I.T. asks from Keyport, NJ on October 16, 2007
HELP!!!!! My Son Just Wont Drink Milk!!!!
Hi all!! my son , just turned 2 years old...He loves his milk, he'll drink it from a bottle BUT I can't get him to drink his milk from a sippy cup, He'll drink everything else from one , but not milk, this is day 2 and no milk!!! my husband said to just give him his bottle, but I think if I give in and give him his bottle, he'll never adjust to drinking milk from a sippy cup. What do I do?
any advise or help is desperately needed....thanx I.
So What Happened?™
First off, I want to thank every single one of you who responded.....We started on Monday Oct. 15 cold turkey and on Wednesday my son was drinking out of the sippy cup like a pro....I tried putting chocolate in the milk and that seemed to work....now he is drinking plan milk...I also ordered the bear cup w/ the flex straw, can't wait to get it...thanx again to all, for the advise.....I.
Featured Answers
J.I. answers from New York on October 20, 2007
I have a two year old, also had the same problem. I drink a lot of tea. Especially right before bed, he started to want some, so I make him a little chamomile tea, mix it with a lot of milk and tell him that you drink tea from a cup like mommy. He still demands a bottle every few days, but he's now able to drink milk from a sippy cup too.
N.C. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
I would think to only give him milk from the sippy cup...no juice or water. If he see that is the only ting he can drink...he will drink it. It soulds a bit creul but some kids have to be pushed or they stay stagnant.
If that is too cruel for you then drink from the sippy cup first to let him know that its okay.
Whatever you do DONT give up and give in to giving him the bottle.
More Answers
S.R. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
My son did the same thing. He will not drink milk from a glass, but he did from a bottle. He's 5, and he's healthy. Don't worry, there are plenty of other good sources for calcium. Some that you may want to think about are fortified breads, bunches are made now fortified american cheeses, cereals, juices, even snacks have calcium added. If your son likes yogurt, there are lots of kid style yogurts out there. Personally, my son hates anything creamy, so he does not eat yogurt. You also have to keep this in perspective, as far as his requirements. According to the USDA, the daily requirment for a healthy child your son's age is about 500 milligrams of calcium a day. A grilled cheese sandwich has about 500 to 600, if you use a calcium fortified bread and calcium fortified american cheese. When you are looking at the packages, when it says 30 percent of the daily requirement, it means that there is 300 milligrams of calcium, because daily requirements are listed for adults, not children. Other veggie sources of calcium are broccoli and spinach. Don't ever feed your child calcium supplements. They can lead to digestive problems and kidney problems. Hope this helps, and hope you can relax.
P.M. answers from New York on October 16, 2007
Hi I., I have the same exact thing. My son is 21 months now. When I tried switching from bottle to sippy cup at 14 or 15 months, he just wouldn't drink it at all. He also drinks water from his sippy cup, but milk has no business being in a sippy cup in his mind. I spoke to the pediatrician at that time, and he told me it was OK to give the bottle till 2, because given the choice between milk and cup, milk is the priority. He said after age of 2 they don't need so much milk, so I think as long as he eats cheese, yogurt, and other sources of dairy, milk is no longer necessary after 2. I've been trying to try some different alternatives in order to prepare for taking the bottle away. I don't know the brand, but in Whole Foods they sell these single milk and choc milk packs. They look just like a juice pack with a straw and everything, and has a picture of a cow on it. Anyway, I gave him the choc milk box and he slowly drank the whole thing. So I think as long as you replace the nutrition, it should be OK if he doesn't drink the full 8 oz. I think it's probably better that he gives up the night time bottle anyway, as it'll be one step closer to potty training. Good luck, I'll be going through the same exact thing in 2.5 months.
C.B. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
My daughter did the same thing. Our doctor said not to worry as long as she was eating 2-3 servings of dairy a day. She never stopped eating cheese or yogurt or mac and cheese. She also "eats" the milk in cereal. We also started trying a variety of cups. The ones with the straw worked the best at first. We gave her a milk cup at every meal. She would take a few sips. She's 27 months now. She will drink a whole cup of milk... not all the time... but usually once a day.
Don't stress too much. Keep giving other dairy products. Just keep offering the milk cup. Good luck!
J.I. answers from New York on October 20, 2007
I have a two year old, also had the same problem. I drink a lot of tea. Especially right before bed, he started to want some, so I make him a little chamomile tea, mix it with a lot of milk and tell him that you drink tea from a cup like mommy. He still demands a bottle every few days, but he's now able to drink milk from a sippy cup too.
A.M. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
Try the sippy cups with the straws in them. That is what worked for my daughter. Maybe he can pick out his own special cup at the store that is just for milk. Good luck!
S.N. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
Try letting him pick out his own special big boy cup to put his milk into. My almost 2 yr. daughter decided to give her bottle up on her own and loved her milk. However, the milk went right along with the bottle-i even tried giving her chocolate milk but that didnt work. Sso now she eats gogarts, drinks yogart drinks and eats lots of cheese. If he really wants the milk, he'll wind up drinking it however it's given to him. Good luck.
N.C. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
I would think to only give him milk from the sippy cup...no juice or water. If he see that is the only ting he can drink...he will drink it. It soulds a bit creul but some kids have to be pushed or they stay stagnant.
If that is too cruel for you then drink from the sippy cup first to let him know that its okay.
Whatever you do DONT give up and give in to giving him the bottle.
L.C. answers from New York on October 17, 2007
I have the same problem with my daughter. We stopped her cold turkey off the bottle right before her second birthday. Since then she wont drink milk. I asked the dr and she said sometimes they just stop drinking it when they stop the bottle and to make sure they get plenty of dairy in their diet. I started giving her string cheese and yogurt and such. All I can say is if you find a way to get him to drink milk out of his sippy cup let me know!! LOL I have been doing water and non-sugary fruit juices. She prefers water out of her sippy cups which i guess isnt a bad thing. But I cant get her to drink milk either and now she doesnt even want a bottle. I tried to give it to her one day to see if she would take it and she refused saying "sip cup" so I dunno. Just make sure you supplement his lack of milk intake with something similar.
Email