M.W. asks from Louisburg, KS on July 29, 2009
Infant Car Seat Help!!
I am about to have my fourth baby and am going crazy trying to figure out which infant car seat to purchase. I have looked at Chicco, Graco and Baby Trend and can't decide which one is best. I thought I was set on Baby Trend, but went to the store and tried it out and really don't like the puzzle lock system used when getting baby in and out of the seat. Then I looked at Chicco (which is ranked #1 by consumer reports), but was told it doesn't hook in a grocery cart so that make me wonder if it would work in a sit and stand stroller. So I went back to graco (which was the brand of seat in the seat I used for my other three? but really don't like any of the styles they have for boy. Any ideas? I would love to know what you have and why you like it. Also, I noticed the baby trend had a real simple way to change the height of straps as baby grows. Do any other good car seats out there have that?
So What Happened?™
Thanks everyone for your thoughts! I did want to say I wasn't looking for a seat just for it to go into a grocery cart...I wanted one to fit in a sit & stand stroller b/c that is the kind of stroller I will be using. I already have two doubles, but one is a jogger the baby wouldn't fit in yet, and the other is so bulky I wanted a smaller one. Anyway, you all helped me so much and I want to thank you. I just ordered a Chicco Key Fit b/c it is the safest seat out there and after looking at what seemed like a million seats yesterday they were the only patterns I liked for a boy. If I was having a girl I could have bought several I liked!! Thanks again for all your help! Just a couple more weeks and my baby will be using a great seat thanks to all of you.
I did first purchase a graco I found that was a great pattern and a great price. Once I got it home I noticed that the adjustment for the straps was in the back and you would have to loosen it from the back everytime to get the baby in the seat. I couldn't believe it was like that and can't imagine anyone wanting to use it. BTW-my youngest daughter has a Britax Marathon that we absolutely LOVE!!! I had always gone for safe but cheaper for my kids before but after buying that one I will definitely get another Britax for this baby once he is older.
Featured Answers
C.V. answers from Kansas City on July 31, 2009
Last time I researched infant seats I found that the Chicco seats did very well safety rating wise.However my Husband is a carseat tech. at a Fire Dept so I waited until I could talk to him today and get his opinion.He said that the Chicco brand is by far the best.He would more specifically recommend the Chicco Key Fit 30.
K.S. answers from Kansas City on July 30, 2009
I have the Chicco Keyfit 30 and I love it a lot, I had the evenflo with my first child & this chicco is so much better. I do put it on some grocery carts, but some it doesn't fit to well, I'm short so its to hard to see over them. I also have the baby trends snap & go stroller that it sets right into, and I love it, its really smooth. My favorite part of the chicco carseat is the base. It is so easy to install into the car & easy to adjust. The car seat with me first child was so hard to install the base & it always seemed like the base was loose, with the chicco one I can actaully install it & get it really tight, I love it!
More Answers
K.S. answers from Kansas City on July 30, 2009
I have the Chicco Keyfit 30 and I love it a lot, I had the evenflo with my first child & this chicco is so much better. I do put it on some grocery carts, but some it doesn't fit to well, I'm short so its to hard to see over them. I also have the baby trends snap & go stroller that it sets right into, and I love it, its really smooth. My favorite part of the chicco carseat is the base. It is so easy to install into the car & easy to adjust. The car seat with me first child was so hard to install the base & it always seemed like the base was loose, with the chicco one I can actaully install it & get it really tight, I love it!
C.V. answers from Kansas City on July 31, 2009
Last time I researched infant seats I found that the Chicco seats did very well safety rating wise.However my Husband is a carseat tech. at a Fire Dept so I waited until I could talk to him today and get his opinion.He said that the Chicco brand is by far the best.He would more specifically recommend the Chicco Key Fit 30.
L.H. answers from Columbia on July 29, 2009
Asking for advice from other moms is a great way to start. You can also go to your nearest car seat safety check point, usually a fire station or police station and ask their opinion. They will know which ones they see the most problems with. They also have the ENTIRE list of recalled car seats. (There have been a bunch lately and you don't want to accidentally get one of those.) Some times you can even get a car seat from them at a deep discount. The one we got from the fire station is a Graco and is great, the straps are extra easy to change the height of and also very sturdy. The only drawback is that it is not removable. It is one of the seats that you turn around when they are old enough. The removable seat we had first my son HATED (screamed when ever put in it). It fit on most shopping carts except for Walmart's, which I went alot. A lot of stores still have the carts with baby seat on them. You can always cover them with a blanket if you are worried about how clean they are. If you are worried about the car seat you are getting fitting on you stroller, I would look for one that is the same brand as the stroller. Most car seats are interchangeable with the same brand of stroller.
S.T. answers from St. Louis on July 29, 2009
We had a Chicco, and liked it. I felt it was on the heavy side though. It fit into some carts, but not all. I tried not to do that too much anyway. I've heard it is very unsafe for baby. Try a sling or baby carrier when shopping. Good luck!
J.T. answers from St. Louis on July 30, 2009
I vote for the Graco Snugride (not the Graco Safeseat). The Graco Safeseat did not test as well in crash testing as the Graco Snugride did. Plus the Snugride did well in side impact testing & only one other brand of seat passed that test in 2007! (Side impact testing is not required.)
The Snugride is easy to use & clean. As for rear-facing, I would rear face as long as you can. It really IS much safer.
Considering the #1 cause of death for children are car accidents, I'd get the safest out there. You can get a convertable carseat when baby gets older & just keep it rear facing as long as you can. Sunshine kids Radian 80 can rear face up to 35 lbs. (It might be up to 40 lbs now since they re-tested it.)
I HTH!
J.
K.C. answers from Wichita on July 31, 2009
Get one with a 5 point harness. They are safer!
God bless!
R.P. answers from Wichita on July 30, 2009
I have the Chicco Keyfit 30 and I put it on grocery carts without any issues. Its also side impact tested and had the best reviews so I got it. I love it. I have a baby trend stroller that is sets right into, cost me 59 or 69dollars, as apposed to the chicco strollers for a couple of hundred bucks. They work great together, easy to get in and out of the car with the base, definitely feel it was worth the money.
H.L. answers from Kansas City on July 30, 2009
I went with the Graco snugride. It is super easy to get in and out of the car, snaps in shopping carts very easily, and has the adjustable straps you are looking for. In fact, I just moved the straps on ours up to the upper slots last night. It was incredibly easy. I think they redesigned it in the past year, so you may want to take a look compared to what you have had in the past. They do have different patterns at different stores, so check online at multiple places- Target, Babies R Us, and Walmart.
Email