D.S. asks from Springfield, VA on September 16, 2009
My Son Is Suddenly Waking Crying for Mommy in the Middle of the Night
I am hoping someone can share their experience and advice on this topic. My son is 14 months old. At 10 months we resorted to the Ferber Cry It Out method to help Matthew sleep thru the night as we made the mistake of rocking him to sleep from the time he was born. That went well. By the 4th night he was sleeping 12 hours thru the night with minimal fussing when we put him down. Since then he has slept well with no issues. This past week he has gotten up (once at 4 am and yesterday at 1:30 am) crying hysterically for me. I just started staying home with him 3 weeks ago, prior to that my mom was living with us caring for him during the day. I think he is really going thru separation anxiety with me.
It does not feel right to use the cry it out method to put him back down the last two nights (we tried it last week when the same thing happened and it did mot work). I've also read that doing that while going thru separation anxiety could make it worse.
We ended up bringing him into our room.
I don't want to create a new sleep issue - but don't know what else to do.
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Thanks to all of you who offered your advice and shared your experiences. We did stop bringing Matthew into bed with us - decided to try the cry it out by the book again when he woke the next time and inside of 30 minutes he was back to sleep. What we also did was add a nightlight and a "woobie" which happens to be on of my t-shirts with a little of my perfume on it. (It happens to be a favorite t-shirt of his). Thanks again!!
Featured Answers
D.B. answers from Washington DC on September 18, 2009
K.H. answers from Richmond on September 17, 2009
Sorry D., I clicked on the wrong Mommy for advice, I hope you do find some help for this issue. Good Luck
More Answers
T.B. answers from Norfolk on September 17, 2009
This happened to us. may I say...keep your visit into his room Short but Sweet. I made the mistake of rocking her and now every time I go in when she screams I have to rock her...however when my hubbie responds she simply goes back in her bed lays day and gets tucked in. So....I am the easy mark.
just be firm, tell the child everything is fine and that you love them. hug, kiss and get out! do this over and over and they will get the point!
however ....also remember this is just a "season" in your childs life! everything changes with time and they sure won't be shouting for ya when they are 16!
trust me on this one...as we have 2 18 year olds as well!
you are doing great! keep it up!
1 mom found this helpful
M.B. answers from Washington DC on September 16, 2009
B.P. answers from Washington DC on September 17, 2009
I'll agree with some other moms, cry-it-out can be great (worked for us!), but it doesn't mean every time they cry, you leave him. We've found with our kids that sometimes we just need to go in, rub their back, hum, etc. until they're settled (but not totally asleep). Just some reassurance. One word, though, with my son we found that after we settle him down, he cries again as soon as we leave the room. At that point, we wait only a few minutes before heading back in. About 98% of the time only takes one trip. He cries when I leave, but it doesn't last more than 2 minutes and then he's back to sleep!
Good luck!
B.
J.K. answers from Washington DC on September 17, 2009
Hey may have an ear infection or something wrong. I would get him looked at if this is a new behavior.
K.H. answers from Richmond on September 17, 2009
Sorry D., I clicked on the wrong Mommy for advice, I hope you do find some help for this issue. Good Luck
J.D. answers from Washington DC on September 17, 2009
Another thing you can try (if the patting of the back coupled with the "shhhh" while leaving the baby in the crib does not work for you) is to pull a chair up next to his bed and sit there or lie there, pretending to be asleep, until he quiets down. We had some sleep issues a few months back with our then 15 month old after we got back from a vacation (on vaca he insisted on sleeping in bed with us the entire time - ugh! no one slept well). This was a child who slept great from 5 months on after we did Ferber - and it was the chair right up next to the crib for a few nights when we got him that worked for us to get us back on track. Don't get me wrong, he really wanted me to get up out of the chair and pick him up, but I didn't do it and eventually (within 10 minutes) he put his head down, hugged his bear and went to sleep. The next night I moved the chair to its normal position (6 ft away from the crib), then left after 5 minutes and the third night he told me "night night" so I left. This could just be a phase your son is going through, or could be dreams ... either way this too shall pass!
K.H. answers from Richmond on September 16, 2009
parenting books and methods, sounds like fun, problem is,
kids dont read them.. ok, seriously, if the child will sleep through the night only after being rocked to sleep, then try that.. or it may be that your mother had a slightly different way or method to get the child to sleep, call her and ask, it cant hurt.. maybe she read the child a certain book, or played a particular game with him before putting him in bed or it may that the child was put to put to bed with a particular stuffed animal. but once you start putting the child to bed with you every night, then you will have the fun of trying to eventually get him back out of your bed..thus creating a new issue.
K. H.
J.D. answers from Washington DC on September 16, 2009
Oh wow! I feel like I am reading my own post!! I have a 16 month old boy (and his twin sister). He was a great sleeper until TEETHING started at 7 months old...at which point he started waking at night. I made the mistake of taking him out of the crib and rocking him at night when he cried...which eventually led to him refusing to go back in the crib...which then led to me letting him sleep in our bed when he woke at night. So for 5 months (until he turned one), he would wake everynight at some point and come into our bed. This became unmanageable at around 12 months old when he started getting smarter and fighting even going to bed (and taking naps) b/c he just wanted to sleep in bed with us. Soooo...we also did the cry it out method and it worked GREAT! Within 3-4 nights, he was sleeping through the night (and never cried for more than 15 minutes during the process). The sleeping lasted for about 3 months...and then he just recently started waking at night again!? UGH!!! I felt so bad letting him cry it out again....but I did try it...and he cried for much longer than he ever had the first time. And I just couldn't stomach letting him cry for an hour in the middle of the night. So I somehow started this routine of going in right when he starts to cry and laying him back down (without any eye contact or talking), and patting his back for 2-3 minutes. This has worked. He goes back to sleep with only 1-2 minutes of crying after I leave. I wish I didn't have to go in at all....but spending less than 5 minutes to resolve the issue and get him comfortable ended up working better for our family than laying there listening to him cry and cry for an hour. And I have to say that I was very nervous about my patting his back resulting in another long term habit....but he has actually gone back to sleeping through the night on many nights. It is hit or miss when he wakes up now. But when he does, I go in and pat his back for a couple minutes.
Best of luck! I know how stressful the night-time sleeping issues can be.
Email