J.B. asks from Grosse Pointe, MI on July 09, 2009
Potty Training Questions - Grosse Pointe,MI
I've just started potty training my almost 3 year old son and have a couple of questions. The first day we started at my mom's house and let him be outside and naked from the waist down. He went in the potty 5 times. When we were getting ready to leave, we put underwear on and he almost immediately wet in them. The next day we had a couple of accidents. My husband went out for Pull-Ups (he got "Good Nites", which I think are about the same, right?) and my son will pee/poop in those. The following day we spent the day outside again, this time in underwear. He did not wet at all, but he didn't go in the potty either. He waited until naptime (when we put him in a diaper). This morning, he wanted underwear on, and he wet himself, but immediately told me "Momma, I'm going potty!" and we ran to the potty. He had already gone all he was going to go.
Should we not be putting him in a diaper or pull-up? Should we just use underwear? I was thinking about getting him training pants, the ones that look like underwear but have a little more padding. Are those worth it? My mom kind of talked me out of them because she said they wouldn't save my sofa anyhow and they are more expensive. I realize that it's really early (we just started Monday), but I'm really clueless. My stepson's mom did all the potty training for him, so this is my first time. Any advice would really be appreciated. Thanks!
Featured Answers
S.C. answers from Detroit on July 23, 2009
Hi! I am new to the potty training thing. but let me tell you this.. I tried for 1 yr (on and off..strick and not so) to get my son to go potty..Well, one day he got it. I wasn't even trying anymore he just decided he was ready to wear the big boy underwear that we bought for him..he is doing well. we are 2 months into it and he has had 2 accidents (from being lazy..nothing else..playing and not wanting to go) he has been dry at night since day one. but I wont say that out loud bc everytime I do I put my foot in my mouth..lol...just let him lead. trust me I found out the hard way.. HE WILL GET IT!!
More Answers
J.S. answers from Detroit on July 10, 2009
I started this when my son turned 3, and had to stop for a few moths as he was using it as blackmail (i.e. he would "have" to go when needing to be in a time out or dinner). So We took a break from it and have resently staarted back up again and are doing very well.
Personaly any type of pullups or diaper just did't work. he always peed/pooped in them.
I liked the training pains personally b/c although it didn't "save my couch" it did help to contain a good portion of the mess.
And you should try a reward system for everytime he goes to the potty. M&Ms didn't work for my son but a sticker chart worked really well. I made a chart and had cartoon pictures of little boys sitting on the potty that I got off the internet and he got a sticker for everything that he did even just sitting on the potty. But the poopoo sticker was a special sticker that he only got when he did #2.
Just remember that this will take time, and there will be messes to clean up. There is always a beginning, middle, and end. And the middle is always the hardest. I had to remind myself over and over and over agin that I am in the middle, it will get better. And it has. We are not quite at the end yet though but we are getting there.
I still have to keep on him about if he has to go, but if I forget to and he starts to have an accedent he will now stop & run to the potty to finish. So we are getting there.
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
N.S. answers from Saginaw on July 10, 2009
Hi, I just had to write to you. When my now 7 year old was in the middle of potty training, I became a maniac. I tried everything on that poor kid. I would set the alarm for 45 minutes and make him sit on the potty. I would put cheerios in the potty and try target practice. I did everything. I'm surprised I didn't give this poor kid a complex. Still, the week after he turned 3 ( I started this whole thing when he was 2), he really decided he was potty trained on his own. It was seriously like he woke up one morning and decided that was the day. It really had nothing to do with me. I think you are doing all the right things. I recommend the pull-ups, lots of praise when he does the right thing. His little body will know when it's the right time. Now that my youngest (well, soon to be middle child) just turned 2, I'm not nearly as freaked out. Just wanted to let you know you're doing everything right. N. S.l
1 mom found this helpful
K.O. answers from Detroit on July 10, 2009
My son trained just a couple of weeks before he turned 3. We started on a Tuesday, and by Friday he was having virtually no accidents.
We went right to underwear and just took him to the bathroom every 1 1/2 for pee. He is very regular with his poops...3 times a day after every meal. So that was actually easier to ensure we got him to the potty!
We only use pull ups at night and during nap. And actually, he wakes up from naps dry and most mornings too. We make sure that he goes pee before and right after nap, too.
Also, we always make him go right before we leave the house. He has done great when we're out right from the beginning. Good luck with your training. Be patient and supportive!
1 mom found this helpful
D.P. answers from Detroit on July 10, 2009
Welcome to the wonderful world of the potty, J.!
Some things that I didn't see others pointing out were:
Girls and boys go to the bathroom at different ages. Girls start at about 2 1/2-3 yrs and boys at about 3-3 1/2 yrs. Those are average ages that I read about in Parents or Parenting magazines. It is something about brain development and when they are physically capable of this new skill.
Going to the bathroom is one thing that our kids have absolute control over. It does not matter how much we want them to do this. On top of them being aware of what their body is doing, they have to choose to follow it and sit on the potty/toilet.
Chin up! You are doing great, Mom! There is a light at the end of the tunnel! You are almost there! It is amazing how a little poop in the toilet can mean so much to us as a "parenting report card." I joked with my mother-in-law that I could only do so much and then it would just be his wife's problem. But, really, we all (or most all) get there before Kindergarten.
