37 answers

Husband Smoking

My husband has always been a cigarette smoker for as long as I've known him and I've always wanted him to quit. I can hear the accusations now, "you shouldn't marry someone who isn't exactly, perfectly, the person you've always wanted!" But that's simply not the way reality worked out for me. I didn't choose who I fell in love with, and while it's not perfect, we have a great marriage.

Smoking has been a recurring problems. He's not satisfied with being a smoker, and I'm super not satisfied with it. The routine goes like this: he stops smoking for a period of time and I stop smelling it on his breath. Everything is ok for a while, then he gets stressed out and responds by smoking again. I know when he's smoking because you can never really get that smell out of your breath, and so he tattles on himself whenever he kisses me. I don't bring it up for months and months and he never, ever lets me catch him in the act. I never see it, but I know it's going on. And he probably knows that I know it's going on. Finally, I'll get up the nerve to confront him about it. He'll be very sad and quiet, and will not defend himself in any way. We sit there, depressed, wondering how we can make this problem go away for good.

Now, we have our four-month-old son, and the problem is back. My husband is in grad school and working, so the stressors abound. He's been smoking for months now, and it's upsetting to me, because I imagine my son as a teenager or young adult watching his dad die of lung cancer. I know I'm going to lose my husband young because he doesn't take care of himself physically, so my son will be too young when he loses his father. It's not fair to us and it's not fair to himself to not strive for optimal health, but I just don't know what to do. Part of me wants to tell his mother that he's been smoking again and ask her to talk to him, although I don't see as how that could help in any way.

Does anyone have any true success stories with quitting tobacco? Is there any advice for the wife of a smoker who desperately wants her husband to succeed at quitting forever? I know that change comes from within himself, I know that he needs to learn to deal with stress in a good way by himself, and I know that I can't guilt him constantly. I know all that stuff. I know that my input in this situation is next-to-worthless and possibly makes the problem worse instead of better. But I thought I'd ask the wise mothers here for any advice you can give. One thing I'm considering is sending him the message that I know he's smoking again non-verbally. I was thinking of printing a picture of our baby, and on the reverse side putting a cigarette logo and then slipping that in his wallet. That way he doesn't have to have the conversation with me, yet again, he knows how I feel, and he has a powerful reminder of why he shouldn't be doing it. But I don't know...that has the potential to be taken worse than the conversation always goes.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Well, after reading all the responses, I've decided to not do anything. Some think I should talk to him, others say no, and everyone says to approach it with a positive attitude. This I've done the last several times we've talked about it, but he still feels like it's nagging. It's a sensitive issue for him and he can't talk about it with me at all without feeling like it's negative, no matter how I approach it. That's precisely the reason that I haven't said anything to him about it for the last long time it's been going on..whether it's been four months or 12 months, I honestly can't remember. There's no way to say anything to him about it without him feeling sad, upset, nagged, depressed, resentful, whatever, so I am just barred out of this part of his life and there's nothing I can do about it. I just have to leave it alone.

Featured Answers

Sometimes I'd like to take some of the women on this site and bottle them... you know like how you'd love to be able to bottle a child's energy. Ditto Peg & Marda 100%.

I know many many MANY people who quit smoking successfully once they were done with school. I don't know a single undergrad or grad student who has. Midterms roll around, or finals, or a term paper, or orals, or their thesis, or, or, or... and they're smoking again. Some after years of being quit when they go back to school.

7 moms found this helpful

He knows that you want him to quit and he wants to too. He's ashamed of the fact that it's too hard for him to quit. I smoked for 10 years and finally quit because I wanted to bad enough and have never started again.

Sending him messages every few months and trying to guilt him into quitting will not help. For now you need to accept that he smokes and that it is his problem and choice that he has made.

I think it would be healthier for you to ask him not to hid his smoking from you because you can tell any way because it smells when you kiss him. Ask him to deal with cleaning his mouth so you don't have to kiss someone who's mouth smells awful. Hopefully he will decide to quit for good and then you can support him and help him when he has made that decision.

