will help her a lot. I know, my son is soooo much better now, thanks to concerned teachers, parents, and therapists.
2 moms found this helpful
E.S. answers from Houston on December 15, 2009
Hi S.,
This is a hard question since you will have to face each other because you live in the same neighborhood. Has the teacher not discussed this with the childs mother? I would also bring this to the attention of the counselor so that she knows what is going on and can talk to the little girl. Also, document all the times this is happening so if you need to bring it to the attention of others it is noted. Good luck with this problem. I hope it gets resolved.
2 moms found this helpful
L.B. answers from Corpus Christi on December 17, 2009
The mother needs to know what is going on when she is not around. The girl may need some special help and the only way that they will know what to do is to hear about these things from some of the other parents that are having problems with her behavior. Good luck. I have been there also.+
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
K.B. answers from Houston on December 15, 2009
Hi S.-
I would tell the mom the truth about why your daughter does not want to attend. You don't have to be confrontational about it, just very matter of fact. I would say, "my daughter does not feel comfortable attending the party or playdates with your daughter because there have been some incidents in school" and then provide a few examples. I would not go into a laundry list of incidents (unless she seems open to the conversation and wants a lot of specifics) just because it seems like you have held your tongue for a long time and it's not fair to suddenly blindside her with a huge list of problems that she was unaware of. Give her enough to know that it's serious so she can take action but not so much that she feels attacked and just gets defensive.
Good luck,
K.
4 moms found this helpful
L.H. answers from Austin on December 16, 2009
As a preschool teacher, my advise to you would to be perfectly honest. Tell the mother you are concerned with the behavior that both girls are exhibiting. You child is being targeted but unfortunately feels she can not speak up for herself. Try teaching her the vocabulary she needs to deal with the girl. And is the elementary school teacher out to lunch? This is such a tough scenario. Chances are the other mother feels terrible about what is going on as well (if she knows).Perhaps she isn't aware...in which case it is extremely important for you to share your concern. Don't worry about awkwardsness...this is your little girl. She needs you as an advocate. She obviously isn't getting it from her teacher. Good luck!
3 moms found this helpful
S.O. answers from San Antonio on December 16, 2009
I wouldn't mention it before the party - but maybe as an explanation afterward. Something like: I'm so sorry we didn't make it to the party. But, it seems as my daughter and yours aren't getting along so well in school and my daughter was really nervous about going to the party. So, we decided to stay home and not take a chance on ruining your party. Leave it at that unless the parent wants details. Then give the details without accusing the parent of anything and let her handle it.
3 moms found this helpful
K.B. answers from San Antonio on December 16, 2009
First of all let me say that I am sorry that your daughter has been the target of behavior that is hurtful. Secondly let me say that I am certain that mom knows her daughter has these issues. She is more than likely overwhelmed, embarrassed, and unsure about what to do about her own child. As a mom of a "special needs" child, I too was mortified with what my child had been doing to others (both kids and teachers) in his preschool, and I was the preschool director! I had no idea why my child was behaving the way he was considering we were raising him as we were our other children and they were not doing those things. After taking him for some testing and spending 2+ years in occupational therapy we finally got his behavior under control at least for the most part when it came to school and party type behavior. I did have a friend who decided not to allow her child to "associate" with our son because of our son's behavior and it hurt me and really hurt my son. My son did not recognize that his behavior was not what you would call "normal" because he is just one of those kids who is wired differently. We had to find different ways to communicate teaching him what behavior is appropriate. It is possible this family is the same way and you want to teach your daughter that although God makes us all different we are all special- Tell your daughter that regardless of how others treat us we are to be kind and loving and set an example of being kind and loving in order to win others over- she is not to young to begin to learn that lesson. That having been said- shadow your daughter at the birthday party and if something happens gently say to the difficult child- "you know that really hurts (insert daughter's name here)- then use the phrase- "let's be sure to treat all our friends with loving kindness ok?!" Using this phrase will alert the child that her behavior hurts and gives her a chance to start again without someone really scolding her. It also shows your daughter how to speak up and use words. This is a great bonding opportunity that you and your daughter have been given and an exceptional teaching moment! Be strong and positive mom! You can do it!
3 moms found this helpful
J.T. answers from College Station on December 16, 2009
I would gracefully decline the invitation, letting the other mom know that your children are not friends.
You do need to ask the teacher if this child is doing these things to other children or is she just targeting your daughter. If she is just targeting your daughter, then I would mention something to the mom. If she is spreading the wealth so to speak, I would demand that the school approach the parents and deal with the situation.
3 moms found this helpful
V.S. answers from San Antonio on December 16, 2009
I was in the same situation and asked a mother with older children what I should do. Her advice was that unless it was a bullying situation, stay out of it. Kids change and sometimes one child is being mean to your child and sometimes your child is the one being mean (of course she wasn't refering to MY child - he is perfect!) : )
Every bone in my body wanted to call the parent but I didn't. I stayed out of it and she was right. The kids worked it out. Kids go through all kinds of things. The best thing you can do is to teach your child how to handle "mean" kids. I told my son that not everyone in life is going to be nice to you and then I gave him ideas of what to do and say when it is happening to him. He needed to know how to handle it. And I support his decisions. I definitely agree that your daughter should not have to go to the birthday party of someone who hits her. She should be able to choose who she wants to hang out with.
And isn't our job as parents to prepare our children for life? Not everyone is going to treat them fairly. This could be a great learning exercise for your daughter.
So make up some lame excuse (even though you really want to tell her how awful her child is being) and don't go. Because as a parent, it's really hard to forgive anyone who says something negative about your child. You have to live in the same neighborhood with this woman. Once you do it, there's no going back. Let the teacher handle it. That's why they make the big bucks - ha ha.
Good luck!!
2 moms found this helpful
S.S. answers from Santa Barbara on December 15, 2009
S.-
I would just say to the mom that your daughter won't be attending because the girls don't seem to get along, then leave it at that. If she inquires further, you can give her examples. Try not to get emotional (this is hard, because it's your baby getting picked on.) The mom might be surprised, but most likely she won't be. My guess is that in her mind she'll probably blame it on your daughter no matter what.
Also, for the future, you might want to request that the girls be in separate classrooms. I had to do this for my son. We had a neighbor kid who always used my son as a scapegoat. I just wanted that removed from the school environment, since I had to deal with it at home.
Best of luck,
S.
2 moms found this helpful
K.M. answers from Houston on December 16, 2009
By all means, tell the mom! My daughter, 10, has had a bully since last school year. I thought, because I was told, that the principal and teachers were handling it. The principal told me the girls' mother had been made aware, but until this bully physical hurt my daughter and threatened to "snap her neck" I had not contacted the mom, as I trusted the school system. Well, I talked to her mom and now the girls are friends; not close enough to spend nights or anything, as I still don't trust the girl; but are getting along at school. The mom had NO IDEA and was horrified that her daughter had been doing all of the things she'd been doing to my daughter. This mom needs to know NOW, so she can put a stop to it. I'd also ask the teacher if she's informed the mother of the problems. Good Luck!
2 moms found this helpful
Email