L.L. asks from Walnut Creek, CA on September 28, 2009
Family Drama - Walnut Creek,CA
My mother and grandmother are living with me because they can’t afford living on their own.
My husband and I have been supporting them for many years now, but they moved in with us only recently. Living conditions in the place they used to live at were not as good as with us. The quality of food is also better here, and I’ve already seen how their health was improving just from moving in together with us.
Bottom line: I know it is better for them to stay with us. Unfortunately, I can’t say the same about myself. I feel inconvenienced, irritated, and unappreciated. I feel like they took over my kitchen and made themselves at home way too comfortably, to the point of depriving me from privacy, convenience, and quality time with my immediate family.
My mother and grandmother are good people with good intentions, but are too hard to live together with. They irritate me so much, most of the time I can’t conceal it. I snap at them occasionally, and every time I snap, it leads to a huge scandal that lasts for days. If my mother feels disrespected she become very upset and angry and can’t let it go for a long time. She cries and makes herself sick. She looks very miserable during our arguments, her blood pressure sky rockets and I’m very afraid she’ll drive herself into a heart attack and it would be my fault. At the same time I feel angry because she has been doing it to me for as long as I can remember myself, and this is just wrong. I don’t want to continue blaming myself for all our arguments because I do believe they are not my fault, and she is the problem. They are both old and have a lot of health issues. I am afraid that after our argument they’ll either die or commit suicide and then I’ll have to live with a horrible feeling of guilt for the rest of my life and be always unhappy.
I know that most parents don’t demand the same from their children what my mother and grandmother demand from me. But they feel entitled to special treatment because when I was little my mother was very sick and suicidal, and grandmother was the one who saved her live, and mine with hers. Because if something happened to my mother when I was little, I could end up in a wrong pass. Bad things happen to poor kids without mothers, and I do appreciate them for raising me relatively normal.
My life with my mother and grandmother was never easy. We were very poor, and life is never sweet when you’re poor. I was beaten by my mother and psychologically tortured and humiliated by my grandmother. All because they had tough lives and unstable psyche. They always meant well, but just couldn’t control themselves and did not know any better. I was always scared that my mother would die, because every time after beating me she was fallen ill. I blamed myself and grandma was blaming me for all the scandals. They were ending by my crying and begging my mother to forgive me. But we were a happy family when I was “behaving”.
Needless to say, that with such childhood and a family history I grew up a little moody and prone to depressions. I read a lot of self help books and learned how to control myself. I am trying to be normal and help my mother and grandmother become normal, but they said only grave will change them.
They want to feel loved and respected. They want me to hug them and kiss them, and show them attention. They want to see more love and respect fro my child. But because of the little annoying things they do every day, I don’t feel like spending a lot of time with them, and I don’t feel like hugging them.
They refuse to accept that now our roles switched and I’m not a helpless little child who must “behave”. In fact, they fully depend on me and should learn how to respect me and be nice to me. When I told them the only way we are going to coexist together is for them to change, they threatened me with disowning me, moving out and becoming homeless and dying on the street.
I’m so confused, I don’t know what to do. I love them very much, but I am so afraid that because of a constant stress I’ll start aging or developing health problems. Living together like this does not make us happy. They refuse to change and be more normal. They have no hobbies except of being together with me and my family.
Sometimes I can’t sleep. I feel unhappy. I argue with them in my dreams. I am afraid they will move out and just die. They are old and helpless and pitiful. Sometimes I do feel like a bad person giving them ultimatums, but at the same time I refuse remaining that little girl who is begging them to forgive her when they are unfair and unreasonable.
What should I do?
2 moms found this helpful
More Answers
T.V. answers from San Francisco on September 28, 2009
Good Morning L.,
Here goes:
*My mother and grandmother are good people
*I was beaten by my mother and psychologically tortured and humiliated by my grandmother.
*I do appreciate them for raising me relatively normal
You are a bundle of nerves and contradictions. I believe it is right that we “honor our father and mother” and help with family when it’s possible. In your situation it is clear that you are unable to do this while your mother and grandmother are under your roof. They must be relocated and soon!
*My husband and I have been supporting them for many years now.
This indicates that you and your husband may have the means to have your mother and grandmother live elsewhere. Do your mother and grandmother have any income such as pensions and/or social security?
*They took over my kitchen
If they are able to do their own food preparation perhaps you could find a one-bedroom apartment, do the grocery shopping (so they have proper nutrition), and check in on them by phone and in person a few times a week. Take them to doctor appointments and have them over for lunch or dinner occasionally and the holidays.
If you are unable to do shopping and appointments, you can pay someone who specializes in eldercare.
If they cannot be on their own, they should be in an assisted living arrangement.
*I snap, She cries
*I feel inconvenienced, irritated, and unappreciated.
*I do believe they are not my fault, and she is the problem
*I am afraid that after our argument they’ll either die or commit suicide
When you relocate your mother and grandmother there will be anger, resentment and tears from everyone for a while. These emotions are not new to you or them and so far no one has committed suicide. I don’t know how old your mom and grandmother are, but the reality is they will probably die before you unless you worry yourself to death over your current situation and not take any action.
When you see your mom and grandmother once and a while, you may feel more like giving them hugs, kisses and other acts of affection and kindness.
I know it is difficult caring for aging parents especially when you feel that you were wronged or mistreated as a child. This has spilled over into your adult life and is very unhealthy. You and your husband are obviously kind and considerate people to have taken on the task of caring for your mom and grandmother and trust me will be blessed for this.
Many of us have people in our lives that we love but don’t like sometimes. When this is the situation, it is best that we love them from a distance.
Please keep us posted and most of all take care of you. You will be in my prayers along with your family.
