Single After 7 years...help!

Updated on June 03, 2008
T.K. asks from North Royalton, OH
16 answers

This advice is for my older sister, who is my mentor, listener, and best friend in the whole world! She recently got out of a verbally abusive relationship of 7 years. As long as I can remember, she has always had a boyfriend. She's that type of person; just needs someone.

She had an epiphany about a year ago where she finally realized she lets her relationships consume her and she basically loses herself to her boyfriend; her interests become her boyfriend's interests, etc. After a huge misunderstanding, horrible berating, and lots of crying, the relationship ended.

In the beginning, she was able to handle being single. Her and our younger brother became roommates. So she's not alone all the time. She started hanging out more with our older brother and his wife in their "development" circle. However, she's now having a HORRIBLE time. Now that she's figured out what she wants and needs, she's like, "Ok, now where's my boyfriend?".

I don't want her to go back to her ex, but at the same time, I don't know what to do for her. So I guess I'm basically looking for ideas and ways for to get her own life. Most of her friends are married. So she feels like she has to make plans 2 weeks ahead of time and when they do out, everyone makes it an early night to get back to their husbands. And she hates it! Any thoughts, suggestions?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thanks for all your advice! She's doing better now and keeping herself busy. Although, the subject is a little touchy. Hopefully it'll get easier as the time goes by.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.F.

answers from Cincinnati on

I'm 41 and recently divorced after being married/in a relationship for 10 years so I am speaking from experience. I have kids so that keeps me hoppin' but I also have decided to use any spare minutes I get to work on myself. I have read The Secret and am now reading Quantum Wellness. I also became a Pure Romance consultant in addition to my other job...not just for the money but to help other women but also to help myself. It helps me have set nights to be out with friends, other women, etc. and see that I don't HAVE to have a man to lean on. This has all helped me learn and grow quite a bit. There's my 2 cents...hope it helps...

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Cincinnati on

See if you can help her find a hobby or two that is new to both of you and if she seems to like it/them, find related groups that meet on a regular basis. This might help her find who she is and have a circle of friends that she can be with without feeling like the fifth wheel. (And of course, over time she might find a good someone there too.)

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.M.

answers from Cleveland on

Hi are you folks in the Cleveland area? If so there is an awesome co-ed sports club called Cleveland Plays. www.clevelandplays.com. She could meet some really nice single folks and stay fit playing a sport like softball, co-ed football etc. It was the best organization I ever got involved with after College. They also have happy hours once a month in the flats area. It is a great place to meet up with guys and to make contacts.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.K.

answers from Indianapolis on

There are SEVERAL books out there that she needs to read. One is called SINGLE BUT NOT ALONE. What about finding a singles group at a local church? They normally have plenty of activities and opporAre there any women's groups or groups that meet to do things that she likes...like gardening, ballroom dancing, scrapbooking, etc.? SHE NEEDS to find HERSELF....NOT another boyfriend. Until she does...she'll keep making the same mistakes OVER AND OVER AND OVER. How long does she want to continue? It's up to her. Which is more important......continuing in the same self destructive circles..and YES they are self destructive when you lose yourself and you DONT get that time back) OR working on moving forward?

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.R.

answers from Indianapolis on

If she is involved in a church she should check into the singles club there. Best way to find reasonable single friends with some morals and ethics.
Join the American Legion and get involved in the woman's group there, of check with the VFW and see about joining the woman's group there if she qualifies or the Moose or Lions Clubs which have women's groups.
Join a church circle that meets in the evening.
If she enjoys theater work have her join a little theater group in the area where she can meet a lot of interesting people who share her interests. There are reading clubs she can join at various libraries etc., that meet in the evenings or on weekends if she is off from her job at that time.
She may need therapy. Someone who can explain to her in order to have a really complete relationship with the opposite sex you first have to have a really healthy relationship with yourself.
I will pray for her. I know of several women who just believe they aren't having a complete life unless there is a man involved.
I have been a widow since 2002. About two years ago I thought I needed a man in my life. After finding 3 different men interested in seeing me online I realized after 1 or two dates with each of them I was much better off alone if these men were the best life had to offer me at this time so I quit and learned to like myself.
There are a lot of single women out there who would love to spend some time with an adult, and not bar hopping.
I will pray for her.

1 mom found this helpful

J.C.

answers from Columbus on

T.,

It's hard to see someone you love make some bad choices. Abusive relationships are particularly heart wrenching to witness. And also hard to advise someone who has been your mentor and in the big sister roll. Whatever you advise for your sister may be reasoned but ultimately her actions will be what she chooses.

Be as emotionally supportive as you can. Definitely reassure her she made the right choice to get away from her former mate. Try and stay positive for her that she will find some security being by herself. And that she doesn't need another person to be whole. She's a good enough person on her own. Tell her it's so much more worthwhile not to settle in a relationship. Compromise, sure, but ultimately "Mr. So so" will not do. It has to be Mr. Right.

