I really like Caroline Grace.
I know one boy named Reece, and a character in a book who was a boy named Reece. But of course, there is Reece Witherspoon, and she's a girl.
I am not a fan of Harper. Granted, there is a town near me called Harper and there's not much there. Also, I knew a guy who's last name was Harper. I like the name Megyn, but don't think it goes well with Caroline. And if you really love Caroline, I think you should stick with it.
I know a Coral. Technically Coralann. Kind of like Caroline, but a little different. I think Coral/Coralann goes good with Grace. I also like the name Carmela.
I also love the name Caroline! I don't care for Harper or Reese. Grace is so popular that it is hard for me to vote for it, but I do like it for a middle name.
Both of them break the trend of 2 syllable 1st names and 1 syllable middle names. I would also stay away from anything that ends with the same sound as one of your other daughter's names since they are all different so far. (I like that!)
I really like Charlotte and think it would sound great with your family. Ditto on Harlow - which is close to Harper, but not Harpie. LOL
I LOVE the name Grace...it was on my list for both my daughters (but my husband wasn't too thrilled about it, or I'd have a Grace right now!) Also, I think the name Skye would sound so pretty with Summer!!
Harper and Reese are very masculine sounding to me, I know that is trendy now - gender neutral names, but it doesn't really match with your daughter's names that are definitely feminine. My favorite is Grace/Gracie.
Caroline Grace! You say you love Caroline and can't let go of Grace. Grace as a first name is pretty popular, but I think it goes beautifully as a middle name with Caroline. And I think it sounds great with the other kids' names.
Love Grace or Gracie. Know someone who named their daughter, Macy Grace which I think is so cute. But Caroline Grace is beautiful too. My sister is Grace, her 105 yr old grandmother-in-law is Grace and I just think it's a name that will always be popular and elegant. If I had a daughter, "Grace" would be part of her name.
I love Gracie and Caroline. Amelia and Madeline were also on my list before I found out our last baby was a boy.
I like Amelia Grace (was on my list), Gracie Lynn, and Caroline Grace. Harper does go well with your other names, but for some reason I just don't like it. I think because the only thing I think of is Harper Halliwell from that TV show. Reese is cute but I don't know what the middle name might be (have to hear it with the last name to get one maybe).
I like your name :) We named our daughter Camryn Ruby. Our oldest daughter is Emerson Leigh. I LOVE Harper....but it is our good friends' last name, so we couldn't do that. I only read some of the responses, but I think they are on the right track with Caroline. Beautiful name. Good luck!
My 7-year-old daughter is Reese Elizabeth and we love, love, love it. She's our sixth, also, and there isn't another Reese (boy or girl) at her school, at church, on her soccer team, etc. She likes that her name is different (although it is misspelled Reece quite frequently.) Her school is loaded with Harpers, Pipers, Maddies, Ellies, Carolines and Gracies. In her first grade class, there were even two Grace S's. Very confusing.
Personally, I like that all my kids names are a little uncommon (or at least were when they were little.) Seems like you do, too. Our last name starts with an R, so the alliteration factor really figured into it, too. When I sent her birth announcement out with all the other kids names on it as proud big brothers and sisters, I received a few comments on how nice all their names sounded together. Try saying them out loud (first names only) with your short list names tagged on the end. Worked for me. Reese was the clear winner and it's been a great choice.
Harper Grace sounds pretty. I have 3 but if I could do it again, I would name them after presidents - ( maybe w/different spellings) Lincoln, Carter, Reagan, Kennedy, Monroe, McKinley etc. Whatever you choose, will be wonderful. Good luck.
Caroline Grace is adorable. The old fashioned names are making a comeback, and they are becoming the unusual names. Good luck mama, with your new addition!!!