Hi ladies...
Can anyone recommend pencil eyeliner that they really like that actually stays on? I have tried many and nothing seems to work. I usually put the eyeliner on my tear line so maybe that's why I'm having a hard time finding a good one. I have MAC's Kohl line and it glides well but smears after a few hours. I also have the liquid one from Laura Mercier but it just takes long to put on. I just need a pencil that works. Thanks so much for reading this!
I would recommend putting the eyeliner just below that tear line. It's actually dangerous to put it on there. I LOVE Origin's eyeliner and it's less chemical as far as make up goes. Try them. :)
HI Annie
put the eyeliner where your lower eyelashes are and it will stay on all day and any pencil will work
I use cover girl
good luck Danielle mother of 4
I personally love the Benefit eyeliner, its a little pricy but seems to work the best and stays on for a long time.
Hi there,
I am a mother of 2 and also having a busy life. As I've been working 2 jobs, I've been looking for make-up to get all thru the day & night. I've tried so many brands and I discovered Maybelline unstoppable eyeliner. I got it from from Walgreens. I swear, I have to take it out after I got home.
Try it, it works for me.
I really like the eye-liner Arbonne offers. I have always had a problem with eyeliners running and smearing, but not anymore.
Rhonda
https://www.arbonne.com/shop_online/showcatalog.asp?category=26
Hi Annie,
I've also run into the same problem, I've tried dozens...
The latest one that has worked out pretty well for me is the line from MaryKay, so if you know anyone from MaryKay, try to get a catalog, there's a pretty good selection of colors.
It's the one line that I can wear all day, and not worry too much about smudging off.
Good luck!
ok I have tried them all, high end to low end, but no kidding, my favorite is Avon's Glimmer sticks. They go on so well and last all day! I love them. Best of all you can get them from like $2.99 So I stock up when my avon lady tells me they are on sale. My favorite color is Cosmic Brown, it is dark enough without being black. They make great lipliners too, my fav on that is Simply Spice, it is a neutral and works under any lip stick or gloss I have tried.
Hi Annie,
I have tried many eye lines myself and have always gone back to Clinique. Although recently I have been using Almay (purple because I have brown eyes) but it runs by day end, I just need to get my little one up to taking trips and we can go to Sephora! Happy hunting.
Holley
Hi Annie,
I love my Bobbie Brown eyepencils. I have a brown and a grey and they both work great and stay on well for me.
You might try one of them when you are out shopping and see if you like it before committing to it since it is a more expensive product.
Bobbie Brown is only in the nicer department stores too so not as easily available although I know you can oder their products online from Nordstrom.com.
Have a great day and happy makeuping.
Nancy
I have used the Clinique eyeliner for a long time now. It stays on really well and doesn't bleed at all.
Hi Annie,
I'm an Arbonne independent consultant, a 28-year-old company that distributes botanically-based, vegan-certified skin care, color cosmetics and nutrition products. Arbonne came out with a new eyeliner, one that is self-sharpening in April that is made with botanicals and enriched with vitamins A, C & E. I've had great feedback on the eyeliner and staying-ability and I can testify that it lasts a long time. I welcome you to try it for 50% off and Arbonne gives you a 45-day return policy. Check out www.naomi.myarbonne.com. The 50% offer is only good if ordered through me.
Naomi Shimizu
Arbonne Independent Consultant 15511496
[email protected]
415.297.6335
Clarins makes a fantastic eyeliner that goes on very creamy and smooth but is waterproof. I love it. You can buy it at Sephora.
I have used good old Cover Girl for the last 15 years and am always satisfied with it. I do use other brands but this is my standard for every day. An added bonus is the price for sure!!
Good luck!
Annie,
I have also had problems with eye liner because I wear hard contact lenses and my eyes are so sensitive, so I have tried just about everything out there. I can't wear liquid because it irritates my eyes too much. I like to wear either black or brown & on my tear line & inner lids but sometimes I wear it outside as well. The ones that have worked well for me are the MAC pencil (regular line) and the Estee Lauder Pencil Duo line (comes in a blue plastic roll-up which I love so you don't have to sharpen and black stayes on me all day.
If you find something other than these two, please let me know. Have a Great Day!
Hello,
I also had this problem and I bought a cheap one at walmart thought what the heck couldn't be an worse then the more expensive ones. marykate and ashley brand. Its a turn up kind so you don't have to sharpen it. It has worked for me. Good luck.
Lori
Hi Annie - I've used Revlon's colorstay eyeliner forever and it has never smeared on me.
Hi,
Have you tried The Body Shop at Home?
Here is my website: www.thebodyshopathome.com/web/cflesher.
It is body shop products for busy Moms like you that don't have time to get to the mall. Let me know what you would like to sample.
Thanks,
Cynthia
I use Mary Kay. I know a lot of people turn thier nose up to Mary Kay and I did too, but I have found this to be a great product.
Hope this helps.
Kathryn J
Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliners are great. They glide on really smooth and you can smudge them for about 30 seconds before they dry and become water proof. They come in great colors too!