Hi L. :)
It sounds like a lot of the responses you got were to just kind of chill for a while longer and don't push the issue with your daughter. Take a rest/break from trying to train her. I totally agree.
My son just turned three and everyone kept trying to tell us he was for sure ready at around two or not long after (although our dr says "OH...I always tell people to not even TRY to train boys until at least 3...they'll go back and forth and then you'll just be frustrated and feel like you are training them for forever!") Well,...we tried anyway and he got all excited and seemed like he was totally ready. He did great for about two weeks and then wanted nothing to do with the potty around momma and daddy after that. ???? It was a little frustrating because he seemed so ready then and when we were at grandma's house he still wanted to go for her. I read part of SuperNanny's book and she was saying if a child is ready, they are ready. That's it - none of this training for 6 months or longer or "training" in pullups, which kids a lot of times think of as just a different type of diaper. If they are truly ready and you are too - put them in regular undies and decide this will happen. So, I made up my mind this obviously was not the right time - he just wasn't ready yet. He would scream and almost cry and throw a fit that he didn't want to go on the potty - so why in the world should I force him and make it such a battle (that he would win anyway). So I made sure he stayed in diapers quite a bit longer - even at grandma's house so it wouldn't be so confusing. (We also were expecting another, so I knew I wanted to wait until all the turmoil and chaos with a new baby was out of the way too)
But when I felt he was finally ready, I had to know I was ready too. I was going to take another shot at it and I thought this time I will for sure do things a little different. Make sure you stay home for a couple of days and every 20 min, or half hour, or hour - whatever works best for you or her...make her go. That's what I did. And from the get-go I put him in cloth undies. I had the Gerber cotton training pants. He did great. (I tried to not go anywhere for about a week so he could just not wear pants to make it easier for him) We also had both kinds of potty seats - a little one, his size, and one that you can put on the regular toilet. I made him start going on the little one, that way if he needed to go he could start doing that by himself without my help, or not so much of it. (he wouldn't need my help climbing up to get on the big potty if I just made him use the little one) He's maybe had two accidents - if that - since I've done that - maybe 4 months ago. I think that's just because he couldn't get his pants down in enough time. And then if I had to go out, for several months - I brought the little potty in the car with us(on the floor) wherever we went and made him go before we went into a store or dr's or wherever and then again before we got back into the carseat. MUCH easier than trying to go into a public bathroom at that point in the game - at least my opinion!! Now, he's great at telling me and holding it and we can go into a restroom and not have it be a great ordeal or worry as much about sanitary stuff - I know I have time to do what I need to do to "get things ready". :)
We do use a diaper at nap and at bedtime though, because I know he's not ready for that change yet. He's doing great and there are many mornings he doesn't have any pee in his diaper at all, but I know it's too soon. The days that he does have pee in his diaper I know he doesn't even have a clue he's peed in the middle of the night, so there's no way he's ready to try to wake up to go.
I do have to say though that right now, that's just peeing. He is a super pee-er!!!! :) Poopin', well...that's a different story...He was going in the potty to poop too, but then all of a sudden he started to not want to go in the potty. Out of the blue - nothing happened - he just all of a sudden decided he HAD to have a diaper to go poop. It was starting to be the same routine as before - he started throwing a fit and screaming he didn't want to go in the potty and I would try to make him. But finally, I just gave up. I realized when the time is right for the pooping...the time will be right. I can't force it, even though it would make life a little easier (and our trash less stinky!!) He'll do that when he's ready too. Just like when he was finally ready to pee on the potty - it was a breeze, SO easy... At his last dr visit they were asking how it was going and I told them and they said that it's all completely normal and it sometimes happens - pooping usually takes longer. If they're not ready, just put a diaper on them and let them go so they won't make themselves constipated or give themselves other issues because they hold it in and won't go. They'll come around eventually to trying on the potty.
In reading things on this site someone once wrote about pottytraining a different time as well and one response said something like - they all get trained. Some take longer than others, but they all get trained. When you send them off to school - they all will have underwear on and not diapers - so don't worry and don't push the issue. It all happens when it's supposed to. After reading that, I was a lot more relaxed about the whole process. It doesn't bother me when people think he should be trained by now or should have been a long time ago. I know he's going at his own pace and that's all that I can go at too. They'll either go at their own pace or have accidents all the time if you don't follow their lead.
So, that's my VERY long story and advice to you. :) Maybe now is just not the right time for your daughter, she's just not really ready. She's close, but not yet. Give her a little longer and try again. I recommend when the time is right to try again, try cotton undies and not pullups, but that's just me.
I wish you the best. :) Everything is a work in progress and learn as you go with kids. You should see us - we are REALLY a work in progress!!!! No doubt about it!!! :) All those thoughts or looks you used to give parents before you had kids...yeah,...HA!!! Makes you just want to laugh now, doesn't it??!!!