And, if their method of going very closely resembles a diaper change then they don't really learn anything. I learned the hard way with my son. He would pee in the toilet because standing and peeing was cool. He would poop in his undies and not tell me. I was not throwing out undies because of a little poop. I soaked/cleaned in the toilet. (Gloves were used) It became clear that even this was too much like a diaper change because I was the one doing everything. So, when he was 2 mos. shy of his 4th birthday, I started having him help clean the undies. He quickly decided that putting the poop into the toilet was way easier. (Within a few days)
Another key was that my husband and I were in agreement about the plan. We had the united front-there was no dividing/conquering to be had. That may have helped to nudge him in the right direction. Daddy took over much of the training after I pointed out that I couldn't stand and pee. My husband really stepped up for this and is still my hero!
My son is almost 8 and my daughter is 5. I've been blessed with kids who can go anywhere-not just home like I've heard about from friends. However, that means that even if we go before we leave home that we also go in a restaurant because they want to check out the bathroom. They could probably write a book on the ones they do or don't recommend. I also rememmber, fondly, when they would sing silly songs (they were in the stall) and entertain all the ladies in the ladies rooms. They have outgrown that. And, Daddy takes our son to the Men's room now. I don't think he sings in there.
I hope this helps to let you know that you aren't the first/last to deal with these things and that you know your child best and can see it through! This too, shall pass. (Pun intended)
D.
1 mom found this helpful
A.O. answers from Detroit on July 09, 2009
Having potty trained 2 kids we had the best luck with sticking to underwear! Only at bedtime did we use pull-ups, and only until they were fully potty trained during the day did we stop putting on pull ups at bedtime.
We would reming them A LOT to use the potty during the day, and reward them for going, and for even trying. M&M's worked great! Also a lot of praise for a good job. There will be accidents-no matter what. Don't get upset, just remind them that they are big now and need to use the potty like big kids. Especially when they are playing and having fun they will forget to go until it's too late.
No pull ups during the day-they are too much like a diaper and they have no incentive to change anything.
Hope this helped. Hang in there!
1 mom found this helpful
R.H. answers from Detroit on July 10, 2009
Hi J..
It sounds like he is on track. Keep in mind... he's learned to go pee and poo where ever he is in whatever was on his bottom. He's done this for three years. That's a long habit to unlearn.
First, he needs to relearn his body awareness. It sounds like that is coming since he told you he was going potty! Praise him for that!!! Make a big deal about it when HE recognizes he has to go.
In the meantime, what I would suggest is that you do the timed thing. Start out with taking him potty every 10 minutes... then stretch it out to 20 minutes and so on. Also, notice his liquid intake and how soon after he drinks does he need to pee. Also, many kids (and adults for that matter) are pretty regular in the poo department... meaning there is a particular time of day when it is more likely to occur. Take note and then when it is approaching that time.... pay particular attention to any changes in your son. For example... blank stare, squatting, disappearing (sometimes kids will hide and poo in their dipes), etc... then take him to the potty and see if he has to go poo.
Patience. It is key. As well as being calm and not scolding for accidents.
I am not a huge fan of pull-ups. I do use them for particular occasions ... like when we go to church and our daughter is in her sunday school class. But honestly, kids know they can go in them and they will. Kids would rather keep playing then stop and go to the bathroom.
If you rinse out the undies right away, they won't be ruined. Trust me. We've dealt with MANY accidents. My daughters panties are fine. Sure, it means more laundry ... but honestly, it helps them learn. In the pull ups my daughter never really had that 'wet' feeling. I even tried the ones with the cool alert. Whatever. She either ignored it, or never felt it. However, wet panties... now that she does not like. At all. So, it helped her not want to have accidents because she didn't like that feeling.
Another thing that really was a turning point for us was a good friend of mine blessed me with a couple of gifts. A potty stool and one of those integrated potty seats. So easy to put on your toilet and so worth it! These things allowed my daughter to get up there by herself. We tried the little potty chair ... but eventually she wanted to go like mama on the big potty. Giving her the tools to do something by herself was huge.
Just remember... it's a commitment not only for your son, but for you. You have to help him learn when he has to go. Right now, he isn't paying attention to his body signals... the first step is to get him in tune with those signals...then you can move on to what to do about those signals.
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
L.L. answers from Benton Harbor on July 10, 2009
google "cloth training pants"
There are lots of options. I think they feel it and therefore become more aware of their body's activity when wearing cloth. IMO those disposable pull ups make potty training take longer because they never feel wet to them even the supposed wet ones and then they end up wearing them for several months and that can get expensive. I invested in some good cloth training pants that have an outside layer that does protect your furniture even good enough for overnight without changing the sheets. I don't know the name of my daytime ones but I used "Happy Heiny's" for night time. I tried the ones from the stores and haven't liked them because they leak but there are lots of online stores and some specialty baby shops. They are worth it and I will use them on my next child as well. They are not hard to clean either.
1 mom found this helpful
S.K. answers from Saginaw on July 10, 2009
I was talking to a friend about potty training my grandaughter. She told me what she did, and it took 1 day. She told her friends and husband not to call on the day she decided to do the training. She had a doll that you use to pee in the potty, also she bought salty snacks and juices to feed the child. She statred with the child and doll-teaching the doll how to potty in the toilet. Rewarded the "doll"-m$m or whatever. Of course the child got the reward. Then started doing it with the child. Feeding the salty snacks and drinks. She said it usually took i day.
S.
1 mom found this helpful
Email