1 mom found this helpful

Since he is in school can he use student medical services to see what kind of low-cost/no-cost options they can offer him? It may take a combo of desire, medication, maybe even therapy to help him change how he deal with stressors in his life.

And since you do have a new baby, he needs to wash his hands, face and change his clothes when he gets home BEFORE he holds the baby. I was just reading about the dangers of 3rd hand smoke, especially to the little ones.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Consider this, C.: You simply can't know for a fact you will lose your husband young. Many smokers do, somehow, live into old age. You can't know for a fact that if he does stop smoking, he won't get killed young by something else. You can know that you have him in your life right now. Worrying about what might happen next week or in 20 years kills this moment you are living right now, because you're not living it – you're off worrying about a future event that may not come.

Your husband has a very difficult addiction. Most smokers have to quit several times before they figure out how to do it for keeps. If he falls back into the habit because of stress, then knowing you're upset with him, his stress increases. Adding his mother's pressure to the situation would only make it worse.

If he quits because you want him to, he's not quitting for his own reasons, so he is less likely to succeed. I can't tell you not to worry, because obviously smoking is not healthy. But if you can stop catastrophizing the situation, and give him space to bring himself to a place of firm decision, you will probably be helping him far more than any emotional pressures you can possibly bring to bear. I'm sure he already knows a couple of good reasons to quit, and your proposed message won't make that any clearer or more loving. It might work better to simply tell him you trust him to quit when he can, and let him know you'll support him in any way that he finds helpful.

People do quit for good. My mom and grandmother both did, but they both tried again and again. They got a little better at it each time. I wish you all well.

9 moms found this helpful

Sometimes I'd like to take some of the women on this site and bottle them... you know like how you'd love to be able to bottle a child's energy. Ditto Peg & Marda 100%.

I know many many MANY people who quit smoking successfully once they were done with school. I don't know a single undergrad or grad student who has. Midterms roll around, or finals, or a term paper, or orals, or their thesis, or, or, or... and they're smoking again. Some after years of being quit when they go back to school.

7 moms found this helpful

I agree with Peg M. 100%. He's the one who has to figure out how to quit for good. Supporting someone means that you accept them as they are. When you believe in them they're stronger in their belief in themselves.

6 moms found this helpful

I have a best friend that had smoked for over 20 years.. Really bad habit. She has tried many times, with some success..

She sat down to figure out how much it was costing her to continue to smoke. She was appalled at the amount.

She finally had the acupuncture along with the smokers gum.
It worked! It still was not totally easy, but she said she was able to kick it. by all of us helping her to stick with her and encourage her.

We provided...Carrot sticks, pretzel sticks, sodas and coffee.. I am so proud of her. She still can get a craving when she is out partying and drinking.. but in Austin, No smoking is allowed in nightclubs or bars.. It helps..

5 moms found this helpful

Tobacco is a tough one. I smoked for over 13 years. I tried to quit multiple times (and did quit during my pregnancies). It was really hard to stay quit because I was surrounded by smokers in the military (you don't get "breaks" in the military unless you smoke) and all of my in-laws smoke (all day, so if I'm not outside with them I don't see them during their visits and I'M the anti-social one!) Finally I got fed up enough to admit that I needed a little help with quitting, so I talked to my doctor and got a prescription for Chantix. It comes with free live support as well, although I didn't need to use that because the Chantix did the one thing I couldn't do on my own. It broke the nicotine addiction so that my will power could come in to play, even during moments of stress. On Chantix you continue to smoke for the first week while the medicine builds in your system and you're supposed to quit on day 8. I quit on day 6 and barely noticed. I just ran out of cigarettes on that day and forgot to buy more. It didn't hit me what had happened until my planned quit date. My doctor recommended that I continue Chantix for 6-9 months as the studies show that those who did had the highest rates of success.

I hope this helped. It's really a very tough addiction to break and it IS an addiction. With your husband it predates his family so he already has a history of smoking after you formed a family together. To me, this makes it harder to use the family as motivation. Please believe that it has nothing to do with his love for you and your son. You can't attach one to the other and in doing so you may be adding another stressor that's making it harder for him to quit....guilt. Talk to him about going on Chantix if he's serious about quitting and be supportive.

5 moms found this helpful

Yep I agree with everyone here so far. I know how you feel and I wish my husband would quit too. I worry about his health and his dying young. But he will quit when he is ready. I was a smoker too, and it is hard.

Trust me that your husband DOES know you feel, he does know that you know he is smoking again, and he has a powerful reminder of why he should quit everytime he looks at the two of you. You don't need any non-verbal gesture to show him all that.

I agree that if you try your hardest NOT to make him feel guilty, he will have more success when it is time. Don't have a conversation where you end up depressed and guilty feeling. Next time you have a reason to talk about it, I suggest what the Peg said. No pressure, let him know you will support him when he is ready. Maybe tell him about the Chantix- I know a ton of people that has helped. My mom had smoked for about 35 years when she quit with Chantix. You could mention it and say that you have heard of this prescription, and when he is ready he should talk to his doctor about it as a possibility. Tell him to let you know what it is he needs from you. Like should you nag, should you not nag, does he want pictures of lungs pasted on the bathroom mirror, etc. Whatever he feels will help him the most. And then drop it and let him come to you.

Good luck, I hope he is able to quit for good at some point. The others are right, it has nothing to do with you, he loves you and your son, and he wants to be around for you guys forever. He just has to do this when he is ready.

4 moms found this helpful

Well this is coming from an ex smoker. I smoked for 21 years and at the end was smoking 21/2 to 3 packs a day! I quit on my wedding night 14 years ago and haven't put one in my mouth since then.
Everyone smokes for different reasons. Mine was that I some how thought it relaxed me, helped me when I was stressed. My boyfriend did not smoke but loved me enough to still marry me even with my stinky, unhealthy habit. Just like you did, thank God.
He never complained but on our wedding night I was in another room smoking a cigarette while he waited for me in the bedroom. He asked what I was doing. After I answered and a long pause of silenced he sadly replied that he was alone waiting on his bride because she needed a smoke. Ouch. Well after sitting there for a while I realized my need for smoking was a big fat lie. It didn't help me at all with anything. It was killing my health and costs me alot of money. I decided to quit. Thought about taking another puff and changed my mind and crushed it up in the ashtray. Grabbed all my cigarette stuff, including lighters and put them in a trash bag and never looked back.
Bottom line, he has to be the one that wants to stop. He has to be the one that realizes the lie. Yes you can care and share your concerns but your nagging will not help him see that. Now it's more than a nasty habit for him. Now it's kind of a dirty little secret between you two. Not good. And the reason it's like that is because it's more about you and your reaction/feelings than him wanting to quit.
Yes I did quit and the reason I came to the point of even considering it was because my sweetie said something to me about it but the choice was mine to quit. And the reason I considered it was because even though I knew it affected him, he loved me anyway and would go one loving me. I felt like I was in a safe enough place to even consider it all.
You reminding him of the bad thing he is doing is NOT going to get him to quit.
My suggestion? Well I would apologize for nagging to him for all this time, tell him that you love him no matter what and never bring it up again. Give him the real space he needs to make his own decision.
The smallest of hope is still hope.
Best Regards to you,
C.

4 moms found this helpful

My advice to you, is to let him be a grown adult and make his own decisions in life. You knew he was a smoker when you married him, so it's not fair to him, for you to be quietly scolding him for smoking. You also knew he smoked when you chose to make a baby with someone whom you think is going to die young. You say it's not fair to your son, but you agreed to bring him into this world by a man who smokes, didn't you? So, I don't understand why you are so upset? Really, if you are that upset and think he is going to die early, then you probably shouldn't have anymore children with this man. I understand you not wanting him to smoke anymore, but sometimes if we just let a person do what they want, you'll find it's easier for them to quit, since they don't feel like they have to hide it, AND it will be easier for him to talk to you about it. Stop acting like his mother and stop treating him like a child.

4 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.