Photo by: Ashley

Motherless Mothering

Photo by: Ashley

I sink down into the glider in my daughter’s nursery. She’s heavy in my arms, panting softly into my shoulder after a crying spell. I rock back and forth, rubbing her back and whispering comforting words into her ear. All around the room are old, black and white photographs of my mother and as I rock my Veronica I look at each one, taking it in before moving on to the next one.

My mother died when I was eighteen and now she’s been gone almost half my life. Before getting pregnant and having a baby I’d gotten pretty good at being a motherless daughter. I’d grown long used to having to mother myself, going through the motions of graduating college, moving across the country, meeting my husband and getting married, all without the comforting guidance of my mother. It makes for a certain kind of woman, I think. Being a motherless daughter creates a fierce sense of independence, a desire to show the world that you can do it all on your own… and most of the time you can.

But what I wasn’t prepared for was being a motherless mother. From the moment I found out that I was pregnant I found myself missing my mother more than I had in a decade. I suddenly wanted to know all about her experience of conceiving me. Was it easy or hard? Was she surprised or scared when she found out she was pregnant? What were those nine months like? Did her feet swell and did her water break? How long was her labor? What were the names she had chosen for me if I’d been a boy?

As I sat surrounded by women at the baby shower my mother-in-law threw for me, I couldn’t help but take a moment to look around the room, wondering what it would have been like to have my mother by my side. And in my final weeks of pregnancy as I sat alone in the empty nursery, my swelling belly protruding out before me, I closed my eyes and tried to imagine my mother there with me, patiently waiting out my due date.

What kind of mother would I be without my own mother there to guide me through it all? A reader recently inquired as to whether anyone else has recently lost their mother. She writes about how, even one year later, she is still mourning this loss.

Grief is a life-long process. It ebbs and flows and resurfaces with various life events. You can think you’ve moved on from a loss, only to view it from a completely new angle decades later. Those who touch our lives deeply never really go away. I read a study recently that showed that women who were cared for in a loving manner replicate the same methods of nurturing that their mother’s enacted with them. In essence, new mothers will hold their babies in the same way their mothers held them, an experience that creates deep sense memories for us. As I sit in the nursery, rocking back and forth and rubbing my daughter’s back, I am comforted by the idea that even if my mother isn’t here to show me how to do these things, in a way she already has.

Claire Bidwell Smith writes the award-winning blog Life in Chicago.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

49 Comments

Claire,
That was a beautiful post and I can relate in every way. I too am a motherless mother. I lost my mom when I was 9 years old and I'm 34 now, but I still remember how she cared for me, her loving touch, the way she would sing me to sleep, and the songs she would sing. I now have a 2 year old daughter and find myself singing the same songs and softly rubbing her forehead like my mom used to do to me...

See entire comment

It is comforting to know that there are soo many women like me out there. Almost same story as those who have shared. Lost my mom 10 years ago. She was only 44 and I only 19. We were just starting to have that mother daughter friendship. Getting passed the "my mom won't let me do anything" phase. It all happend so fast and was never in reality that I could lose her. She had breast cancer and within 2 months she was gone...

See entire comment

To echo everyone else, your story struck a chord in me. My mom passed away when I was 21 (on Mother's Day of all days), and if I thought being a motherless daughter (very helpful book, BTW) was hard, being a motherless mother is no picnic. It hurts me that my husband and son never got the opportunity to meet and get to know my mom. And I hate that I cannot call and ask her advice or tell her funny things about my day anymore. I do try to remember what she taught me, to pass on to my baby...

See entire comment

I can sympathise with you, My mother passed earlier in the year that I would be married. She was not able to see my accomplishments or any of my children. They have alot of her ways clever, smart , wise and generous. She would love to have known them. They are grown now my youngest is 17.5yrs old...

See entire comment

To the author of this beautiful story...you have so much care and compassion and your child is blessed to have you.

It's somehow comforting to hear other motherless mother's talking about their experiences. My Mom died when I was nine and my step mother never had children of her own. My pregnancy and the last 2 years of being a mother are the best thing that ever happened to me, but there's always this bit of loneliness - especially when I'm dealing with an issue (like potty training) where I could really use a mom's advice. Thanks for posting!

My mother passed away several years ago and I am not yet a mother myself, but I appreciate your perspective and willingness to share this deeply personal experience.

I totally identified with this post, and like others have said it is incredibily beautiful. Losing a mother young, then becoming a mother; it's like grief re-opens because we FINALLY understand where our mothers were coming from when they were alive...

See entire comment

What a touching story; so beautifully written. And all of the posts as well. My heart goes out to all. I am fortunate to have my mother with me as I had my daughter late (40), I fear I will not be around for enough of her life and this just legitimizes that fear. I pray every day that my time here on earth will overlap with hers as much as possible. May God bless you all.

I can relate so very much to what Vanessa said. I never received a "tool box" from my mom. My "mom" is still alive. What I got from her was a lot of rage and her emotional illness. I brought myself up. I have been a woman without a mother since the day I was born. Emptiness, and anger are what I got from her.
My spirit is so strong. I have learned how to nurture my girls. Grown into a mother bear protecting them forever.
Over the years I am releasing some of my wound...

See entire comment

I can really relate to Claire,but wouldn't be able to write it as well.My mom committed suicide on my 16th birthday,and I am now 36.My father died in a car accident when I was 20.Now that I have children,3 beautiful ones..I really miss them in a new way.I keep it to myself,not even my husband can relate or talks to me about it.I just think that hopefully they can see me parenting and hope I don't disapoint them too much.

Thankyou so much for writing what I have been feeling all these years but could not put into words. You are my mouth. I lost my mother when I was 18 yrs old to cancer.I am now 34. I feel guilty that sometimes I forget some of the memories that I have of her. Thankyou from my heart.

I can really relate to your story. I, too, lost my mother, my best friend, at the age of 25. My son was six months old at the time. I am now a grandmother myself and there have been so many times when I greatly needed her in my life. I have no siblings and lost one child to an ectopic pregnancy. I thank you for sharing your story because for so many years I have felt not only her loss but that nobody else could understand what I went through and have felt so alone...

See entire comment

Thank you to everyone for leaving such beautiful comments. I cried when I read them all. Being a motherless daughter and a motherless mother is a unique experience.

We can only benefit from supporting one another.

I just read your post; so touching. My situation is special because I have two mothers. My real mom worked from the time I was 4 months old so I was kept by an older woman that watched other children during the day. She and her husband had no children of their own but all of us she kept we were like hers.
When I was old enough to stay home after school we left her care. I still got my mom or dad to take me over to visit through the years...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive

Related Questions

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all