Blessings……
Hi L.,
This is one of those "Lean not to thine own understanding moments in life."
I have a longer response because I have a similar yet different family circumstance. Still, I need to pray on this one becuse it just hits to close to home.
Additonally, I'm sure you have the thoughts and prayers of many Mama's on our site.
God bless your for honoring your family...it can be really hard, hurtful, frustrating and worse...I will write you agian...tomorrow.
Blessings.....
3 moms found this helpful
M.N. answers from Sacramento on September 29, 2009
Hi L.!
I've read all the others and agree with mst of what they say. What does your husband say about this?
There are good senior apartments that some one is there to help with emergencies all the time. The rent is usually 1/3 of their income. They are government subsidized. There are people who are paid by the government to do "chores" i.e. housework,make meals, most anything they need. Your mother and grandmother would be assigned a certain number of hours a week, and the choreworkers would use those. Usually they want to get double(one hour of work equals two hours). The best ones do this to get paid a little more. That is how it used to work, I'm not sure how it does in this economy.
Have you ever tried calling their bluff? They aren't going to move out on the street and be homeless!Do you really think they will? Sounds like they have it too cushy there. Call their bluff.Turn it right back on them. One thing I was told a long time ago, my parents were abusive also, is that first off they are human beings, secondly they happen to be your parents. You don't have to buy into their drama.You aren't obligated to be their whipping post.They have no respect for you. Don't get pulled into their little games. I wish I could say the right thing to get you out of this, but I don't know what to say. Be strong!
Good luck to you!
1 mom found this helpful
V.W. answers from San Francisco on September 29, 2009
L. - I am not trying to be harsh, but you need to do what is right and healthy (physically and emotionally) for your, your husband and your child. Assuming you can still afford to support Mom and Grandma, find them an apartment very near by and cook for them a few times a week. Visit regularly but at YOUR convenience. They will not change, it is up to you to control how much they affect your daily life. My sympathies for this tough situation. Good Luck
V.
1 mom found this helpful
C.C. answers from Fresno on September 28, 2009
Oh, L.! This is a really tough situation. I think it would help you to talk this over with a counselor (your work or your husband's work may pay for this - a lot of companies have membership in an employee assistance type plan, if your health insurance won't cover it). You may also want to call a social worker with the County health department and see what elder care resources are available.
Even though this living situation is better for your mother and grandmother, it sounds like it's worse for you. Bottom line is, if you are stressed out and unhappy, then the situation needs to change one way or another. If your mother and grandmother don't have the money to live on their own, then there may be some type of assistance programs available that would take the strain off of you. I don't think it's okay for people to expect their grown children to bail them out, when the adults weren't really there for them when they were children. But it's tough, I know in some small way you still feel like you're obligated to help. And now that they're in your house, it will be big drama to move them out again... I feel for you. Good luck!!
1 mom found this helpful
S.M. answers from San Francisco on September 30, 2009
I don't mean to be rude, but it sounds to me like you brought this mess on yourself due to your guilt feelings. Move your relatives into an apartment, and if they need help give it to them --- but DO NOT let them move back into your house and take over your life! Also, start seeing a counselor about your relationship with them, and your feelings of guilt, ASAP.
1 mom found this helpful
A.C. answers from Washington DC on September 29, 2009
First, take a nice deep breath and repeat after me, "my mother and grandmother are responsible for their own happiness".
Second, get some counseling for yourself (and them if you can get them to go).
Third, take a nice deep breath and repeat after me, "my mother and grandmother are responsible for their own happiness".
Fourth, look into assisted living facilities/communities. Not neccesarily nursing homes, but communities that will still give them independence but have someone on call 24/7 should the need arise. Along with this check into what kind of help they might get for it from social security or social services or such.
Fifth, take a nice deep breath and repeat after me, "my mother and grandmother are responsible for their own happiness".
Right now that's the best I can come up with. YOU need peace and not to be manipulated. Your child needs a happy mommy who isn't being manipulated. And your mom and grandma need their own space to be who they are without harming themselves or others.
Good luck with everything and I hope it all works out for you and them.
1 mom found this helpful
M.R. answers from Sacramento on September 29, 2009
L.,
I feel for you. It is obvious in your post that you don't want to repeat the harm and control that your mother and grandmother have over you for your own child. I commend you for changing your ways. I understand that you have guilt, remorse, etc and feel the 'need' to provide for your mother and grandmother, but it is not your responsibility. My husband grew up as an only child, and had similar feelings toward his mother as you do. The 'need' to provide for her, but honestly, this is YOUR life. If they want to live their life the way they have, then that is their problem, not yours. The counselor will tell you the same thing! Assist them in finding an alternate place to live, and restore peace to your way of life for you, your husband and your child. You have your own family now, and it is your responsibility to provide for them. Remember how you were raised, and prevent your child from having those feelings. Seek counseling...it does a world of difference. You create your own happiness, and your mother and grandmother create their own. good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
N.P. answers from Modesto on September 29, 2009
L.,
I am so proud of you! You are trying to NOT remain that precious little girl and are attempting to stand up for yourself...........
I believe THEY said it best....only the grave can change them. Honey, you cannot change anyone. THEY are responsible for THEMSELVES, and as much as you love them, you are NOT responsible for their safety and happiness.
Save yourself........get a good therapist to talk to, and ask them to leave. You do not want to put your family through everything you went through as a little girl.
You are certainly not obligated to pay their way through life! You owe them nothing from the past. In my opinion, you are a strong woman who made her own life different from her past, and that is to be commended. YOU are trying to change the "circle of life".....and they are still stuck there.
It's time for some peace in your life.......they will make the life they CHOOSE to make on their own.
Hang in there, L.....
~N. :O)
1 mom found this helpful
Email