Suggest some interests outside of her married friends. Maybe even go to some outings with her.

Good luck to you. Your sister is lucky to have you.
J.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.F.

answers from Cincinnati on

I can tell you really care about your sister and want her to be happy. I have a couple of suggestions: look online for singles groups/activities in her area to help her find some single friends and/or a new boyfriend. Also, my husband and I just finished reading a book called How We Love by Milan and Kay Yerkovich (http://www.howwelove.com/) which has revolutionized our marriage(and parenting). I would recommend it to anyone single or married to help improve relationships and just help you understand yourself better.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Indianapolis on

Hi T.,

I guess it depends on how adventurous your sister is.
For instance, I hear a lot of people join Toasmasters to network, inprove their spkeaing and confidence and to meet friends.
Volunteer in things that interest her, church activities, organizations for women, children, advocacy groups, political parties etc.

These are the type of things I'd get into if I were single again. I would not go on online dating. That's my preference, I tried it in the past and was very dissapointed.

There really is stuff out thereif she is open to new experiences :)

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.V.

answers from Cincinnati on

I'm sure that's tough...the older you get, the harder it is to be single. Maybe she could join a running/walking group (often hosted by running shoes stores), take dance classes, or volunteer for a charity? If she is ready to start dating, she could try match.com or eharmony. I met my spouse online, as did three of my best friends (and we're all happy). Good luck to her!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.N.

answers from Columbus on

Okay- first sit down with yoursister and write a list of everything she wants in a man- BE SPECIFIC .... and POSITIVE. Specific down to religious affiliation, race if any of that matters to either of you, bepositive say puts family first instead of isn't a work a holic...... write things like, devoted, caring, kind with words, supportive... instead of not abusive...got it? THat will give her a clear idea of what it is she wants.... them take the list and hide it. Hewill arrive when she is ready for him. the univers will put out an all call for that list and he will arrive, but youahve to be patient.

Then explain to her, that he is out there looking for her too and all she has to do is relax and let him find her. Once you make your list, you really dont comprimise on it and even if she does go back with the jerk, she will know that he sin;t her guy. Then get her a therepist to help her stand on her own. She really needs some professional help to guide her into being more cinfident as a woman and as an individual who has self worth beyond her relataionships.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.H.

answers from Cincinnati on

check out: www.catholic.com/seminars/evert.asp for some relationship advice. What relationships are meant to be like.

God Bless you and your sister.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.S.

answers from Terre Haute on

Does she go to church? Find one that has singles around her age.
ask her friends if they know any great guys with similar interst to hers.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.M.

answers from Indianapolis on

I am a writer who has sisters and friends like yours. No matter how intelligent they are, the emotional IQ never seems to reach maturity. So I am going to share a couple of excerpts from my books that you can print out and share:

Can I tell you something? You say you want better, but every time the same guy/girl comes along – whether he is wearing the same pants or shows up in different packaging-- you keep choosing him over and over. Do you want the truth? Can you handle the truth? Or do you want to keep doing what you’ve always done, expecting that the results will be different? Personally I think that when it comes to love,no matter how intelligent, men and women alike go a little bit crazy. The truth is that the moment you let the same one into your life, it becomes about YOU -- not about him/her, who they are, or what they’ve done.
Without any indication that s/he has changed -- because when someone shows you who they are you really should believe them.—you are basing your decisions on a hope that will never be realized. So you want to know if s/he has really changed? If s/he is willing to go the distance in proving that your relationship should really exist? Then do this -- as hard as it will be for YOU to not do what you’ve always done: Do nothing. Let me say it again, do nothing. Don’t be the one to drive miles to see him/her, don’t be the one to initiate the phone calls, and don’t be the one who throws away your list of standards as to how you will be treated from now on as soon as s/he throws you a bone The other important factor: hold up on the sex until you know who you are dealing with. If it isn’t the person that meets your expectations for a long-lasting relationship, then all you are doing is having sex with a stranger, not making love to someone you are in love with. Which brings up the question: are you in love with the person or the idea of who you’d like for him/her to be? That is a real and valid question. I often try to understand how a woman or a man claims love for someone who physically, psychologically or emotionally abuses him/her…but I can’t, especially when there is no remorse, no help sought, no change. Why? Because if you do what has always been expected of you, then s/he knows that you expect nothing of him/her and will fall back into the same rut you just dug yourself out of. If they get upset because you aren’t the same compliant person you’ve always been then you will begin to see that this was nothing more than a new game. If they are willing to do anything to make the relationship work, then you have a chance for the long-term. If it was an issue of character that caused the breach in the relationship, understand that character is hard to change and you will not be the one to change his/hers, no matter what you do. You can't fix it and trying to won't change whatever's happened in your past. Because that's what we really want to do. Fix a parent's abandonment, a sibling rivalry, some past unresolved pain over which we had no control. If it was a habit – drink, drugs, sex, gambling, shopping, et, al – if they haven’t proactively sought outside help that will be in place for the rest of their lives –that is a clear indicator that nothing has changed and you will ultimately get the same results you've always gotten. Know what I believe? Love is just not enough to base a relationship on. An expert in the relationships, Dr. Phil, says that a good relationship is based upon two things: One, it meets the needs of the two people involved and Two, there is a solid, underlying friendship between them. And in true friendship one shows respect -- even when s/he doesn’t agree; both can speak freely about anything, and, most importantly each can TRUST the other with his/her physical and emotional life. Even the Bible speaks of the greater love in this realm.
So…it is all in your power, at the end of the day. You either set the standards for how you are treated, or expect all of the pain, all of the hurt, all of the loss you had in the past. Because, what’s changed? S/he hasn’t and, by the way, neither have you...


