Problems with My Soon to Be Mother in Law

Updated on January 22, 2008
K.M. asks from Piedmont, MO
15 answers

I am a mother of 3, 2 sons and one step daughter. I am having problems with my soon to be mother in law and I'm not quite sure how I should deal with it. I'm hoping someone has some good advice cause I really need it. My daughter is 10 and my sons are 4 and 2. My problem is this. My 4 yr. old always wants to go over and spend the night with my mother in law but I am worried because if we even go over to visit he throws a huge fit when it is time to leave. It scares me because I'm not sure how close I should let my kids get to her. She is bipolar and has a lot of mental problems. Some days she is fine but there have been alot of times where all the sudden she will blow up for no reason at all. I don't want my children to be around that but I also don't want to keep them away from there grandma. My other complaint is that for about the past year I have started to notice that she is playing favorites. Of course my 4 yr. old is her pick and it's not fair. My 2 yr. old is getting to the age to where he is starting to notice it. He always asks her if he can stay the night but she will not let him but at the same time she tells my 4 yr. old that he can. It really hurts my feelings because I don't feel there should be any favorites. I haven't talked to her about because quite frankly I am afraid she will blow up at me. I don't know what to do. Should I keep them away completely or what should I do.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

Featured Answers

S.L.

answers from Kansas City on

This crazy lady in Mass. just took her niece and nephew and undressed them and herself and walked herself and them into traffic on a highway and killed them all. She had mental problems they said. Another man in Honolulu just dropped a 2 and a half year old off of a bridge killing him. And an unstable mother just killed all 4 of her children. All these people were mentally unstable and all these killings were in the last week.

This world is crazy and no way will may daughter stay the night at anyone else's house family or no. I won't leave her alone with anyone other than me. I don't even let my own young teen and early 20 year old daughters take her out because I just don't want even the chance that something could happen to her and they are perfectly normal.

Just don't do it and you will never have to look back and wish you had made a better choice. I know that sometimes people have to trust others so they can work. But if it's not needed why do it?

Suzi

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.A.

answers from Lawton on

Talk to your soon to be husband, let him handle his mother. He should know how to explain the problem to her, and how to handle her if she blows up. Be there with him to give him support, but I think it would be best to have someone else keep the kids while ya'll have this talk. Good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.E.

answers from Kansas City on

I would talk to your fiancee. Is she on medication for her disease? If you do decide to let your 4 yr old go, I would not let him go alone! At least the 10 yr old can call home if something is amiss!
Maybe start with short visits and see how it goes.
Good Luck!!!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.C.

answers from Kansas City on

Where is your soon-to-be husband in all of this? Can't he talk to his mom about treating the kids equally?

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.G.

answers from Tulsa on

Bipolar in an adult is h*** o* the kids around them, but I don't think it's good to not let them get close to her. Although, trust me, I know how tempting that is!!! But maybe no overnights until they are older would be a good thing. Is there another adult there, as well, or someone who is consistently monitoring her meds with her? If not, I wouldn't let them stay overnight at all. But if so, maybe wait a little longer.

We told my MIL the truth on that one -- that the ones being left out were getting their feeling hurt. In her case, it was always wanting the oldest/easiest.

When your children are older, it's good to explain their grandma's illness in age-appropriate terms, so that they can start to learn to let her little blow-ups roll off their backs, and not to take her personally.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.L.

answers from Tulsa on

Problems with Mothers in Law can cause problems in your marriage. When you marry the man, you marry his mother. If I had known how much of a pain in the rear my mother in law would be, I would have never married my husband. She has done the exact thing you are speaking about: Playing favorites and telling the kids they can spend the night or go home with her- completelely disregarding my feelings. And never did she ask me privately first. Unfortunatley my husband would always say, "well, she won't be around forever and they do help us out a lot when we need a babysitter."

Now my kids are 9 and 13 and she is definitely winding down. The whole thing was a control issue and not being one to start trouble- I usually let her have her way. I refused to fight with her. On occasions that I knew they were coming over and I didn't want the kids going home with her I would tell my husband that the kids had a prior commitment the next day and could not go home with MawMaw and Pawpaw. I also would tell the kids in advance. Occasionally this did not work.
I would not try to keep them away from her completely because it will backfire. Even if she is a little nuts, she probably still loves them is fine around them. If she starts getting out of hand then the kids will stop wanting to go over there. Trust your kids.

Is she their paternal grandmother? You might reconsider getting married into that family.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.D.

answers from Decatur on

If this were your mother, then you would be the obvious one to speak to her about the favoritism, but since it is your fiance's mother, he should speak to her about it.
A marriage means unity, and sometimes that means unity against one of the grandparents.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.O.

answers from Kansas City on

K.,
I have learned from my own experiece that you must tell her how you feel and what you think is best for your children. I have had to stop my kids grandmother from over stepping her boundries and she had a new respect for me after and I have not had a problem again. If you mother in law blows up at you then you probably should not let your kids stay with her. Your just need to talk to her and you will have your answer. Good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.S.

answers from St. Louis on

What are you fiance's feelings about this? Is your mother diagnosed bi-polar? If so, does she take meds to control the behavior?

My mom has issues. She likes to play favorites. The way I put an end to it was when my kids visited, I visited. When she asked about the kids staying I just said we were doing family things or the kids were at a stage where they weren't sleeping well. With you mother inlaw, just make the decisions without making an announcement. My mom probably resents the fact that I didn't let the kids stay all the time, but deep down - she knew why.

You can't shelter your kids from everything. To not allow your kids to have sleepovers with friends or be under your constant watch isn't going to help! My kids are well adjusted, I think :), and made it through.

Just set rules now, so you don't have this fight with your mother inlaw five years from now.

If she does scream, tell her you see that she is really angry and you'll try to work this out with her when she isn't so upset. If she is truly bi-polar and has other mental issues, later may never come.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.D.

answers from Springfield on

Let's just say if I were in your shoes, my children would only have supervised visits with her. That will partially eliminate the favoritism, but not completely and ease your fears of her mental disease. Is she being treated for it? And being that it's your husband's mother, it's his responsibility to discuss any issues your family has with her.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.P.

answers from Kansas City on

I think the fact that your mother-in-law is bipolar is the first thing you need to deal with. You really don't say that much about your mother-in-law's condition, other than you're afraid that she will yell at you or play favorites with the kids (don't need to be bipolar to do that!). I know some bipolar people who are FINE as long as they are taking their medications, or who CYCLE in and out of their weirdness - long normal periods punctuated by periods of anger and nastiness. It sounds like your mother-in-law either doesn't take medication or takes it sporadically or is a cycler. It would make me very nervous (and I am NOT a nervous mom) to leave my kids with someone who might go off at my kids when I am not there to intercede and protect them. But only you can determine if she has safe cycles or is ALWAYS scary.

If the bipolar problem isn't overwhelming, then moving onto the issue with your 2-year old: The good news is that your soon-to-be mother-in-law obviously has the capacity to be good with kids, and wants to be grandmotherly (at least to your 4 year old).

Is she playing favorites, or does she feel that a two-year old (with diapers, needing to be carried more, harder to feed) would wear her out? My own parents, as they get older, are showing naturally less interest in doing the care-taking, and more interest in playing and spoiling. If it might be the work-load, you could just ask her (or have your fiance ask, since he probably is used to dealing with her), "what age do you think you'd want to let the 2-year old spend the night? Because he sees his brother stay, and really wants to do the same. That way we can tell him "when you're __.""

Good luck and let us know how it goes. When's the wedding?

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.H.

answers from Kansas City on

Oh K.!
We have had this SAME problem. How we've solved it? "Sorry, no overnights!" Period. Tell his mother in law that you are not comfortable with them spending the night anywhere. She might get her feelings hurt (like mine did), but if she truly has your best interests at heart she will buck it up and move on. Stop being afraid she will blow up at you. Who cares? They are your children; it's your job to protect them. Stop feeling guilty and do what's best for your children. That's what i Finally had to do.

Email me privately if you'd like - I could go on and on for days... ____@____.com

just because you are not letting them spend the night does not mean you are cutting her off entirely. you will just do supervised visits.

R.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.P.

answers from Kansas City on

Hi K.. I know your concerns as a mother but I am curious to know how much you know about bipolar? Is your soon to be MIL following her treatment? And just because someone is bipolar does not make them an outsider or not to get mad and have a blowup. I know because I was diagnosed with type II and I am big on staying with my treatment because I know the affects it can have on me and my family if I am off of them but that doesn't mean I never lost my temper. I suggest talking to your mother in law first. Let her know your concerns in a gentle manner, a manner that won't offend her or set her off. I can suggest some really good websites that offer great information for people with family members being treated for bipolar.
With the favorites, you can't control that and don't make an issue because everyone had their favorites-I know because my MIL favorites the granddaughters over her only grandboy. I think if you made a deal out of it it would just make it worse.
Good luck and feel free to email me.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.M.

answers from Enid on

Hello K.,

Grandparent relationships with children are very special.
The information you provided is very interesting.

The Bipolar Disorder issue is very important and you will have to initiate a discussion with your Mother-in-Law and perhaps you can frame it as a legitimate inquiry into her ability to care for your children alone, given her tenuous heath realted issues.

But you need also take into consideration your bias against this woman that is rubbing off on your children.
I presume that this lady is your Husband's Mother and the Children's legitimate Grandmother or will be after your marriage.

There are very big differences in the actions in 2 year olds vs that of 4 year olds. Believe me, as a Grandmother myself, I can appreciate the difference. Four year olds can follow directions, commands and be helpful, while 2 year olds lack this ability. It can be very exhausting for older people to try to keep up with a two year old. Your Mother-in-Law may be waiting for him to attain the age and social skills necessary for her to be able to care for him alone.

You are wary of her because of her health related disability, yet you are failing to be understanding of her health-related disadvantages that may prevent her for caring for more than one of your young children at a time, which also stems from the same illness.

Elders with Bipolar Disorder may exhibit signs of nervousness and intolerance of the quick movements and inexhaustive bursts of energy that two year old's possess.

I just spent an entire week caring for 2 Grandson's ages 2 and 8 (because the youngest Grandson's other Grandmother died in a different State) and let me tell you, I have a husband helping me and we both ended the week needing a week to sleep off our exhaustion.

It was lovely taking care of them both. The 8 year old was very helpful in entertaining the younger child, but their activities had to be constantly supervised because of the age difference. We had to also keep our bathroom doors closed, we already had our house child-proofed (meds put away, no cleaners down low, plugs covered and on and on). Our two year old grandson still managed to open Grandma's Bottled Water when my back was turned and found a black marker inside my antique table and marked it up during the early A.M. hours silently and stealthily while everyone else was asleep.
Grandma was horrified! but I kept my cool, he was just leaving me some artwork! (LOL!). I can imagine if I had Bipolar Disorder how his unwelcomed foray into Furniture Decorating Art 101 might have sent to me stress level number 10!

Another thing that might set someone off is to have to encounter young people that don't seem to exert any control over their children in someone else's house. You didn't give any indication about why your Mother-in-Law might have "blown-up" but most times, something happened to make them blow and with Bipolar Disorder, they will often times be extra vigilant about watching for the recurrance of the unwanted behavior. Otherwise, you are talking about a Tourette's Syndrome type of behavior, wherein she may blurt out loudly, yell or curse.

People suffering from Bipolar Disorder are usually set off by events or actions.

K., please remember that 10 year olds are extremely perceptive. Your daughter can pick up on vibes of hesitation, reluctance, disgust, fright and a whole host of the range of emotions available to man. More than likely, her independence and unwillingness to hang around Grandma anymore than you like to, would naturally keep her from being Grandma's best buddy at this time.

The four year old is incapable of judging Grandma and very likely loves her unconditionally. However, you and she should reassure him that he will get to come visit again. Perhaps Grandma can help walk him to the Car and strap him in. Give him a kiss and tell him that she will see him on Saturday (or whenever you choose). This should minimize the crying episodes and separation anxiety.

If you all are going to be a family, you are going to have to open yourselves to acting like a family. Involve your husband in your concerns about his Mother. There are roles for everyone to fulfill.

I sense that since you have been the primary caretaker for your family that it is a little more difficult for you to now relax and allow others to assume their natural role as extended family members.

It is entirely possible that your Mother-in-Law is not intentionally trying to break up your family unit or to pick favorites. She may have simply grown an affinity to the only choice available to her. She has found someone who loves her unconditionally that she feels capable of caring for overnight, while you are trying to make her feel guilty for not being able to care for the other younger child that may be beyond her caring capabilities at this time.

Did she manage to raise your husband?

To that point, there is overwhelming evidence that suggests that many people inherit Bipolar Disorder and that there is a genetic vulnerability to developing the illness.

So I would suggest that you learn as much as you can about Bipolar Disorder so that you can begin to develop an enhanced understanding of your Mother-in-Laws challenges that will always be with her.

It would be such a shame to consider that your Mother-in-Law may have waited all her life for the joy of seeing her son marry the love of his life and acquire children in the process and that love would then consider wiping her Mother-in-Law out and alienating her from the son and his entire family because of a bias against an illness that she cannot change.

Good Luck!
Angie

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.C.

answers from Kansas City on

The first thing I thought of when you described her playing favorites in regards to spending the night was this: I have a 18-mo & 5-yo. We usually don't leave our 18-mo at our in-laws, but we do the 5-yo, and it's just because my in-laws aren't up to watching the little one. The younger one requires much more "looking after" to make sure she stays out of things she shouldn't get into. The 5-yo can entertain herself safely. Plus, your MIL might be afraid that the 2-yo would get upset sleeping away from home. So if that's the only symptom in regards to playing favorites, that might not be the issue.

If I were you, I'd talk to your fiancee about your worries, just to see if he shares them. If he thinks they're legitimate fears, he may know the best way to adress his mom, or work around it. Just make sure you let him know that you want your kids to know their grandma, but you're worried about these things. My husband & I talk about the shortcomings and strengths of both sets of our parents, and we've come to agreements on how to work around that (for instance, my in-laws go crazy with Christmas gifts-- WAY too much! So we basically tell them 1 or 2 toys and the rest is clothes and books). If you think your fiancee will be offended by you talking about his mom, be sure you approach the subject gently. Don't attack her, but don't just imply or drop hints either-- he needs to know exactly what you're worried about. Try to come to an agreement with him that when it comes to your kids, you both want what is best for them, so neither of you should get defensive when discussing how to raise them. And keep an open mind about what the other person is saying. If he feels that there's nothing to worry about, then agree to do things on a trial basis. Let them stay over there a few times and see how it goes. Look at it again in a few months and see if something needs to change. Sometimes just bringing up your fears will make him notice what you're seeing, even if he didn't see it before.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches