Photo by: NPA

Fear and Loathing at the Moms' Club

by Robin Pittfield
Photo by: NPA

The pages were stacked neatly on the kitchen table, and I regarded them with the same anxiety I would normally reserve for a bikini wax from a beauty student. It was my first moms’ club application.

I had fallen into a routine of counting down the minutes until my husband came home, and, upon his arrival, I would greet him by tossing the baby at him and running off to lock myself in a closet for few quiet minutes. I was pretty sure this wasn’t great for our marriage. I needed another plan, and everywhere I turned, I got the same advice – Mom’s Club.

Resolved, I set out to try Club #1. They were having a Saturday morning book club, and, really, if I couldn’t bond with these ladies over books, I had nothing. I easily spotted the knot of mommies at the appointed café and drew in a deep breath when I noticed something – I was easily ten years older than almost every mom there.

During the course of book club, I dazzled no one with my amazing reading list and thoughtful analysis. Rather, they dazzled me. First, with the history of the moms’ club. Turns out, they had founded this particular club after being booted out of the teen moms’ club. Rather unfairly it seemed, as one mom complained, “Really, I’m only 20!” And second with their solemn attention to the image of the club. They had recently been on a mothers’ night out at Joe’s Crab Shack, and someone had posted the pictures they took down their blouses to the website. The mom in charge gave them all a scolding reminder this was bad form.

I’m not judging young moms at all. In fact, the moms were all very gracious and welcoming. It just wasn’t the right fit for me. I soldiered on.

Next up, Club #2 was having a mothers’ night out at local pottery painting shop. The moms turned out to be roughly my age, but it was clear to me from the get-go these ladies all knew each other very, very well. I stood to the side and pretended to really concentrate on which piece of pottery I wanted to paint, while they greeted each other with compliments and hugs. I finally picked out a plate and spent the rest of the night at the loser table with another mom who just nodded nervously at the coffee cup she was painting. I listened to the other moms giggle and gossip at the table right behind me and really thought I might cry. No one said hello to me until it was time to leave.

At this point, my prospects were dimming and my hopes were dashed, but I decided to give it one last try. Moms’ Club #3 was hosting a playdate at a mall, and I hesitantly packed up my son and went. As I sat taking off our shoes, a woman in her 30s with a son only two months older than mine sat down next to me and smiled. A few more moms came and smiled. Someone broke the ice with, “Did you ever picture yourself doing this for real?” Everyone laughed, but I’m pretty sure I was in tears. But this time it was because – hallelujah! – I had done it. I had found a moms’ club, and…that woman in her 30s? She became my best friend.

Robin is a writer who happens to stay at home with her son.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

42 Comments

I was the only one in my family with a young child, so I too sought out a Mommy Group to make friends for my son and for me. IT WAS AN AWFUL EXPERIENCE!! Just as bad as highschool, cafeteria & highschool. I went through FOUR groups. The first one booted me out without even meeting me or giving me a try BECAUSE I was WORKING mom!! In the end, with Group #4, I made some really great friends. Some moved away to different states, but I will always cherish and love my girls!

I've found that often, when we think another mom or group is being cliquey, they're really just as nervous to meet new people as you are. Being a mom has forced me to become SO outgoing, that I can now have conversations anywhere, with anyone...

See entire comment

I could FEEL your pain in this post. I agree with a previous poster that your article is a good reminder to keep my eye out for new faces and to do everything I can to make them feel welcome. It's been almost 4 years since I was the newbie in a mom's group; I have found a group of moms I am very comfortable with, and I have almost forgotten how hard it was to forge these bonds. This is my third mom's group as well. Hang in there mama...

See entire comment

I had the same experience, 3 Mommy groups and I finally found the right fit with one. One had way too many Mom's who were unfriendly. The 2nd had some nice folks, but I didn't make a connection with anyone. Finally the 3rd group I found a few great connections!

I'm heading to my first MOMS meeting today. I met some of the ladies last week, and I think I might luck out and find a positive experience right off the bat. Thanks for your story, it really made me feel like I'm not alone! :)

This was a really good article and something many SAHM moms struggle with. I think it is a good reminder to those of us looking for the right group to just keep trying. I also think it is a good reminder for those already in established groups to reach out to new members...

See entire comment

The article rang so true. I'm STILL on the hunt. My husband was a SAHD for the first 8mos and I SENT him in search of groups (library time, Gymboree then My Gym, etc)... and he met some wonderful people and fortunately when he went back to work and we became two working parents a couple of those women were still willing to 'go with the flow' and have new experiences - after work...

See entire comment

Being an mom in her late 30's, early 40's has always made it hard for me to find a mom's club where I fit in. I have tried and tried so many and usually bail out because I don't have anything in common. I usually just try to surround myself with friends that I feel comfortable around. However, I have recently found one with a wide range of ages and joined a book club with some amazing women and all I can say is it has really been a lot of fun...

See entire comment

I just think it's sad that some of these groups aren't very welcoming to the newcomers. I'm sure when they first joined they felt the same but they have conveniently forgotten how it felt. So typical! It's like high school!

Looking back I approached 'mom's club' from a different point of view... Somewhere for my kids to play with other kids of their own age for a few hours a week. Actually I joined, through Parks and Recreation, three mom's clubs that met on three different mornings each week. I often skipped the mom's meeting in favor of playing with (allegedly supervising) all the kids.... actually trying to protect my kids (and me) from the running noses in favor of those who looked healthy.....

See entire comment

This could have been written by me, although I'm still struggling to maintain these friendships I've made through the mom's group. I have never really had many close girlfriends. I had no trouble making friends, and haven't had any falling outs with any, but for some reason, it is hard to form close, call at the drop of the hat and know you're not bugging them, friendships. Now, men, on the other hand I've been able to be completely myself around...

See entire comment

Robin, great article! So glad you were my #3! (Thanks for being so open and such a sweet introduction to my journey into the mom's club scene!)

Thanks for sharing this -- I am a new president of a moms club and we are striving to be a welcoming and open group. I hope you don't mind, but I posted your article on our group-news sharing site as a reminder of what people go through on their journey to find connection. Thanks!

I have had the same experiences similar to club 1 & 2. Even the school has their groups of moms that have no place for newbies. I am running out of places to bond with local moms. Maybe someday I'll find my #3.

*sigh* I'm in the midst of this search right now. About to get in the shower so I can go to a mommy froup/breastfeeding support thing. Went one time when Fynn was born. No one asked my name or anything about us. But I can tell you ALL about the two ther women who were there. It's been two months so I'm hoping other moms will come along.
Aside from that I've found a mom's group that seems to meet at Starbucks monthly...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all