12 answers

Need Advice from ,Specifically Illinois Moms, Who Have a 2 Religion Household

Hi ladies,
I am Jewish and my husband is Catholic. We have been together since high school (married for nearly 15 yrs) and have always, and still do, celebrate all of the holidays. I went to hebrew school and he went to catholic school. We are both, obviously not religious, (otherwise we would have converted to the other's religion)but we are spiritual. We both feel that is extremely important to know your history and believe in G-d and to celebrate who you are. Our question is are there any families that go to either a Temple or Church that is open to both religions? Thank you

What can I do next?

More Answers

I would suggest investigating a Unitarian Church which accepts all religions. I am a former Catholic who enjoys going to this type of church now. I have met many Jewish and Catholic members of this church. I mostly joined so my kids can be exposed to different kinds of religions and they can then make up their own minds when they are older. This church does not push a dogma or creed. You basically are encouraged to be your own theologian. Occasionally I go to a Catholic mass (like on Easter) because I sometimes miss the mass ritual. Unitarians are very open minded and accept a person as they are. There are also agnostic, secular humanists and outright atheists who go to this church. The church I go to is in Deerfield. They also offer Buddhist meditation which I like.

J.
single mother of 14mo. old twins

1 mom found this helpful

My home is spiritually eclectic. I was raised Catholic and now tend toward secular humanism. My husband was raised Christian. As several parents noted in previous posts, Unitarian Universalism offers children a chance to learn from many spiritual sources. Most UU congregations offer nursery for infants-three years, then different levels of "Sunday school" (preschool through High School).

Hi there - I am Jewish and my husband is Catholic as well. We actually got married with both a rabbi and a priest who work together in Chicago, respecting both religions. Rabbi Sternfield, who was the co-officiator, is from Chicago Sinai Congregation downtown (in Chicago, near Chicago and State). We have been there many times, and not only do they welcome interfaith couples, but a large minority of their board and other committees/groups within the temple are Catholic or non-Jewish! It was such a welcoming experience for my husband, too. Father Cimarrusti (the priest who co-officiated) was from St. Matthias, a church in the Lincoln Square area. I am not sure about the church services there (i.e., how welcoming they are to both religions), but we received pre-wedding counseling from him, and he was very welcoming as well.

We've been to the very deepest corners of this issue! I was raised Muslim, am culturally still pretty conservative but don't believe in God. My husband is a Christian missionary and theologian.

I've founded a ministry with him, it's a service ministry and gone to all the Bible studies, even led some. When we baptized my daughter (he was Catholic at the time) I knew more of the Bible than anyone else in our classes. It took a LOT of looking, but we finally found a church we both get good things from.

It can be done, but it takes a lot of compromise and willingness to grow and become more like each other. It's worked well for us.
.

Hi... I'm the director of youth ministry at a spiritual church that is open to all religions. We are culturally christian, which means we generally celebrate all the christian holidays, and we teach metaphysical interpretation of the Bible (looking for personal meaning rather than taking it literally). We have several inter-faith families and couples in our congregation. It's Unity Church on the North Shore... www.unityns.org. There are other Unity churches in the area that are similar as well... www.unity.org. Good luck!

Hi,

I was raised Catholic, and my husband comes from a Jewish family. He was raised in the Unitarian Universalist church, and I really like it. We have attended different UU churches, including one in Florida (when we lived there for 5 years) and now one in Illinois. All UU churches are very welcoming to couples and families with different religious beliefs; in fact, many of the couples we have met at our current church were Catholic/Jewish couples who found a home here. We have 2 children, and they are in the RE program, exploring many different religions. You may want to look for one near you. Go to http://www.uua.org/ to check out the religion and find a congregation near you, if you so choose. Good luck!
M.

Call around to churches and temples. If the staff are unwilling or unwelcoming to your inquiry, you know that's somewhere you don't want to be. There's no mark on your forehead (nor his) that identifies your religion as you go into worhsip (except the kippah). Though I'm not Jewish nor Catholic, I think you and your husband should be able to worship with each other without a problem regardless of which Temple or Church you choose.

I am Jewish and my husband was raised Presbyterian. We are members at Temple Sholom, which has a very supportive environment for interfaith families. To complicate matters even further, we are sending our son to Catholic school, though that decision was motivated by educational rather than religious factors. We also celebrate all of the holidays. We'll have to see how it works out. I agree with the poster who said that if you sense judgment from a church or synagogue, you should keep looking.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.