S.S. asks from Olathe, KS on March 15, 2008
Potty Training - Olathe, KS - Mom with 1 kid
I have a 23 month old son and I was wondering when I should start potty training him. He is one of those kids that is constantly running. I am afraid that I will not be able to keep him on the potty chair long enough for him to learn to go. Any suggestions would be great.
Featured Answers
T.S. answers from Springfield on March 17, 2008
He is old enough to start potty training. I hate to tell you this, but it took forever for my son to potty train. I was afraid he was going to go to Kindergarten still potty training! I tried just about everything- the trick that worked for me from the first time was Cheerios. Get him to try to hit the Cheerios in the toilet. I know that's for him standing, and it doesn't help with "#2", but it's a start for when you're ready. I'm sorry that I don't have any tricks for #2, that took the longest with a lot of patience, but eventually it was just like it happened overnight. Good luck!
L.K. answers from Springfield on March 16, 2008
My daughter likes to be read to. So, I kept two of her favorite books in the bathroom, and only read them when she was sitting on the tolet. This really helped for those times when she didn't want to sit for more than a second. I hope this helps.
More Answers
K.W. answers from St. Louis on March 16, 2008
I have 3 boys -- none of them were really "trained" until their 3rd birthdays, even though I used different tactics with each. My advice is: Don't push it, you'll make yourself crazy!
I started by getting them a potty chair, a video and "big boy pants" for their 2nd birthday. I prefered using training pants as opposed to Pull ups, just using them at night.(they didn't feel wet and the boys weren't anxious to get changed when they had an accident) Start in the summer (less clothes to wash). Let Dad help -- my sons wanted to pee standing up like Dad. Also used cherrios in the potty to "aim." This made it kind of a game. With active boys who are always running, you HAVE to keep reminding them. Instead of "do you have to go?" I always would say "it's time to go" & take them to the bathroom when I had to go during the day. Lots of praise, of course and no penalties for accidents.
Be patient and try to make it an exciting, fun experience. Boys don't develop the muscle control as quickly as girls. I found that it didn't matter if I worked hard at it & worried about it, or just let it be -- each boy had his own timetable for getting the job done!
1 mom found this helpful
R.B. answers from Kansas City on March 16, 2008
My son is now 25 months and the same active way. You will get a bunch of responses on there, and they may work, however I was able to train my son in 3 days a week after he turned 2. I suggest googling....3 Day Potting Training and reading that. You do have to purchase the manual once you think you might like it....It's around $20 however it's excellent and it WORKS!!!!!!
D.M. answers from Kansas City on March 16, 2008
My son is 2½ and i just started training him, although I wish I would have started sooner. I had a week of vacation, which helped immensely, and made him wear big boy undies only. He peed and hated the feeling of wet underwear. My boy is also very active. He finally got to wear he would hold his peepee when he needed to go and we would take him right away. When he went we would reward him for going pee by giving him an m&m. We've only been training for a week and we are doing great.
C.G. answers from Columbia on March 16, 2008
I work with toddlers so I see a lot of kids going through the toilet learning process. We give parents a "potty packet" including a check list for signs of readiness. Some of the signs include the child being able to notice when they need to go, being able to tell you, being able to use words like "pee" and "poo," disliking a wet diaper, being able to pull pants up and down, staying dry for at least two hours, and more.
In addition, in the child's brain, myelinization must be complete before potty training can occur. Parents can try and try, but until this happens, it won't work. This means that long motor neurons reach from the Betz cells of the motor cortex in the brain down to the urethral sphincters, which control the flow of urine. For the child to be able to control this themselves, these long motor neurons must be fully covered with a white, fatty sheath, called myelin. This myelinization allows voluntary control over these muscles and may not happen until about 24 months of age.
Anyway, children are developmentally ready to potty train at different ages. If they are ready, some children will take a few weeks. If the child is not ready, it can take much longer. I'm not sure what kinds of readiness signs your son is showing, but each child will be ready at a different age so it's hard to say a specific age to start. It should be individual to your son. I would avoid power struggles, as it can make it a stressful and tense situation for him.
Many parents use rewards, but I personally do not agree with this because this is a normal body function that everyone does and I don't think rewards really have anything to do with using the bathroom. I've seen so many kids learn to use the potty as "just something you do" rather than something you get a reward for.
Remember, learning to potty train really is a LEARNING PROCESS and, like most other things, not something that can be taught overnight. Even children who are mostly potty trained will have accidents from time to time and this is normal. Just keep in mind, no normally functioning child will grow up to walk down the isle wearing diapers! Just keep it positive and it will happen in time.
S.R. answers from St. Louis on March 16, 2008
S.,
I am of the belief that a baby should be potty trained as soon as they have made the connection dirtying their pants. If they have messed in their diaper and they come and tell you about - it's definiately time to start - If you see them concentrating on going - jump up and try to get them to the potty before they finish.
Every one is different. - trust your instincts more than all the books and/or advice given.
S. ###-###-####
W.B. answers from Kansas City on March 15, 2008
Hi S.,
I am a mother of 4 children and a home child care provider. I was just talking to one of my daycare parents about this last night and here is what I told her. And this is what I work on with the kids in my daycare.
I feel from the age of birth - 1 yr your main goal for your child is getting to all her first milestones, like rolling over, sitting up, crawling, and then walking.
From the ages of 1 yr until 3 yrs, you spend your time working with them on getting themselves dressed, working on good communication skills, using words, learning the body parts and sharing with other kids.
In between the time of 2 1/2 and 3 the potty training comes into play. So now you are setting up for potty training. The ways you start this is by taking them at key areas during the day: 1st thing in the morning when they wake up, after breakfast, before/after lunch, before/after naptime, before/after bathtime and before bed. Now somekids like my daughter were ready at 2 1/2 but I was expecting a new baby and didn't want to be in the middle of potty training, have a new baby, not sure what to expect from that and then I have to backtrack all of the time and effort we had put in. So when I did potty train her we went from pullups to panties and we were potty trained in 1 week.
1 of the daycare girls I watch has/had all the classic sign of ready to be potty trained. Her mom started with her at 18 months. She would and still will bring you a clean pullup and wipes and tell you she pooped, she will say she just peed and go get a clean pullup and put it on and throw the old one in the trash. Everything was goin good but 1 problem she will not poop on the potty and we tried for a couple weeks and she was severly constipated. This was back in November of this year. Now with her new brother is here and mom is on Maturnity leave and home with him and I don't yet have him we are thinking it would probably be a good time to readdress the potty training.
Another thing is maturity, in your child. Some 2 yr olds are different from other 2 yrs olds.
So my advice wait until he is 2 1/2, let him get the feel of being 2. They change so much from the time they turn 1 - 2 and the same from 2-3. All I can say is that with potty training it is about consistency, the child showing signs of being ready, and good communication skills, when you have all of these potty training is a breeze and you will have mastered within a week.
S.H. answers from Lawrence on March 17, 2008
My little boy is strong willed and this presented a problem for potty training, and well, I couldn't "make" him go. After many failed attempts, the summer before he turned 3, I let him run around naked (inside and out-we live in the country). It didn't take long for him to start going potty outside on a bush or a tree. With much praise and no "pushing", he started going on the toilet standing up with his hands leaning against the toilet tank (this was great because then "it" was pointing down the right direction to hit the toilet. I rearly had to clean potty off the floor or wall or running down the outside of the toilet. He basically trained himself just before he was turned 3. I've heard over and over again that boys just take longer than girls in this area and my mother-in-love reminded me that he would not graduate highschool in diapers. So I let it go and let him. Hope this helps!!
L.K. answers from Springfield on March 16, 2008
My daughter likes to be read to. So, I kept two of her favorite books in the bathroom, and only read them when she was sitting on the tolet. This really helped for those times when she didn't want to sit for more than a second. I hope this helps.
Email