SQUARE ONE

Beginning again is hard and for most of us it happens more than once in our lifetime. After a divorce, break-up of a relationship, the untimely death of a partner, even moving to a new city, we have to start over. Perhaps its time to take a hard look at where we are, especially if we don’t want to end up there again. If you are at the end of a relationship or in the middle of a questionable relationship, postpone making any life changing decisions, or initiating any new relationships – at least for a few days while you take a quick read. You may still make the same decisions, but at least you will be armed with other options or more information that would increase the likelihood of success.
When we look in the mirror, we oftentimes do not see what’s really there. What we see is based upon how we view ourselves. We overlook, ignore, or emphasize our physical or mental flaws, depending upon our mental self-image. Or we what we see is based upon how someone else defines us. When we don’t know who we are, when we can’t define the person reflected in the mirror, we leave ourselves open to continually being defined by others. Constantly attempting to fulfill someone else’s perception of who we are is not only exhausting, we are soon lost as individuals. Getting to know oneself can be a painful process. So fasten your mental seat belts, it may be a bumpy ride. The good news is that if you can hang with me through this journey, we may be able to improve the quality of all the relationships we have and set the standards for how the new ones develop.
So how do I/you start the process of taking an honest, nothing-held-back look at me? I do not pretend to have all of the answers, and I am not a psychologist. I can tell you what I have come to know and hope that it will be a motivation to continue the process of self truth. Self-analysis starts with educating oneself. You and I are the primary component in our relationships. Most of us never examine how we really feel about ourselves. We relate that self truth to the negative; when we also need to see what’s right, what’s good about us, inside and out. We often ignore the voice inside of us that sends messages to our consciousness about how we feel about ourselves and the people we interact with. We fear that voice. We're afraid that if we listen to it, we might hear a truth that is unbearable. We will bury truths we do not want to face in our subconscious by any means available. Then we act out those messages that describe our pasts, our unresolved hurts, our losses, our negative self-image in one relationship after the other. We see every experience through the prism of what we expect from others or what we think we don’t deserve for ourselves.
Most of us, especially African-Americans, would benefit from talking to a therapist, but there are three reasons why most of us never will. One reason is the belief or stigma about mental and emotional health. Many believe that mental and emotional illness are synonymous terms (mean the same thing), that these are not diseases but are signs of personal weakness, and that we should be able to solve these problems -- just as we must solve all of our other problems -- or keep them hidden from public view. Some even believe that emotional or mental illness is a sign of a lack of faith in God. Our men speak of staying strong; our women resign themselves to having to struggle through life and bear the pain. And then there is the cost of receiving counseling. If it’s not covered by our health policies, and we do not have the ability to bear the expense then we suffer in silence, paralyzed by the pain. The third and most common reason is that we think that the cure will be more painful than the problem.
Here's an example: Lee has always felt emotionally abandoned since her father left their home when she was a small child. She loved him so, even at age three. When he left, he did little to maintain a real relationship with Lee; in fact he married again and had more children. She never told anyone how she really felt, how much pain and anger she held onto, even into her late twenties and after he died. She wanted to be truly loved, yet she continued to choose relationships with men – each in his own way mirroring her father -- that were either passive aggressive, physically or emotionally abusive, controlling or unavailable, each one increasing her personal pain and anger. And even after discovering who he was, she stayed too long every time, trying to “fix it”, proving that she wouldn’t abandon him the way she had been abandoned, that she really could make her father love her after all...
Look at personal pain and anger. How many of us have a fragile shell surrounding the emotional results of negative relationships? The relationships we have or are in today, actually began in our childhood. How we relate to each other as adults is directly impacted by the relationships we grew up with or without. Have you ever taken a good look at your relationships, or lack thereof, with your family members and seen the similarities between those relationships and your current personal, even business relationships? Our view of love comes from how we grew up experiencing it. If we have never seen it, we don't really know what it is. If we equate love with pain, that is what we expect to receive.
I have come to the conclusion that all of us have some degree of "dysfunctionality" in our lives. This comes from just being human; humans make mistakes; humans are not perfect. Unfortunately, we often become what we do not resolve. We tend to act out or repeat those relationship issues we cannot or will not resolve from our childhood. For example, if we were abandoned as children, emotionally, physically or as a result of death, we tend to abandon others or initiate a breakup, attempting to avoid the pain of the other abandoning us first. Or, we stay too long in bad relationships in an attempt to prove that we won't cause that kind of pain to someone else that has been shown us; we confuse loyalty with love. Ike and Tina Turner are prime examples of this kind of destructive relationship. Or we are determined to win this time. Or we believe that we can “fix it” this time.
A good friend shared this Haitian proverb with me: "Dis moi qui tu frequentes je te dirai que tu es." Meaning: "Who I see you with tells me who you are."' I discussed this proverb with a circle of friends and discovered that they had diverse thoughts about the validity of this statement. Some did not want to be defined by the company they kept, others believed that one should not judge a book by its cover and instead, take the time to really know a person on an individual basis. Conversely, another could point to a real-life example of someone who evolved negatively and accepted the same value system as the person with whom he chose to spend his time. He changed from being open and giving to being manipulative and less than truthful -- not at all dissimilar to the woman he chose to be in a relationship with. This person ultimately lost one of his closest friends in the process.
This is not unusual in our communities. Normally nice kids can become gangbangers overnight just to achieve a sense of belonging. Nice girls will agree to shoplift a pair of socks they can afford to buy, just because their peers dare them to and think that it's cool to try. In the end, we must judge ourselves by our intentions and judge (not condemn) others by their actions. People will ultimately show us who they really are. Where we get into trouble in any relationship is when we choose not to believe them. If our intentions are to develop relationships with others, without allowing the who that they are to define us, then the above saying does not apply. We take both the precautions and responsibility to insure that we do not allow them to lead us into a circumstance in which we are victimized. We choose not to become lost in someone else’s definition of who we should be. If we are driven by our intentions, we learn that aloneness can be temporary and is still the better option to toxic, negative, addictive and/or destructive relationships...

SAY WHEN

Makin’ me crazy.
All this talk of love
Love, love, love.
Gimme some of yo’…
While you let him
One more time
Get away with
Beating you senseless
With his verbal fists.
So many scars
That he has you scared
Of finding out what true
Happiness feels like.
But I love her…
As she maxes your credit cards
and drains your
emotional accounts
before she departs for
wherever… again…to visit
that “friend” who calls
after midnight.
Who told you what love was anyway?
Did you get it out of a magazine
or off a video scene?
Why the hell do you stay
in a place where you
are not wanted
just needed
And not for love
Just for the money
and the power
to control.
It’s getting’ old.
I must be crazy
to think that
real love has nothing
to do with all of the above
and
You are not the loser
If you just leave.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.C.

answers from Dayton on

Hi Therese,
I am not a relationship expert. As a matter of fact, I fit your sister's description when it comes to finding boyfriends, but there is hope! There is a free class called "Love Thinks" which used to be called "How to Avoid Marrying a Jerk." It's great! It will help your sister identify why she chose the wrong guys before and help her figure out who would make a good husband. Tell her to check it out on the web at www.TrustMarriage.com I know the classes are meant for couples, but if they have room they will let singles join in too, or maybe she can talk your brother into going and then they both would learn a lot from it. In addition to great relationship skills, they serve a free meal with it and they have free child care! I'ld even recommend the class to happily married couples because it shows how to create the best bond possible. Check it out!
~N.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.M.

answers from Fort Wayne on

Hello there I myself was in a BAD relationship for 7 yrs. I am SO happy to get out of it and I have been for 13 yrs and I am SO happy now. GREAT hubby and 2 WILD kids lol.. IF she is looking for a B/F my hubby works at GM in Ft Wayne IN and he has a friend he works with looking for a mate /friend. Let me know if you are close by and we will see what we can do for her. He is VERY nice LOVES kids. He LOVES my kids. Avery my daughter sent a dandaline to work with Mike my hubby to give Kent the single guy and Mike said he kept it at his station and put it in his locker so he can see ti all the time.lol Well I hope things work out and OH he like to ride his Harley and has a nice home in country with cats. NICE guy. TTYL

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.R.

answers from Elkhart on

If she really wants to date someone then she needs someone that is compatible. My brother was tired of being single and the bar scene was not working. He tried eharmony.com and it worked. I know you said she is the kind of person who needs to be with someone and I don't see anything wrong with that. Most people want someone to share their life with. With eharmony at least you share interests and you don't have to change who you are. A friend of mine is a photographer and she is doing two weddings this summer of couples who met though eharmony. Maybe there is something to it.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches